Deep Dive

Dallas never punted once it had a first down, and not only in the fourth

Kyle Shanahan says the defense fell apart in the fourth quarter. Before the fourth, too, Dallas scored every time it moved the chains, except for one fourth-down interception.

SK
Sam KezarNov 17, 20267 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Malik Mustapha, No. 6, in the 49ers' home red jersey and gold pants, set in a crouch before the snap at Levi's Stadium against Denver on Oct. 4, 2026.

Dallas had the ball 12 times on Sunday. Set aside the kneel-down before halftime and the nine-second lateral play that ended the game, and that leaves 10 possessions. Seven ended in points. Two ended in punts. One ended when Malik Mustapha caught a fourth-down throw at his own 10.

Both punts came after three plays and no first down. Once Dallas moved the chains on a possession, San Francisco did not get it off the field without a turnover, in any quarter. The 46-40 score hides that. Kyle Shanahan, on Monday's conference call, described a defense that played three good quarters and then came apart.

The 49ers are 8-1, they gained 9.4 yards a play, and they won. The question the game answered is what kind of defense is underneath that record. On this evidence it is a defense that wins at the start of a drive or not at all.

What Shanahan saw, and what the drive chart adds#

Shanahan's version, from the club's transcript: "I didn't think it was like that for three quarters and I think we kind of fell apart defensively in the fourth quarter, which made it very bad." On the pass rush he was more specific. "I wouldn't have said it was a bad pass rush game by any means if I never watched the fourth quarter," he said. "I thought we had a number of chances to get them off the field. And they stayed on for whatever the reason."

The fourth quarter was the worst of it. Dallas had three possessions there before the final nine seconds and scored a touchdown on each, on drives of 65, 66 and 76 yards.

The first three quarters look better on the scoreboard. They do not look different on the drive chart. Here is every Dallas possession before the fourth quarter that produced a first down:

That is five for five in points or a takeaway, and the takeaway came on a fourth-down gamble. Shanahan said Monday he wants defenders to knock that ball down on fourth down unless there is a return lane. A knockdown would have given San Francisco the ball at its 40. Mustapha caught it at the 10. San Francisco went 90 yards in 12 plays anyway.

So the fourth quarter did not change what kind of stop the 49ers could make. It changed what Dallas did with the ball once the stop failed. Two 52-yard field goals in the first three quarters became three touchdowns in the fourth.

Four fourth downs, four touchdown drives#

Dallas went for it on fourth down five times and converted four. All four conversions came on touchdown drives. Three were fourth-and-1. The fourth was fourth-and-6 from the San Francisco 11 with 3:42 left, and Prescott threw it to Ryan Flournoy for the touchdown that made it 38-32. Nineteen seconds later Christian McCaffrey took a short throw 66 yards, and the two-point try made it 46-32.

A defense that cannot win third down gets one more chance on fourth, and Dallas was 7 of 16 on third down. San Francisco did not win the fourth-down snaps either, except once.

Why the defense was tired#

Shanahan said Sunday night that "it seems like we got gassed." The defense was on the field for 83 snaps by the official game book, against 65 for the offense.

The easy explanation is the 49ers' own offense, which scored on plays of 74, 66 and 70 yards and handed the ball straight back. The game book does not support it. San Francisco had the ball for 31 minutes 47 seconds and Dallas for 28:13. Dallas ran its 76 official plays in less time than San Francisco ran its 62.

Two things made the snap count. Dallas went fast: by the play-by-play it ran 12 snaps without a huddle across its three fourth-quarter touchdown drives, after two in the first three quarters. And San Francisco extended its own work. Five of the defense's 83 snaps were plays that a 49ers penalty erased: the Odighizuwa roughing call, a Bosa offside on the first drive, Deommodore Lenoir's hold that wiped out Mykel Williams's strip-sack, a second Bosa offside on the last drive and Ephesians Prysock's pass interference at the 1.

Bosa jumped three times in all; the third was declined. Counting the kickoff and punt returns that started them, five of Dallas's seven scoring possessions included at least one San Francisco penalty.

The pass rush got home once#

Prescott threw 51 times and was sacked once, by Dre Greenlaw and Williams together, for no loss. The only other sack the 49ers made was the one Lenoir's hold took off the board.

