The line

Michigan Has Played Eight Of The Nineteen Offensive Linemen On Its Roster

Kyle Whittingham said on Monday that the lineup change against Oklahoma was injury and nothing else, that Evan Link should be back this week, and that Andrew Babalola will not be available in the near future. Against Oklahoma, Michigan's own participation report listed one name at each of the five line positions.

GL
Grant LombardSep 15, 20265 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Evan Link in a tan jacket, white shirt and a navy checked tie carrying small maize block M marks, smiling head-on against a white background in a Michigan roster portrait. There is no football uniform in the frame.

Michigan's official roster lists nineteen offensive linemen. Two games into the season, eight of them have taken a snap on offense.

That is mostly how it is supposed to work. An offensive line is meant to be boring. Five men play, the other fourteen hold bags and wait their turn, and the best season a line can have is the one where you never learn the other fourteen names. This line has not been boring since the first week of August. On Monday morning Kyle Whittingham explained why in one clause, and then spent the rest of the availability making it worse.

"We shuffled the lineup due to injury, not due to anything other than that."

Start with what got shuffled. Against Western Michigan on September 5, Michigan started Blake Frazier at left tackle, Evan Link at left guard, Jake Guarnera at center, Brady Norton at right guard and Andrew Sprague at right tackle. That was Link's first career start at guard. Michigan's own postgame notes for that game record seventeen earlier starts at tackle, six on the left and eleven on the right. Seven days later, against the eleventh-ranked team in the country, four of those five started again. Link was not on the paperwork at all. Not a starter, not a backup, not one of the forty-three names in the special teams block at the bottom of the page. Nathan Efobi, listed second behind both guards in the opener, started at left guard in his place.

Nobody said why. The participation release went up on Saturday afternoon, Michigan won 17-10, and Sunday came and went without a reason attached to it. The reason arrived Monday.

"We hope to get Evan Link back," Whittingham said, in the full transcript published by Alejandro Zuniga of MGoBlog. "In fact, we should have him back this week, barring anything unforeseen. But Nate Efobi stepped in and did a nice job at left guard. You may see a rotation there this week with those two; that's to be determined."

So the left guard was hurt, the left guard is coming back, and the job may turn into a two-man arrangement on Saturday. Lines survive that. Lines survive it every year.

Here is the harder half, and Whittingham got to it later, when somebody asked about two players at once.

"Carter should be good to go this week. Andrew, setback. And so we're going to have to work through some things, and he will not be available in the near future, unfortunately."

Carter is Carter Meadows, a true freshman edge rusher who has missed both games and who now looks likely to make his debut on Saturday. Andrew is Andrew Babalola, who arrived in 2025 as a five-star recruit and has still never played a down of college football. A torn anterior cruciate ligament in fall camp last year cost him the entire season, as Charles Post and Von Lozon of Maize n Brew have both reported. He got healthy. This August he was competing with Blake Frazier for the starting left tackle job, per Post, and then he got hurt again, and Michigan has not said what the injury is. Fourteen months, two fall camps, no snaps.

Now count what Michigan actually has.

The Oklahoma participation release lists one name at each of the five offensive line positions. Frazier, Efobi, Guarnera, Norton, Sprague, and underneath them nothing. The opener had put Efobi's name second at both guard spots, which is what a line with a spare part looks like on paper. Against Oklahoma there was no spare part. The only other linemen who played were Manuel Beigel and Avery Gach, and both of them played the Rhino, Jason Beck's sixth-lineman package, which adds a man to the formation rather than replacing one in it. Michigan beat Oklahoma without relieving a single one of its five, and nobody else took a snap at any of those five spots.

The nineteen thins out quickly once you read past the top of it. Ace Hamilton, a true freshman that Blake Frazier had been raving about in August ("Ace Hamilton is going to be a guy," the left tackle told Sam Webb of 247Sports), is gone for the season with a lower-leg injury; Whittingham announced that on August 21, and Lozon quoted him saying Hamilton "will be out for the year, so that one is unfortunate. Very unfortunate." Babalola is out with no date on it. Houston Ka'aha'aina-Torres, Peter Donini and Marky Walbridge have each appeared in both games on special teams and nowhere else. The other eight, Babalola among them, have not been in a game.

None of that is a crisis and it would be daft to file it as one. Michigan is 2-0 with a win over Oklahoma, Whittingham said the line graded better in week two than in week one, and he described the effort as markedly different from the opener. The scoreboard is not arguing with him.

