Home
The Record

Called Shots

Every falsifiable call made on this site, dated the day it was made and graded when reality settles it. Nothing here gets quietly deleted. A call that missed stays up, marked missed, next to the ones that landed.

OpenJul 2, 2026Sharks

Doing both the Trouba signing and the Nurse trade is an overcommitment whose bill lands around 2029, right as the title window opens.

Either move alone was defensible; the blue line genuinely had to be fixed. Wrong if the Sharks extend the core in 2029 and can still add without subtracting. Right if that summer is spent moving Trouba or Nurse to make room. Revisit every offseason through 2029-30.

The piece that made itMike Grier Bought The House
OpenJul 22, 2026Sharks

Collin Graf signs a short bridge deal in August rather than being traded before camp.

A read, not a conviction. He is the last unsigned RFA and the odd man out of an overloaded top nine, which makes him the obvious chip if San Jose adds another veteran defenseman.

The piece that made itNobody Has A Seat For Collin Graf
OpenJul 26, 2026Giants

On the two teenage shortstops the public shops disagree about, the truth sits closer to FanGraphs on Luis Hernandez and closer to MLB Pipeline on Josuar Gonzalez.

The shops are two full years apart on both: FanGraphs has Gonzalez in 2031 and Hernandez in 2032, Pipeline has them in 2029 and 2030. The call splits them rather than picking a side. Gonzalez is a year older, is already at a full-season affiliate, and his limiting factor has been health rather than performance, which is a more fixable risk than whether he can hit. Hernandez has one professional season and it was in the complex, where the attrition FanGraphs prices in is real. Interim marker well before the ETAs resolve: whether Gonzalez holds a full-season level through 2027 while Hernandez needs a second complex-adjacent year.

The piece that made itThe Giants Bought Four Shortstops. Only One Of Them Can Play Shortstop.
MissedJun 30, 2026Sharks

With the cap jumping to $104M, UFA defensemen get bid up and cap-dump absorption trades dry up. Priced Trouba around three years, $17M total.

Scored as a miss on magnitude, which is the honest grade. The direction was emphatically right and the consensus board (two years, $3.5M) was off by an order of magnitude, but Trouba signed four years at $33M. Being less wrong than everyone else is not being right.

The piece that made itGrier pays the minimum tab and guards the window: my July 1 forecast
Held upJun 2, 2026Sharks

Do not re-sign John Klingberg.

Resolved July 1: the Sharks let him walk. The call matched the decision. Whether it was the correct decision on the merits gets graded by Klingberg's 2026-27 season, checked at year end.

Held upMay 19, 2026Sharks

Take Stenberg over Chase Reid at No. 2 overall.

Resolved June 26: San Jose took Stenberg, Reid slid to Seattle at No. 7. Evaluator rankings still have Stenberg clearly ahead a year on. The real test is Stenberg versus Reid over five years, not draft night.