Shanahan said on Monday the rush "disappeared" in the fourth quarter, "mainly our D-Line. A lot of them hold on it way too long." He also said the rush did affect Prescott earlier, and the public charting agrees with him on that much. Pro Football Focus credited Bosa, Keion White and Williams with five pressures apiece, tied for the game high in pressures, 49ers Webzone reported Monday. White led the team with three quarterback hits, by the box score.

Pressure that does not finish shows up exactly where this game shows it. Prescott got the ball out, the drive kept going, and the next stop had to come on fourth down. The 49ers have 16 sacks in nine games, by ESPN's count. Bosa, in his fourth game of the season, has none of them, and Shanahan said Monday he is "not worried about Nick."

The last drive, snap by snap#

The final Dallas touchdown drive is the whole argument in 12 plays. With 1:33 left Dallas had a first down at the San Francisco 28. George Pickens caught a 9-yard throw and was flagged for taunting, and Dallas faced second-and-16 from the 34.

Bosa jumped offside on the next snap, an incompletion. Second-and-11. KaVontae Turpin caught a 10-yard throw. Third-and-1, incomplete. On fourth-and-1, Prescott threw short to Javonte Williams for 4 yards. On the next snap Prysock was flagged for pass interference, 14 yards to the 1. CeeDee Lamb caught the touchdown and Prescott ran in the two-point try.

The defense had Dallas at second-and-16 with a minute and a half left and a 14-point lead. It gave back 5 yards on an offside, a first down on fourth-and-1 and 14 yards on pass interference.

What was true before Sunday and is not now#

Before Dallas, the most any opponent had scored on the 49ers this season was 30, by Arizona in Week 3. They had allowed 156 points in eight games, 19.5 a game. Dallas scored 40.

The corners are the other change. Lenoir and Renardo Green started after a week without a full practice. Green left in the second half with his back and is day-to-day, Shanahan said Monday, with a read on Wednesday. Shanahan said Lenoir "missed some big plays" and that some of Pickens's catches against him were "real impressive plays." Pickens caught 11 of 18 targets for 145 yards and three touchdowns. Asked why he did not activate Nate Hobbs from injured reserve for the game, Shanahan said: "Because we thought those two gave us the best chance to win."

The offense, briefly#

Shanahan was as hard on the offense as on the defense. "I thought we had three big plays that were really good by all our guys," he said, "but I think you take those three plays away and there's a lot of stuff that we could have cleaned up." The three touchdowns of 74, 66 and 70 yards account for 210 of the 584 yards. The other 59 plays gained 374, which is 6.3 a play.

One offensive possession would have ended the game. Up 38-25 with 9:08 left, San Francisco ran Kaelon Black twice for 4 yards and no gain, and Purdy threw incomplete deep for Keenan Allen on third-and-6. The punt return drew a Siran Neal face mask, and Dallas started at its 34.

What would change this#

The argument rests on one game, against an offense that converted three fourth-and-1s. A defense can lose four fourth downs to an aggressive offense and be the same defense it was in October.

The test is Minnesota in Mexico City on Sunday. The Vikings will start Kirk Cousins, Shanahan said, and Cousins quarterbacked Las Vegas against San Francisco a week before Dallas. Las Vegas scored 17. Minnesota has scored 15 points or fewer in four of its nine games.

If Minnesota gets first downs and the 49ers still force punts after them, Dallas was the exception. If Minnesota's drives behave like Dallas's, scoring or turning it over once they get going, then the problem is the defense, and it will not wait for a fourth quarter.

The call: Minnesota scores 24 or more points against San Francisco on Sunday.

Sources: NFL official game book, San Francisco at Dallas, Nov. 15, 2026 (team statistics, time of possession, snap totals); ESPN box score, drive chart and play-by-play (event 401873063); ESPN team schedules and team statistics, 2026 season; Kyle Shanahan postgame, Nov. 15, and conference-call transcript, Nov. 16, via 49ers Webzone; Pro Football Focus pressure figures as published by 49ers Webzone, Nov. 16.