It is just that the shortest sentence Whittingham said on Monday is the one that explains the season. The staff did not move Efobi to left guard because Efobi won a competition. It moved him because the man in front of him could not go, and it kept him there all afternoon because there was nobody behind him either. Whittingham said so himself, in plain words, two days after the game. A five that cannot be relieved is a five that is one ankle away from being a four.

UTEP is in Ann Arbor on Saturday at 3:30 on Big Ten Network, and UTEP is the last opponent on this schedule against whom that arithmetic will not matter. Iowa opens the Big Ten the following week. Minnesota is the week after that. The bye is October 10, three games from now, and the only reinforcement anyone has promised before it is a man Michigan already had two weeks ago.

The pick is that the man gets his job back. Efobi did nothing wrong and may well share the position, but the head coach has already said on the record that the only reason the lineup moved was that Link could not play, and that reason is reportedly going away this week. Michigan will publish its Player Participation release on Saturday night, the way it does after every game, and the first name at left guard will settle it.

Sources#

Filed under Michigan FB

More on Andrew Babalola

His page →
Penn State allowed six 20-yard runs in a night, and Michigan has one all season
Game day

Penn State allowed six 20-yard runs in a night, and Michigan has one all season

Michigan (3-2, 0-2 Big Ten) hosts Penn State (3-3, 0-3) at Michigan Stadium at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS. DraftKings has Michigan by 6.5 with a total of 42.5 at 8:13 a.m. Eastern, which splits to about Michigan 24.5, Penn State 18. Michigan has one run of 20 yards or more in five games, Bryce Underwood's 38-yard touchdown against Oklahoma; its running backs have 111 carries and a longest of 17. Penn State allowed six runs of 20 or more to Northwestern and none to Wisconsin or USC. Rocco Becht is 59 of 102 for 646 yards in three Big Ten games, 6.3 a throw, after 11.7 against Marshall, Temple and Buffalo. Penn State lists receiver Koby Howard Out; he has 344 receiving yards, all of them in non-conference games. Michigan lists Andrew Sprague and Ace Hamilton Out and Jake Guarnera, Brady Norton, Andrew Babalola, Dom Nichols and John Henry Daley Questionable. Prediction: Michigan 20, Penn State 13.

Wes FerryOct 17, 20265 min read
Three of Michigan's five starting linemen are on the Penn State injury report
Game week

Three of Michigan's five starting linemen are on the Penn State injury report

Michigan's initial Big Ten availability report for Saturday's game against Penn State, filed Wednesday, October 14, lists 14 players, six of them offensive linemen. Jake Guarnera, who started at center at Minnesota, and Brady Norton, another Minnesota starter, are Questionable; Nathan Efobi, a third starter, is Probable. Evan Link and Blake Frazier are not listed. Andrew Sprague is Out, the first time Michigan has opened a week with him at Out rather than Questionable, and Ace Hamilton is Out. Andrew Babalola, Out on all eight of his earlier designations this season, is Questionable. Manuel Beigel, Out on game day at Minnesota, is off the report, which makes him Available under the conference rule. In Michigan's two earlier conference weeks, ten Wednesday Questionable designations ended with three Outs on game day, all three of them offensive linemen; the six non-linemen all finished Available and the fourth lineman, Houston Ka'aha'aina-Torres, was a Game Time Decision who played. One take filed.

Grant LombardOct 15, 20264 min read
Whittingham changed one starter on Monday, and it was the punt returner
Game week

Whittingham changed one starter on Monday, and it was the punt returner

Kyle Whittingham said at his Monday press conference on October 12 that Bryce Underwood remains Michigan's starting quarterback and Jason Beck remains the play-caller for Saturday's game against Penn State. The only personnel change he announced was at punt returner, where Andrew Marsh, who has lost fumbles against Western Michigan and Minnesota, will be replaced for reasons Whittingham said include injury. Right tackle Andrew Sprague, out since the UTEP game, will miss several more weeks; Whittingham said his return is \"way out there.\" Andrew Babalola returned to practice Monday for the first time in about a month, by Whittingham's count. Whittingham said more linemen hurt at Minnesota will be questionable on Wednesday's availability report. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten, its first 0-2 conference start since 2014, with a turnover margin of minus 4; Underwood has thrown 4 interceptions and lost 2 fumbles. Tommy Carr took first-team reps in the bye and could get a series or two. Penn State, 3-3 and 0-3, visits Michigan Stadium at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on October 17.

