44 resolved, 68% held up.
OpenJul 31, 2026
Between the 49ers' first regular-season game and 2026-11-01, Deebo Samuel runs more pass routes from the slot than from out wide. Method, fixed in advance: alignment splits as published for Samuel over that span, slot routes against wide routes, backfield routes excluded from both sides. Ties resolve as FALSE. The comparison is his own two figures, so no league-wide source is needed to score it.
Resolves by Nov 1, 2026
The piece that made itOne Year, A Ceiling Nobody Will Price, And Two Roster Spots That Do Not ExistOpenSep 4, 2026
The NFL's public league transaction wire at nfl.com/transactions/league carries NO Victor Dimukeje row of any kind, on any of its six tabs (waivers, terminations, reserve-list, signings, trades, other), at any point through the end of 2026-09-11 Pacific time. The take is WRONG if a row naming Victor Dimukeje appears on any tab in that window, whatever its classification string. It is CORRECT if no such row has appeared by then.
Was due Sep 11, 2026. Still ungraded.
OpenSep 6, 2026
The 49ers win 10 or more of their 17 regular-season games in 2026. The stated line is 9.5; 9 wins or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Christian McCaffrey rushes for MORE than 900 yards in the 2026 regular season. Exactly 900 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Christian McCaffrey scores 13 or more total touchdowns (rushing plus receiving) in the 2026 regular season. Twelve or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Mike Evans finishes with FEWER than 900 receiving yards in the 2026 regular season. Exactly 900 or more grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
De'Zhaun Stribling finishes with MORE than 550 receiving yards in the 2026 regular season. Exactly 550 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Brock Purdy throws for MORE than 3,600 passing yards in the 2026 regular season. Exactly 3,600 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Brock Purdy totals 28 or more touchdowns (passing plus rushing) in the 2026 regular season. Twenty-seven or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Kaelon Black finishes with more 2026 regular-season rushing yards than Jordan James. A tie grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
George Kittle finishes with FEWER than 700 receiving yards in the 2026 regular season. Exactly 700 or more grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
Osa Odighizuwa finishes with MORE than 4 sacks in the 2026 regular season, i.e. 4.5 or more. Exactly 4.0 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
The 49ers offense gains MORE than 360 total yards per game across the 2026 regular season (total net yards divided by games played). Exactly 360.0 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
The 49ers offense gains MORE than 5.6 yards per play across the 2026 regular season (total net yards divided by offensive plays). Exactly 5.6 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 6, 2026
The 49ers record MORE than 35 team sacks in the 2026 regular season, i.e. 35.5 or more. Exactly 35.0 or fewer grades this WRONG.
Resolves by Jan 11, 2027
The piece that made itEvery Under Is A Man Coming Off A Lost SeasonOpenSep 10, 2026
The San Francisco 49ers add at least one defensive lineman to their 53-man active roster between September 10 and September 19, 2026 inclusive, Pacific time. Any route counts: a free-agent signing, a promotion from the practice squad, a waiver claim, a trade, or an activation from a reserve list. A STANDARD PRACTICE-SQUAD ELEVATION DOES NOT COUNT, because an elevated player is not signed to the active roster and reverts after the game. The take is WRONG if no defensive lineman is added to the active roster in that window.
Resolves in 8 days, Sep 20, 2026
The piece that made itNobody San Francisco Added Thursday Plays Defensive TackleHeld upJul 27, 2026
Connor Colby is the 49ers' starting left guard in the Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on 2026-09-10. Scored off the official starting lineup for that game: Colby listed at left guard is a hit, any other player listed at left guard is a miss, including if Colby is unavailable through injury.
The piece that made itFour Men At Left Guard, And Two Practices Of EvidenceHeld upJul 29, 2026
Kaelon Black is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 mandatory cut. Scored off the initial 53 only: the practice squad is a miss, a later signing or elevation after the initial roster is a miss, and being placed on injured reserve from the initial 53 counts as a hit.
The piece that made itPearsall's Knee, Two Quarterback Lines, And A Strip-Sack To Open Team DrillsMissedJul 29, 2026
Between July 29, 2026 and the 49ers' Week 1 game on September 10, 2026, San Francisco does not add a defensive end or outside linebacker who has more than 10 career regular-season sacks, by any means: free-agent signing, trade or waiver claim. K.J. Henry and Quinton Bell, reported July 28, do not falsify this and are not counted.
