Grab Some Pine Pull up a bench. Bay Area sports, Michigan, and a model or two.
October 28, 2026
The wider view

Michigan has held all seven opponents to 20 or fewer, and is playing for a bowl

Only Michigan and New Mexico have held every opponent to 20 points or fewer. New Mexico is 6-1. Michigan is 4-3, and ESPN's game-by-game numbers make a bowl likely and a seventh win close to even.

WF
Wes FerryOct 28, 20265 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Michigan linebacker Nathaniel Staehling (44) shouts in celebration beside two teammates, all in Michigan's white road jerseys, navy trousers and winged helmets, at Huntington Bank Stadium in Minneapolis on October 3, 2026.

Two teams in the country have held every opponent they have played this season to 20 points or fewer. One is New Mexico, which is 6-1. The other is Michigan, which is 4-3.

That is the season in one comparison. Michigan has allowed 15.7 points a game, 15th of 138 FBS teams. It has scored 20.3, which is 119th. It has lost 20-19 to Iowa, 20-14 at Minnesota and 13-6 in overtime to Indiana, three games by a combined 14 points, and it is 1-3 in the Big Ten with five games left.

So the question this team is playing for has changed. It is no longer whether Michigan can reach the playoff. It is whether Michigan reaches a bowl, and how many wins it brings there.

Where the polls and the ratings put it#

Michigan received no votes in the AP poll released Sunday. Nine teams were listed as receiving votes, and Minnesota, which beat Michigan, was one of them with 7 points. The coaches gave Michigan 2 points, tied with North Texas at the bottom of their list.

The ratings are kinder and say the same thing. ESPN's Football Power Index, updated Tuesday, has Michigan 34th. It gives Michigan a 0.2% chance to make the playoff, a 1.2% chance to win its last five, and 0.0% to win the Big Ten. SP+, Bill Connelly's rating as published through CollegeFootballData, has Michigan 27th overall, made of the third-best defense in FBS and the 86th-best offense. ESPN's own efficiency measure is less generous to the defense, 18th, and harsher on the special teams, 133rd of 138.

The selection committee has not published a ranking yet. When it does, the question it answers will be about teams Michigan is no longer competing with.

Teams built like Michigan#

Michigan is not the only team in the country with this shape. Four teams have an SP+ defense in the top 10 and an offense outside the top 60.

TeamRecordSP+ defenseSP+ offensePolls
Michigan4-33rd86th2 coaches points
Oklahoma4-36th88th1 coaches point
Wisconsin5-29th93rdAP 25th
Iowa5-210th62ndCoaches 24th

Michigan has played two of the other three. It beat Oklahoma 17-10 in September and lost to Iowa 20-19. Together the four are 18-10, and two of them are in a poll. A defense this good keeps a team in almost every game it plays. On its own it does not decide many of them, and Michigan's six games decided by 7 points or fewer have split 3-3.

The five games left, by ESPN's odds#

ESPN publishes a matchup predictor for every game, built on FPI. Here is what it gives Michigan for each of the five, read Wednesday morning.

OpponentDateSiteMichigan's chance
RutgersOct. 31away83.7%
Michigan StateNov. 7home78.8%
OregonNov. 14away22.9%
UCLANov. 21home60.3%
Ohio StateNov. 28away8.7%

Bowl eligibility takes six wins, which means two of these five. Multiplying the five numbers out as though the games were independent of one another, Michigan has an 88.6% chance of getting there. The same arithmetic gives 53.3% for seven wins or more, and 12.7% for eight or more. FPI's own projection is 6.5 wins. The independence is an assumption, and a real one: a team whose offense improves in November improves in every game at once, and so does one whose offense does not.

The schedule sorts itself cleanly. Rutgers is 2-5, has allowed 28 points or more in six of its seven games, and has a defense SP+ rates 124th. DraftKings has Michigan by 14. Michigan State is 2-6 and 0-5 in the Big Ten, with an offense SP+ rates 98th. Those two are the bowl.

The seventh win has to come from one of the other three, and the odds say where to look. Ohio State is 6-1 and first in SP+. Oregon is 4-3 after losing at Illinois on Saturday, the same record as Michigan, and still rated 12th by SP+ with the game in Eugene. UCLA is 7-0 and seventh in the AP poll, rated 17th by SP+, and comes to Ann Arbor. It is the only one of the three in which ESPN makes Michigan the favorite.

Health, carried forward#

Michigan ruled out right tackle Blake Frazier and edge Dom Nichols on game day against Indiana, along with tight end Zack Marshall. Safety Rod Moore Jr. and defensive tackle Enow Etta were game-time decisions. Andrew Sprague, Ace Hamilton and Julius Holly remained out.

The quarterback is the other open question for Rutgers. Tommy Carr started against Indiana, his first start, and Bryce Underwood played one snap. The Big Ten's first availability report for the Rutgers game is the next document that will say who is back, and Michigan kicks off at Rutgers at 9:30 a.m. Pacific on Saturday on the Big Ten Network.

Called shot. Michigan finishes the regular season with at least seven wins. ESPN's odds put it slightly better than even, the two games that make the bowl are against teams that have allowed points to almost everyone, and UCLA comes to a defense that has not allowed more than 20 to anybody. The other side is real. Michigan is 0-2 this season against teams SP+ now rates in its top 25, Iowa and Indiana, and a seventh win needs a win over one of UCLA, Oregon or Ohio State, each of them rated higher than Michigan.