Filed under 49ers

More on Malik Mustapha

His page →
Five takeaways in one half, and the 49ers never sacked Kirk Cousins
Takeaways

Five takeaways in one half, and the 49ers never sacked Kirk Cousins

San Francisco beat Las Vegas 38-17 at Levi's Stadium on Sunday and is 7-1. The 49ers scored touchdowns on their first three possessions, did not punt, and ran 43 times for 190 yards. Las Vegas turned the ball over on five of its six second-half possessions: Jaden Dugger's 35-yard interception return on the first play of the half, two forced fumbles, and interceptions by Renardo Green and Malik Mustapha. The official game book credits San Francisco with no sacks and six quarterback hits, two of them on the plays Green and Mustapha intercepted. Nick Bosa played 39 of 50 defensive snaps in his first game since Sept. 20, and DeForest Buckner played 34. Jordan Watkins caught all four of his targets for 86 yards and his first NFL touchdown. Christian McCaffrey's 12-yard catch set the Super Bowl-era record for touchdown catches by a running back and was Brock Purdy's 100th touchdown pass. Gracen Halton broke his ankle and is out for the season, Shanahan said; Green (back) and Deommodore Lenoir (foot) did not return.

Sam KezarNov 9, 20265 min read
After Pineiro's field goal, Washington ran 40 plays and the 49ers ran nine
Takeaways

After Pineiro's field goal, Washington ran 40 plays and the 49ers ran nine

San Francisco beat Washington 23-17 at Levi's Stadium on Monday night and is 6-0 for the first time since 2019. It led 23-3 with 5:56 left in the third quarter, and from there the offense ran nine plays on three possessions without a first down while Washington ran 40 and scored twice. Four of Washington's first downs came by penalty, two of them wiping out a third-down incompletion and a fourth-down sack. Malik Mustapha broke up a fourth-and-3 pass at the 17 with two minutes left, and Keion White and Romello Height sacked Jayden Daniels on the final play. Mike Evans caught three passes for 94 yards and left with 1:10 in the first half with the Achilles soreness that kept him out of practice all week. Brock Purdy passed 1,500 career attempts on the opening drive, and the club's notes list him first in career passer rating. Jaden Dugger led the team with 11 tackles. Luke Gifford and Upton Stout also left and did not return.

Sam KezarOct 20, 20265 min read
Without Bosa, the defense Shanahan hoped would survive is third in points allowed
49ers Notebook

Without Bosa, the defense Shanahan hoped would survive is third in points allowed

Kyle Shanahan said the injuries on his defensive line had him hoping to survive until the second half of the season. Through five games the 49ers have allowed 93 points, 18.6 a game, and only Minnesota and Kansas City have allowed fewer per game. Bosa is out Monday against Washington, Halton and Mykel Williams are questionable, Malik Mustapha starts again for Marques Sigle, and Brock Purdy is five attempts from qualifying for the career passer-rating list.

Sam KezarOct 18, 20264 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
MissedJul 30, 2026

Malik Mustapha, not Marques Sigle, lines up at safety alongside Ji'Ayir Brown with the 49ers' first-team defense on the opening defensive snap against the Los Angeles Rams on September 10, 2026. If Sigle is on the field with the first team on that snap and Mustapha is not, this call is wrong.

Filed off Camp Battles 2. The competition is the spot beside Brown rather than against him: Wagoner has Brown taking every first-team free safety rep through three practices, and the rotation is at the other safety spot. The call rests on two things. Mustapha is the incumbent, with 22 starts in 28 career games per Niners Wire against zero for Sigle, and this camp has already produced one incumbent-over-rookie result at left guard, where Connor Colby took every first-team rep on day one and Chris Foerster called him the incumbent. Against it: Mustapha strained a hamstring on Monday July 27 and missed Wednesday's practice, Sigle worked with the first team in his place, and every rep in the competition so far was taken in shorts with the first padded practice on Friday July 31. Single-part, no injury escape hatch, and the falsifier is named in the piece.

Latest on the 49ers

The whole beat →
Mike Evans and Dre Greenlaw sit out the first practice at the Air Force Academy
Notebook

Mike Evans and Dre Greenlaw sit out the first practice at the Air Force Academy

Mike Evans (Achilles tendinitis) and Dre Greenlaw (neck) did not practice Wednesday as the 49ers opened Minnesota week at the Air Force Academy in Colorado Springs. Kyle Shanahan said he hopes Evans can go Thursday and that Greenlaw has a good chance to. Renardo Green, day-to-day after leaving the Dallas game with a back injury, was limited, as were Upton Stout, Khalid Kareem, Siran Neal, Ji'Ayir Brown, Luke Gifford and Mac Jones. Christian McCaffrey and Trent Williams did not practice, listed on the official report as rest days. The practice ran outside at half speed. De'Zhaun Stribling, on injured reserve with an ankle injury, worked on the side, per ESPN's Nick Wagoner. The 49ers (8-1) play the Vikings (7-2) in Mexico City on Sunday at 5:20 p.m. Pacific.