The piece that made itSix Grade Changes, Eight Transactions, And Not One Name Has Crossed The LineMissedJul 30, 2026
Malik Mustapha, not Marques Sigle, lines up at safety alongside Ji'Ayir Brown with the 49ers' first-team defense on the opening defensive snap against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. If Sigle is on the field with the first team on that snap and Mustapha is not, this call is wrong.
The piece that made itThe Safety Battle Everybody Previewed Is Not The One Being HeldHeld upAug 1, 2026
On 2026-09-10, at least three of the wide receivers on San Francisco's active roster are men the 49ers' own roster page lists at age 30 or older. Method, fixed in advance: read 49ers.com/team/players-roster on 2026-09-10, count the players listed at position WR on the active roster, and use the age the club's page states for each. Players on injured reserve, the practice squad or any reserve list do not count.
The piece that made itThe Warning About This Receiver Room Was Published On May 13Held upAug 2, 2026
On or before 2026-08-09, San Francisco signs at least one more defensive lineman or edge rusher who is not on its roster as of 2026-08-02. Method, fixed in advance: read the official transaction log at 49ers.com on 2026-08-09 and count signings at position DL or LB of any player absent from the roster page counted on 2026-08-02. Practice-squad signings do not count, because there is no practice squad until after the August 30 cutdown. A player re-signed after being waived counts.
The piece that made itSan Francisco Has Never Been Over The Roster Limit. The 91st Man Has A Name And An Exemption.Held upAug 5, 2026
Deebo Samuel Sr. is credited with at least one kickoff return for the 49ers in their Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on 2026-09-10. Method, fixed in advance: the kickoff return column of the NFL's official gamebook for that game. Punt returns do not count. A return credited to any other player does not count.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Wrote A Kick-Return Bonus Into Deebo Samuel's ContractMissedAug 5, 2026
KhaDarel Hodge is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced by the club on 2026-08-30, and Ogbo Okoronkwo is not. Both halves must hold. If either name lands the other way, the take is scored wrong.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Signed A Pro Bowl Special Teamer This Morning. He Has Never Returned A Kick.Held upAug 5, 2026
Connor Colby is listed as San Francisco's starting left guard in the official starting lineup of the 49ers' Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on 2026-09-10. If Robert Jones, Carver Willis, Brett Toth or anybody else starts there, the take is scored wrong.
The piece that made itThe Injury List Picked Wednesday's Left GuardHeld upAug 6, 2026
Kion Smith is NOT on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced by the club on 2026-08-30. If he is on that roster, the take is scored wrong. Being waived and re-signed to the practice squad does not count as being on the initial 53; the scoring document is the club's announced initial 53-man roster and nothing else.
The piece that made itThe Roster Was Full, So Kion Smith Cost Colton Dowell His JobHeld upAug 6, 2026
Gracen Halton is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced by the club on 2026-08-30. If he is not on that roster, the take is scored wrong. A practice-squad signing after a waiver does not count.
The piece that made itConnor Colby Rotated With The Backups At Both Guard SpotsHeld upAug 7, 2026
San Francisco signs at least one of Doug Kramer, Joe Michalski or Lecitus Smith to its 90-man roster on or before 2026-08-12. Scored off the club's own transaction log at 49ers.com, with ESPN's 49ers transaction log as the second feed. A practice-squad agreement does not count, because there is no practice squad until after the August 30 cutdown; the claim is a signing to the active 90.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Worked Out Three Centers On A Day They Did Not PracticeHeld upAug 10, 2026
Between 2026-08-11 and 2026-08-29 inclusive, EVERY San Francisco 49ers addition to the 90-man roster is announced together with at least one corresponding subtraction in the same club announcement. Scored off the club's own transaction log at 49ers.com, entry by entry. The take is WRONG if any single dated entry in that window adds one or more players without removing at least one in the same entry. Placements on injured reserve or the physically-unable-to-perform list count as subtractions when they appear in the same entry as a signing, and do NOT count when they appear on their own date. The August 30 cutdown itself is outside the window and does not score.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Signed A Center Off Friday's Tryout Sheet And It Cost Them Nick ZakeljHeld upAug 10, 2026
Robert Jones, not Connor Colby, takes the first offensive snap at left guard for the San Francisco 49ers in their preseason opener against the Tennessee Titans on 2026-08-13. Scored off the official game book's starting offensive lineup, with the first-drive participation reported by the beat as the second source. The take is WRONG if Colby, Carver Willis, Brett Toth or anyone else opens the game at left guard, and it is WRONG if Jones opens the game at any position other than left guard. If San Francisco does not play the game on August 13, the take voids rather than scores.
