Preseason Analysis

The 49ers Could Not Run And Could Not Stop The Run

San Francisco out-gained Tennessee by 43 yards, held the ball five and a half minutes longer, converted nearly half its third downs, turned it over zero times and scored thirteen points. Everything that went wrong Thursday night happened at the line of scrimmage, in both directions.

SK
Sam KezarAug 15, 20265 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Connor Colby, number 75, in the 49ers white jersey with red numerals and gold pants, walking through a corridor of teammates slapping his hands during player introductions at Levi's Stadium. This is a 2025 game-day photograph and not from Thursday's preseason opener, in which Colby started at right guard.

Two days on, the Tennessee game reads worse in a spreadsheet than it did in the stadium, and it reads worse in a specific way.

San Francisco out-gained the Titans 322 net yards to 279. It held the ball for 32:48 against 27:12. It converted 9 of 19 third downs against Tennessee's 4 of 12. It committed seven penalties for 48 yards, two fewer and nineteen fewer yards than the Titans. It did not turn the ball over, and neither did they.

It lost 19-13, and it scored those thirteen points on 322 yards, which is one point for every 24.8 yards gained.

A preseason result is not evidence of anything and nobody in the building will look at the 19-13 again. The line of scrimmage is a different matter, because that is where a 90-man roster gets sorted into 53, and Thursday it went badly in both directions at once.

The run game, with the denominator printed#

Four running backs carried the ball 23 times for 52 yards. That is 2.3 yards a carry.

The team line of 28 for 84 looks better than that, and it is better than that, because it includes the quarterbacks. Adrian Martinez, No. 4, ran twice for 18. Kurtis Rourke, No. 14, ran three times for 14 before his ribs sent him to a hospital, where X-rays found no break and he was released. Take the quarterback scrambles out and the men whose job is running the football gained 52 yards on 23 attempts.

Taylor's line is the one that stops you. Five carries for minus five yards, and a touchdown, which is a sentence that could only be written about a goal-line back on a night when nothing else worked. He scored. He also lost ground on the majority of his attempts, and 23 carries is a small enough sample that one back going backwards moves the whole number.

Twenty-three carries is not a verdict on anybody. It is barely a quarter of a normal week's work split four ways. What it is, for a club that has to cut roughly 37 men by September 1, is most of the live evidence any of these four will get before the decision, because the second and third preseason games will be split the same way.

The other side of it, which was worse#

Tennessee ran 31 times for 167 yards. That is 5.4 a carry.

San Francisco's backs averaged 2.3 and its defense allowed 5.4, and both halves of that were produced against the other team's backups, in a game where neither side's regulars played meaningful snaps. The Titans gained more than twice as much per rush as the 49ers did while carrying it three more times.

The passing halves ran the other way, and hard. San Francisco threw for 238 yards to Tennessee's 112, on 28 completions in 44 attempts, with no interceptions and no touchdowns. Rourke was 12 of 14 for 101 before he left. Martinez was 16 of 30 for 159 after he came in. A 53 percent completion rate on 30 attempts and an 86 percent rate on 14 are not comparable samples, and the honest version is that the club got eighteen minutes of the quarterback it wanted to see and then two and a half quarters of something else.

Joey Slye kicked four field goals for Tennessee, from 39, 55, 53 and 58 yards. The 58-yarder with 2:23 left decided it. Nine of Tennessee's nineteen points came from a kicker on a night its offense converted a third of its third downs.

What this does and does not say about the offensive line#

The gamebook has the starting five: left tackle Austen Pleasants, No. 62; left guard Robert Jones, No. 65; center Drake Nugent, No. 66; right guard Connor Colby, No. 75; right tackle Brandon Parker, No. 60. Every offensive regular sat, which is why that line exists at all.

Carver Willis, No. 74, the fourth-round rookie out of Washington who came off the concussion protocol on August 10, played at left tackle rather than at the left guard spot where he had been taking second-team reps. Doug Kramer Jr., No. 58, signed on August 10 when the club released Nick Zakelj, played center behind Nugent.

Here is the limit, and it is a real one: the club published no participation report for this game. No official snap counts exist. That means nobody outside the building can say how many snaps any of those men played, in what combinations, or against which of Tennessee's defensive units. Anyone telling you a specific 49ers lineman played a specific number of snaps on Thursday is either inside the building or guessing.

So the line's night has to be read through the team numbers, and the team numbers say two things that do not agree. The protection was good enough for two quarterbacks to complete 28 of 44 with no interceptions and for a passing game to out-produce Tennessee's by 126 yards. The run blocking was not good enough for anybody to gain three yards on the ground.

That matters because the argument this camp has actually been having is about pass protection at left guard. It has been Colby's job, then Jones's job on the only published Saturday alignment, with Willis and Brett Toth behind them and Toth in the concussion protocol since August 8. Thursday did not settle that argument. It suggested the club may be arguing about the wrong half of the position.

The spot nobody has been promoted into#

The 53-man projection has carried an open offensive line spot since August 8, the day Toth's concussion took him off the board. It has been deliberately empty ever since: 52 named men and one hole, rather than a name promoted to make a counter read correctly.

Thursday was the first live football played since that hole opened. It produced 52 rushing yards on 23 carries and did not obviously fill it.

Two preseason games remain, at the Chargers on August 20 and at the Raiders on August 27. The roster is set on September 1.