Sam KezarNov 18, 20263 min read
Shanahan calls Renardo Green day-to-day after his back tightened at Dallas
Notebook

Shanahan calls Renardo Green day-to-day after his back tightened at Dallas

Kyle Shanahan said Monday that cornerback Renardo Green is day-to-day after leaving Sunday's 46-40 win at Dallas with a back injury, and that the 49ers will see how he is Wednesday. Green played 53 of 83 defensive snaps before rookie Ephesians Prysock replaced him. Nate Hobbs, whose injured-reserve practice window closes Nov. 25, was not activated for Dallas because Shanahan thought Green and Deommodore Lenoir gave the team its best chance; activating him requires releasing someone from a full 53. Mike Evans, out three straight games with Achilles tendinitis, flies to Colorado Springs Monday night, and Shanahan is not sure yet whether he will practice this week. The 49ers are practicing at the Air Force Academy before facing Minnesota (7-2) in Mexico City on Sunday at 5:20 p.m. Pacific.

Sam KezarNov 16, 20263 min read
The 49ers led Dallas by 19 with 11 minutes left and won by six
Takeaways

The 49ers led Dallas by 19 with 11 minutes left and won by six

San Francisco beat Dallas 46-40 at AT&T Stadium on Sunday and is 8-1. Christian McCaffrey had 223 yards from scrimmage and three touchdowns, two of them catches of 74 and 66 yards, and caught the two-point try after the second. The 49ers gained 584 yards. They led 38-19 with 11:26 left; Dallas scored touchdowns on its next three drives, and San Francisco's defense and special teams drew five penalties in the fourth quarter. George Pickens caught 11 of his 18 targets for 145 yards and three touchdowns. Renardo Green left in the second half with a back injury and did not return, Kyle Shanahan said, and rookie Ephesians Prysock played 30 defensive snaps. Trent Williams played all 65 offensive snaps; Brock Purdy was sacked five times and threw for 389 yards and three touchdowns. Keenan Allen caught five passes for 61 yards in his debut, and Deebo Samuel scored twice in his return.

Sam KezarNov 16, 20265 min read

Earlier on the 49ers

Demarcus Robinson takes Christian Kirk's spot on the 49ers' 53
49ers Notebook

Demarcus Robinson takes Christian Kirk's spot on the 49ers' 53

The 49ers placed Christian Kirk on injured reserve Saturday and activated Demarcus Robinson off it, so Robinson is in line to play Sunday against Las Vegas for the first time since Sept. 20. KhaDarel Hodge was elevated from the practice squad. Nate Hobbs, questionable on Friday, was not activated and stays on reserve.

Sam KezarNov 7, 20263 min read
Kirk is in line for his 49ers debut, and Evans and Samuel are both out
49ers Gameday

Kirk is in line for his 49ers debut, and Evans and Samuel are both out

The 49ers (6-0) play the Falcons (2-4) at Mercedes-Benz Stadium at 10 a.m. Pacific on FOX, the last game before their bye. Nick Bosa, Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel, Luke Gifford, Marques Sigle and Garret Wallow are out. Christian Kirk was activated off injured reserve Saturday and carries no designation, so he is in line for his first game as a 49er. Ten to watch, led by the rookies and second-year players: Jaden Dugger, Gracen Halton, Mykel Williams, Upton Stout, Jordan Watkins, plus Kirk, Jacob Cowing, Keion White, George Kittle and Fred Warner. Inactive lists post at 8:30 a.m. Pacific.

Sam KezarOct 25, 20264 min read
Four Transactions, Three Skirmishes, And Not One Word About Left Guard
Camp

Four Transactions, Three Skirmishes, And Not One Word About Left Guard

The fourth practice of camp and the first with contact. Four roster moves, three of the last four subtractions out of the same January class, a Wednesday tryout that became a Friday signing, and no line play reported by anyone.

Sam KezarJul 31, 20264 min read