The piece that made itLeft Guard Is An Open Competition Everywhere Except In The RepsHeld upAug 11, 2026
Demarcus Robinson is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster on 2026-08-30. The take is WRONG if he is waived, released, traded, or placed on any reserve list that removes him from the initial 53, and it is WRONG if he reaches the initial 53 only by way of a practice squad agreement. It is CORRECT only if he is on the active 53 the club submits.
The piece that made itThe 49ers' First Depth Chart Lists Demarcus Robinson As A Starting ReceiverHeld upAug 12, 2026
Corliss Waitman is the San Francisco 49ers' punter in Week 1 of the 2026 regular season. The take is CORRECT if he is on the active roster and is the club's punter for that game. It is WRONG if any other player punts for San Francisco in Week 1, and it is WRONG if Waitman is waived, released, traded, or placed on a reserve list before it.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Ended Their Punter Competition Twenty-Five Days After It StartedHeld upAug 13, 2026
Xavier Thomas takes at least one snap for the San Francisco 49ers against Tennessee on August 13, 2026. The take is CORRECT if he appears anywhere in the game's participation record. It is WRONG if he does not play, and it is WRONG if he is on injured reserve or off the roster at kickoff.
The piece that made itOne Of The Ninety Is Listed Two Different WaysHeld upAug 15, 2026
None of the three defensive backs San Francisco worked out on August 14, 2026, Bryce Hall, Troy Pride Jr. and Corey Mayfield Jr., signs with the 49ers on or before August 20, 2026. The take is CORRECT if the club's transaction log carries no signing of any of the three by the end of August 20. It is WRONG if any one of them is signed in that window, whatever the corresponding move is.
The piece that made itJack Jones And Marques Sigle Were In Uniform Saturday. The 49ers Signed Nobody.MissedAug 16, 2026
Robert Jones lines up at RIGHT guard, not left guard, on San Francisco's first offensive series of the August 20, 2026 preseason game at the Chargers. The take is CORRECT if the game book's starting offensive line has Jones at right guard. It is WRONG if he starts at left guard, if he starts anywhere else on the line, or if he does not appear in the game at all. A game San Francisco plays with no Robert Jones in it scores this Wrong; the risk of that is mine and it is stated here rather than argued afterwards.
The piece that made itDominick Puni Is In Concussion Protocol And The Left Guard Job Is Still Three DeepHeld upAug 17, 2026
Alfred Collins is listed among San Francisco's defensive starters in the official game book for the August 20, 2026 preseason game at the Los Angeles Chargers. The take is CORRECT if the game book's defensive starting lineup contains his name. It is WRONG if it does not, including the case where San Francisco rests him or he does not appear in the game at all. The no-show risk is mine and it is stated here rather than argued afterwards.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Need Alfred Collins Against The Run, And PFF Ranks Him Near The Bottom ThereHeld upAug 18, 2026
Carver Willis is listed as San Francisco's starting LEFT guard in the official game book for the August 20, 2026 preseason game at the Los Angeles Chargers. The take is CORRECT if the game book's starting offensive line has Willis at left guard. It is WRONG if it names Connor Colby, Robert Jones or anybody else there, and WRONG if Willis does not appear in the game at all. The no-show risk is mine and it is stated here rather than argued afterwards.
The piece that made itCarver Willis Took The First-Team Left Guard Reps In El SegundoHeld upAug 19, 2026
Brett Toth is NOT on San Francisco's initial 53-man roster after the August 30, 2026 cutdown. The take is CORRECT if his name is absent from the club's published initial 53, including the cases where he is waived, released, waived/injured, placed on injured reserve, or reaches an injury settlement. It is WRONG if the club's published initial 53 contains his name, whatever his health designation.