Correction, 2026-08-17

This piece stated, in two places, that San Francisco's roster is set on September 1, once as the deadline by which the club has to cut roughly 37 men. The NFL's 2026 cutdown deadline is 3 p.m. PT on Sunday, August 30, and waiver claims are awarded at 10 a.m. PT on Monday, August 31. The published date was two days late and fell on the wrong day of the week, which matters to a reader planning around cut day. It does not change the argument, which is that 23 carries is most of the live evidence any of these four backs will get before the decision.

DS


Sources: ESPN box score and team statistics for Tennessee at San Francisco, August 13, 2026, read August 14, and re-checked August 15. Rourke's X-ray result and his release from the hospital via NBC Sports Bay Area and CBS Sports, August 14. Official gamebook starting lineups via the 49ers beat file. Club transaction releases of August 10 for the Kramer signing and the Zakelj release. Jersey numbers verified against the club's published roster.

Filed under 49ers

Latest on the 49ers

The whole beat →
Mike Evans and Dre Greenlaw sit out the first practice at the Air Force Academy
Notebook

Mike Evans and Dre Greenlaw sit out the first practice at the Air Force Academy

Mike Evans (Achilles tendinitis) and Dre Greenlaw (neck) did not practice Wednesday as the 49ers opened Minnesota week at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs. Kyle Shanahan said he hopes Evans can go Thursday and that Greenlaw has a good chance to. Renardo Green, day-to-day after leaving the Dallas game with a back injury, was limited, as were Upton Stout, Khalid Kareem, Siran Neal, Ji'Ayir Brown, Luke Gifford and Mac Jones. Christian McCaffrey and Trent Williams did not practice, listed on the official report as rest days. The practice ran outside at half speed. De'Zhaun Stribling, on injured reserve with an ankle injury, worked on the side, per ESPN's Nick Wagoner. The 49ers (8-1) play the Vikings (7-2) in Mexico City on Sunday at 5:20 p.m. Pacific.

Sam KezarNov 18, 20263 min read
Dallas never punted once it had a first down, and not only in the fourth
Deep Dive

Dallas never punted once it had a first down, and not only in the fourth

San Francisco beat Dallas 46-40 and is 8-1, but the drive chart shows a defense that could stop Dallas only before it gained a first down. Dallas punted twice, both times after three plays, and apart from a kneel-down and the final play every other possession ended in points or Malik Mustapha's fourth-down interception. It converted four of five fourth downs, all four on touchdown drives. Shanahan said the pass rush disappeared in the fourth quarter. The 40 points were 10 more than any opponent had scored on the 49ers this season.

Sam KezarNov 17, 20267 min read
Shanahan calls Renardo Green day-to-day after his back tightened at Dallas
Notebook

Shanahan calls Renardo Green day-to-day after his back tightened at Dallas

Kyle Shanahan said Monday that cornerback Renardo Green is day-to-day after leaving Sunday's 46-40 win at Dallas with a back injury, and that the 49ers will see how he is Wednesday. Green played 53 of 83 defensive snaps before rookie Ephesians Prysock replaced him. Nate Hobbs, whose injured-reserve practice window closes Nov. 25, was not activated for Dallas because Shanahan thought Green and Deommodore Lenoir gave the team its best chance; activating him requires releasing someone from a full 53. Mike Evans, out three straight games with Achilles tendinitis, flies to Colorado Springs Monday night, and Shanahan is not sure yet whether he will practice this week. The 49ers are practicing at the Air Force Academy before facing Minnesota (7-2) in Mexico City on Sunday at 5:20 p.m. Pacific.

Sam KezarNov 16, 20263 min read

Earlier on the 49ers

Robinson and West could return after the bye to a 49ers 53 with no room
49ers Notebook

Robinson and West could return after the bye to a 49ers 53 with no room

Kyle Shanahan named eight 49ers with a chance to return after the bye. Six are already on the 53-man roster. Two, wide receiver Demarcus Robinson and defensive lineman C.J. West, are on injured reserve, and each needs a roster spot that does not exist yet. The club's roster page on Thursday listed 53 active players, 14 on injured reserve, one on PUP and 17 on the practice squad. Of the six players released or waived from the 53 in October, four were defensive linemen, and three of those men are back on the practice squad.

Sam KezarOct 29, 20263 min read
San Francisco Promoted A Fourth Tight End And Worked Out Three More
49ers Roster

San Francisco Promoted A Fourth Tight End And Worked Out Three More

San Francisco promoted tight end Brayden Willis from the practice squad to the active roster on Tuesday morning and signed defensive lineman McKinnley Jackson to the practice squad. The promotion fills the roster spot Alfred Collins vacated on September 10 and puts the active roster back at 53. Hours later the NFL's transaction report showed the club had worked out five players, three of them tight ends. Jake Tonges, who played eight snaps in Melbourne before he was hurt, remains on the active roster with no injury designation and no published imaging result, and the club's Week 2 injury report does not exist yet. Willis has played 23 regular-season games, all with the 49ers, and has no career receptions.

Sam KezarSep 15, 20264 min read
The Safety Battle Everybody Previewed Is Not The One Being Held
Camp Battles

The Safety Battle Everybody Previewed Is Not The One Being Held

Camp Battles, second installment. Nick Wagoner has Ji'Ayir Brown taking all the first-team free safety reps in a contract year, which is not what the preview said would happen. The live competition is beside him, between an incumbent with 22 starts and a fifth-round second-year player, and it has been contested for exactly one practice because Malik Mustapha strained a hamstring on Monday. Everything on the record was recorded in shorts. The pads arrive Friday.

Sam KezarJul 30, 20264 min read