Grant LombardOct 12, 20264 min read

More on Nathan Efobi

His page →
Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost
Takeaways

Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost

Minnesota beat Michigan 20-14 at Huntington Bank Stadium, its first win over Michigan since 2014 and its first in Minneapolis since 1977. Michigan led 14-7 at halftime on Jordan Marshall's 5-yard run and Nathaniel Staehling's 79-yard interception return, then turned the ball over on a muffed punt and two Bryce Underwood interceptions in a span of 7:31. Minnesota scored 13 points off those turnovers on drives of 4, 34 and 35 yards. Michigan's offense gained 180 yards, its fewest of the season, held the ball for 41 seconds of the third quarter, and ran eight plays for no net yards between its touchdown and the fourth quarter. Underwood was 10 of 21 for 101 yards and was sacked three times. The running backs carried 18 times for 59 yards. Michigan's defense forced two turnovers, allowed one scoring drive longer than 35 yards and had no sacks. Michigan's last drive ended with two timeouts unused. JJ Buchanan, Nathan Efobi and Chase Taylor each went down during the game, and Kyle Whittingham said a couple of players could not finish without naming them. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten.

Wes FerryOct 4, 20266 min read
Michigan Would Not Name Its Two Starting Guards Because Three Seniors Are Going To Split The Job
Game week

Michigan Would Not Name Its Two Starting Guards Because Three Seniors Are Going To Split The Job

Michigan's offensive coordinator held his final press conference before the opener on Wednesday afternoon and was asked the question that has followed this offensive line since camp opened. Jason Beck answered it with a number rather than a name. Evan Link, Nathan Efobi and Brady Norton will all play at the two guard spots, at what Beck called fairly similar snaps, and Clayton Sayfie of On3 reported that the rotation may hold for more than one game. The three tackles-and-center jobs are settled: Blake Frazier on the left, Jake Guarnera at center, Andrew Sprague on the right, the last of those hardened by Andrew Babalola's injury. Michigan's own roster still lists nineteen men as OL and nothing else, while it breaks the defensive line into ends and tackles, and on Wednesday the defensive coordinator named starters at both.

Grant LombardSep 3, 20265 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
Held upAug 11, 2026

Michigan has not publicly identified all five offensive line starters by name and position on or before August 22, 2026.

Harding's target was internal solidification rather than an announcement, and that gap is the whole basis of the call: programs settle a line in the building weeks before they say so, and Michigan has published no depth chart. There are three spots open, one of them left tackle, where Kyle Whittingham said on Monday that Andrew Babalola, Evan Link and Blake Frazier are splitting the majority of the reps, and Babalola did not play in 2025. Whittingham's own marker is looser than a date: about 10 practices before definitive decisions, and five were in the bank on Monday. It fails if coaches or the program name all five spots on or before August 22, including a released depth chart or a coach confirming the five in an availability. Reporters projecting a five does not resolve it, because the claim is about what Michigan says rather than what anyone predicts. A partial naming, four of five, does not resolve it either.

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
Does the Big Ten's $49 million line bind Michigan? Its own budget can't say
The money

Does the Big Ten's $49 million line bind Michigan? Its own budget can't say

The Big Ten's presidents adopted a rule on October 28 that caps, at $49 million per school for the 2027-28 cap year, the total of a school's revenue-sharing payments, NIL deals between its athletes and its associated boosters and collectives, and any third-party NIL deal the school helps arrange. It is one number across every sport. Michigan's FY 2027 budget sets revenue sharing at $21.32 million against a 2026-27 ceiling the Big Ten puts at $21.58 million, and Michigan projected spending $18.0 million of the $20.5 million allowed in 2025-26. The associated-entity layer is not published, so whether the line binds Michigan cannot be settled from the public record.

Wes FerryOct 29, 20265 min read
Michigan has held all seven opponents to 20 or fewer, and is playing for a bowl
The wider view

Michigan has held all seven opponents to 20 or fewer, and is playing for a bowl

Michigan is 4-3 despite holding all seven opponents to 20 points or fewer, and ESPN's game-by-game numbers make a bowl likely and a seventh win close to even.

Wes FerryOct 28, 20265 min read
Michigan ran on every short-yardage down inside the 25, until Indiana
Deep dive

Michigan ran on every short-yardage down inside the 25, until Indiana

Through six games Michigan had nine short-yardage snaps (third or fourth down, three yards or fewer to go) at or inside an opponent's 25. It ran on all nine and converted seven, Bryce Underwood carrying three of them from under center and the backs six from shotgun. In Saturday's 13-6 overtime loss to Indiana it had six such snaps and called a pass on four. One converted; Tommy Carr was sacked on the other three, including on third-and-1 from the Indiana 1. Indiana's first seven opponents converted 12 of 20 short-yardage runs against it and 7 of 14 throws, sacks counted, so running was not the losing bet against this defense. The wider pattern: Michigan scored 10 touchdowns on 36 possessions that began in its own territory in its first four games, and one on 27 in the three since, under two quarterbacks. That one followed an interception. Rutgers, next, has allowed 28 points or more in six of its seven games.