The piece that made itEleven Days To The Cutdown And Jake Brendel Still Has No Settled BackupHeld upAug 21, 2026
In San Francisco's Week 1 game against the Rams on September 10, 2026, Jack Jones plays MORE defensive snaps than Nate Hobbs. A player absent from the game book's Playtime Percentage page counts as zero, whether he is inactive, on injured reserve, or no longer on the roster. The take is CORRECT only if Jones's defensive snap count is strictly greater than Hobbs's. It is WRONG if Hobbs's is equal to or greater than Jones's, and that includes the case where both are zero.
The piece that made itJack Jones Broke Up Two Passes At The Chargers. Nate Hobbs Has Not Played A Preseason Snap.Held upAug 22, 2026
In San Francisco's preseason finale at Las Vegas on August 27, 2026, Nick Zakelj plays MORE offensive snaps than Carver Willis. A player absent from the game book's Playtime Percentage page counts as zero, whether he is inactive, injured, or no longer on the roster. The take is CORRECT only if Zakelj's offensive snap count is strictly greater than Willis's. It is WRONG if Willis's is equal to or greater than Zakelj's, and that includes the case where both are zero.
The piece that made itCarver Willis Graded Last Among The 49ers Linemen A Week After Grading First On The TeamMissedAug 22, 2026
Sincere McCormick plays MORE offensive snaps than Jordan James at Las Vegas on August 27. Equal counts grade this WRONG.
The piece that made itBoth Of The 49ers' Outside Cornerbacks Missed The Same PracticeMissedAug 23, 2026
George Kittle takes part in a full-team (11-on-11) practice period on or before the 49ers' preseason finale at Las Vegas on August 27, 2026. Individual drills, walkthroughs, side-field work and conditioning do NOT count. If no named beat report places him in a team period by that date, this grades WRONG.
The piece that made itActivating George Kittle Ended The 49ers' Four-Game Option On HimHeld upAug 23, 2026
George Kittle plays at least one offensive snap in at least one of the 49ers' FIRST FOUR regular-season games of 2026 (the Rams in Melbourne on September 10, then Miami, Arizona and Denver). Zero offensive snaps across all four grades this WRONG.
The piece that made itActivating George Kittle Ended The 49ers' Four-Game Option On HimHeld upAug 23, 2026
Jacob Cowing is on the 49ers' initial 53-man roster announced on August 30, 2026.
The piece that made itEighty-Three Of Jacob Cowing's Eighty-Six Return Yards Came On One PlayMissedAug 23, 2026
Jacob Cowing returns at least one punt in the preseason finale at Las Vegas on August 27, 2026.
The piece that made itEighty-Three Of Jacob Cowing's Eighty-Six Return Yards Came On One PlayMissedAug 24, 2026
Kaelon Black is credited with at least one kickoff return in the 49ers' preseason finale at Las Vegas on August 27, 2026.
The piece that made itJordan James And Kaelon Black Have Eight Preseason Carries Between ThemMissedAug 25, 2026
Deion Jones is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 mandatory cut. Scored off the initial 53 only: a practice squad signing, an injury settlement, a later addition or his absence from the published list all grade this WRONG.
The piece that made itSan Francisco Traded For A Linebacker Five Days Before The CutdownHeld upAug 26, 2026
Nick Martin is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster announced at the August 30, 2026 cutdown. The take is WRONG if he is waived, released, traded, or placed on injured reserve or reserve/PUP before that roster is submitted, and WRONG if his name is absent from it for any other reason.
The piece that made itTwo Men On The 49ers' Injured Reserve Page Do Not Work There AnymoreMissedAug 27, 2026
San Francisco carries EXACTLY TWO quarterbacks on its initial 53-man roster on Sunday, August 30. Three or more quarterbacks on that roster grades this WRONG.
The piece that made itKurtis Rourke Has Three Broken Ribs And Does Not Play TonightHeld upAug 28, 2026
San Francisco does NOT publicly identify a Week 1 starting left guard before the team departs for Australia on September 2, 2026. Public identification means either a 49ers coach naming the starter on the record at a media availability, or the club publishing an official depth chart that lists one man first at left guard. If either happens on or before the end of September 2 Pacific time, this is WRONG. If neither has happened, this is RIGHT.
The piece that made itCarver Willis Graded Last Among The Linemen In The Game He StartedMissedAug 29, 2026
Jalen Stroman is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 cutdown. Scored off the club's announced initial 53-man roster and nothing else. The practice squad is not the 53, and a signing, claim or elevation after the initial roster is announced is not the 53. A player placed on injured reserve FROM the initial 53 counts as having made it, per the Kaelon Black precedent of 2026-07-29.
The piece that made itJalen Stroman Played Every Defensive Snap And More Special Teams Than AnybodyHeld upAug 29, 2026
Nate Hobbs is on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 cutdown. Scored off the club's announced initial 53-man roster and nothing else. The practice squad is not the 53, and a signing, claim or elevation after the initial roster is announced is not the 53. A player placed on injured reserve FROM the initial 53 counts as having made it, per the Kaelon Black precedent of 2026-07-29.
The piece that made itJalen Stroman Played Every Defensive Snap And More Special Teams Than AnybodyMissedAug 29, 2026
Jordan Watkins is NOT on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 cutdown. If his name is on that roster, this is WRONG. Scored off the club's announced initial 53-man roster and nothing else. The practice squad is not the 53, and a signing, claim or elevation after the initial roster is announced is not the 53. A player placed on injured reserve FROM the initial 53 counts as having made it, per the Kaelon Black precedent of 2026-07-29.
The piece that made itJalen Stroman Played Every Defensive Snap And More Special Teams Than AnybodyHeld upAug 29, 2026
Ashtyn Davis is NOT on the San Francisco 49ers' initial 53-man roster as announced at the August 30, 2026 cutdown. If his name is on that roster, this is WRONG. Scored off the club's announced initial 53-man roster and nothing else. The practice squad is not the 53, and a signing, claim or elevation after the initial roster is announced is not the 53. A player placed on injured reserve FROM the initial 53 counts as having made it, per the Kaelon Black precedent of 2026-07-29.
The piece that made itJalen Stroman Played Every Defensive Snap And More Special Teams Than AnybodyHeld upAug 30, 2026
Jalen Stroman is on the San Francisco 49ers' practice squad as the club first publishes it after the August 30, 2026 cutdown. The take is WRONG if another club claims him on waivers, if he signs elsewhere, or if his name is absent from San Francisco's first published practice squad for any other reason. Being on the initial 53 instead would also grade this WRONG. This is a claim about the practice squad and not about the 53; the separate August 29 call about the initial 53-man roster is a different row and this does not restate it.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Released Robert Jones And Traded For A Lineman Seven Minutes LaterMissedAug 30, 2026
Jarrett Patterson plays at least one offensive snap for San Francisco in its Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. The take is WRONG if he plays zero offensive snaps, including the cases where he is inactive, is not on the roster, or appears only on special teams. Special-teams snaps do not count.
The piece that made itThe 49ers Released Robert Jones And Traded For A Lineman Seven Minutes LaterHeld upAug 31, 2026
Jon Weeks is on the San Francisco 49ers' ACTIVE roster, not its practice squad, for the Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. The take is WRONG if he appears in that game as a standard practice-squad elevation rather than as an active-roster player, WRONG if a different long snapper is on the active roster in his place, and WRONG if he is not with the organisation at all. This is a claim about which list he is on, not about whether he plays.
The piece that made itNate Hobbs Made The 53 On Sunday And Went On Injured Reserve On MondayHeld upSep 1, 2026
Jarrett Patterson is NOT San Francisco's starting left guard in its Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. The take is CORRECT if the official game book's lineup card names anybody other than Patterson at left guard, and WRONG if it names Patterson there.
The piece that made itCarver Willis Is The Only Name At Left Guard, And He Is Listed SecondMissedSep 2, 2026
Nick Bosa plays FEWER THAN HALF of San Francisco's defensive snaps in its Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. Scored off the official game book's participation page: his defensive snaps divided by San Francisco's defensive snap total. Under 50 percent is CORRECT. Exactly 50 percent or more is WRONG. If he does not play at all, zero is fewer than half and the take is CORRECT.
The piece that made itNick Bosa Practised For The First Time Since August 3Held upSep 3, 2026
Sam Okuayinonu records ZERO defensive snaps in San Francisco's Week 1 game against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. Scored off the official game book's Playtime Percentage page. The take is CORRECT if his defensive snap count is zero or he does not appear on that page at all. It is WRONG if he records one or more defensive snaps. Special teams snaps do not count either way.
The piece that made itEight Of San Francisco's Nine Defensive Linemen Landed In Melbourne