Wes FerryOct 26, 20266 min read

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Michigan completed nothing that travelled more than 11 yards in the air, and won
Deep dive

Michigan completed nothing that travelled more than 11 yards in the air, and won

Michigan beat Penn State 21-18 without completing a pass that travelled more than 11 yards past the line of scrimmage. By the catch spots recorded in Michigan Athletics' official play-by-play, its 10 completions covered 41 yards in the air and 49 after the catch, and the four throws that went 25 yards or more downfield were two Tommy Carr incompletions and both Bryce Underwood interceptions. Across six games, Michigan has completed five passes of 20 or more air yards, all against Western Michigan and Iowa. Penn State's deep passing game was one receiver: the stat crew marked five of Rocco Becht's 44 throws as deep, all five went to Chase Sowell, and three were caught for 76 yards. In the run game, the second half's 14 runs up the middle were Michigan's season habit producing 10.1 yards a carry instead of the 4.0 it had averaged there in the first five games, and the ball moved to Savion Hiter, who carried twice before halftime and nine times after it. PFF's grades, cited as rankings only, had Avery Gach first in run blocking among the five linemen who started at the conventional spots, Manuel Beigel's run-blocking grade highest of any Michigan lineman, Rod Moore Jr. the highest-graded Michigan defender despite leaving in the third quarter, and Jyaire Hill last in coverage among the eight defensive backs who made a tackle. Kyle Whittingham said Monday he will not name the Indiana starter.

Wes FerryOct 19, 20266 min read
Iowa has one ranked team left to play, and Michigan has four
The wider view

Iowa has one ranked team left to play, and Michigan has four

Michigan is 3-1 and 0-1 in the Big Ten after losing 20-19 to Iowa, and is out of the AP Top 25 for the second time this season: 54 points, sixth among the teams outside the 25, down from 18th and 432. The coaches have it 24th with 166 points. The three teams Michigan has beaten are a combined 5-7 and none is ranked. Six Big Ten teams are in the AP poll: Ohio State 5th, Indiana 6th, Iowa 14th, Oregon 15th, USC 18th and UCLA 23rd. Michigan still plays four of them, Indiana and UCLA at home and Oregon and Ohio State on the road, worth 3,816 AP points, the most left on any of those seven teams' schedules. Iowa has one ranked opponent left, Ohio State at home on Saturday, and holds the head-to-head tiebreak over Michigan. In the two seasons of an 18-team Big Ten, the four title-game berths went to teams that were 9-0, 8-1, 9-0 and 9-0 in conference play, and two other 8-1 teams stayed home. In the two seasons of a 12-team playoff, none of the 14 at-large bids went to a team with three regular-season losses, and four of the eight 10-2 teams in the committee's final top 16 that were not conference champions and did not play a title game got in. Three of Michigan's four ranked opponents come in its last four games, after the committee's first ranking on November 3. Andrew Babalola is due back at practice next week, Andrew Sprague's status is unresolved after two missed games, and John Henry Daley was hurt on the second-to-last play against Iowa. Michigan plays at Minnesota on Saturday at noon Eastern on Fox.

Wes FerrySep 30, 20266 min read
Iowa's special-teams edge is 0.8 points, and three games have shrunk it
The rating

Iowa's special-teams edge is 0.8 points, and three games have shrunk it

In Bill Connelly's SP+ ratings after Week 3, Iowa's special teams rate 0.5 points per game better than an average FBS unit and Michigan's rate -0.3, a gap of 0.8 points. That is the same size as the gap between the two defences, which sit 9th and 11th, even though the special-teams ranks are 7th and 108th. Every FBS special-teams rating sits between -0.6 and 0.6, a range of 1.2 points, against about 30 points on offence and on defence. ESPN's own note says early-season ratings rest mainly on preseason projections, special teams included, and the table agrees: across all 138 teams the Week 3 special-teams ratings track the final preseason ones almost exactly, and 121 teams have moved by 0.1 or less. Michigan has moved up 0.2, from -0.5, and Iowa down 0.1, from 0.6, so the gap has shrunk from 1.1 to 0.8. Michigan's counting numbers through three games are clean: 2 of 2 on field goals, 10 of 10 on extra points, 43.5 yards a punt. Iowa has missed two extra points and a field goal and averages 17.0 yards on 11 punt returns, with a touchdown. One take filed, on where Michigan's rating finishes the regular season.

Jamie SilvaSep 24, 20266 min read