Sources: AP Top 25 and AFCA coaches poll, released October 25, 2026, via CollegeFootballData and ESPN's rankings feed (receiving votes); ESPN Football Power Index and efficiency ratings, updated October 27, 2026; ESPN matchup predictor for each of Michigan's remaining games, read October 28, 2026; SP+ ratings, 2026, via CollegeFootballData; CollegeFootballData 2026 FBS game results; DraftKings line for Michigan at Rutgers via CollegeFootballData; Michigan Athletics football schedule page, opened October 28, 2026; Michigan's game-day availability designations for Indiana as reported by The Wolverine, October 24, 2026.

Filed under Michigan FB

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
Michigan ran on every short-yardage down inside the 25, until Indiana
Deep dive

Michigan ran on every short-yardage down inside the 25, until Indiana

Through six games Michigan had nine short-yardage snaps (third or fourth down, three yards or fewer to go) at or inside an opponent's 25. It ran on all nine and converted seven, Bryce Underwood carrying three of them from under center and the backs six from shotgun. In Saturday's 13-6 overtime loss to Indiana it had six such snaps and called a pass on four. One converted; Tommy Carr was sacked on the other three, including on third-and-1 from the Indiana 1. Indiana's first seven opponents converted 12 of 20 short-yardage runs against it and 7 of 14 throws, sacks counted, so running was not the losing bet against this defense. The wider pattern: Michigan scored 10 touchdowns on 36 possessions that began in its own territory in its first four games, and one on 27 in the three since, under two quarterbacks. That one followed an interception. Rutgers, next, has allowed 28 points or more in six of its seven games.

Wes FerryOct 26, 20266 min read
Michigan had third down at Indiana's 1 and 3, and lost yards both times
Takeaways

Michigan had third down at Indiana's 1 and 3, and lost yards both times

Indiana beat Michigan 13-6 in overtime at Michigan Stadium in front of 111,276, its first win there since 1967. Michigan is 4-3 and 1-3 in the Big Ten. Michigan had the ball inside the Indiana 23 on five possessions and scored two field goals. Three of the five ended with Tommy Carr sacked on third down, including a 13-yard loss on third-and-1 from the Indiana 1 that Kyle Whittingham called 'not a good football call,' and a 5-yard loss on third-and-3 from the 3 with 32 seconds left. Trey Butkowski, 4 of 4 on field goals before Saturday, missed from 53 and 32. Indiana's six points in regulation both came on short fields after Carr's two turnovers; its nine other regulation possessions, all starting in its own territory, produced nothing. Josh Hoover, playing hurt per Curt Cignetti, was 8 of 18 for 81 yards and threw his first interception of the season, to Zeke Berry. Michigan ran 42 times for 57 yards, its running backs 26 times for 52. In his first start Carr was 20 of 32 for 167 yards; no completion travelled more than 18 yards past the line. Blake Frazier and Dom Nichols were ruled out on game day; Marky Walbridge started at right tackle and Benny Patterson III made his first career start. Michigan plays at Rutgers on Saturday.

Wes FerryOct 25, 20266 min read
Tommy Carr's first start is against a team that almost never gives the ball back
Game day

Tommy Carr's first start is against a team that almost never gives the ball back

Michigan (4-2, 1-2 Big Ten) hosts Indiana (6-1, 3-1), sixth in the AP poll, at Michigan Stadium at noon Eastern on Fox. DraftKings has Indiana by 7.5 with a total of 42.5 at 5:43 a.m. Eastern, which splits to about Indiana 25, Michigan 17.5. Tommy Carr, a true freshman, is expected to make his first start at quarterback; Kyle Whittingham said Monday the staff had decided and would not say who. Michigan scored all 21 of its points against Penn State after takeaways. Indiana has three turnovers in seven games, all fumbles, and Josh Hoover is 108 of 169 for 1,660 yards, 18 touchdowns and no interceptions. Indiana ran 51 times for 138 yards against Nebraska and Ohio State, sacks included. Michigan lists seven players Out and seven Questionable, among them Rod Moore Jr. and two linemen who started against Penn State; Indiana lists no one. Prediction: Indiana 20, Michigan 13.

Wes FerryOct 24, 20265 min read

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Michigan Lost Four Of Five Third-And-Shorts To A Team Averaging 3.3 Yards A Play
Deep dive

Michigan Lost Four Of Five Third-And-Shorts To A Team Averaging 3.3 Yards A Play

Michigan beat Western Michigan 13-12 and the possession number that defined the night has a narrow cause. Across 18 third downs the Broncos converted eight. On the 13 that needed four yards or more, Michigan allowed four. On the five that needed three or fewer, Western Michigan ran the ball every time and converted four, twice on quarterback keepers up the middle out of shotgun on third-and-1. Michigan's own offense was the more efficient one, 276 yards on 48 snaps against 221 on 67, and it lined up under center exactly four times all night, consecutively, from first-and-goal at the 5 through the fourth-and-goal touchdown that opened the scoring. It never went back, and it won the game on the last snap of the night. The three-turnover total the box score carries includes a muffed punt that no offensive drive chart records.

Wes FerrySep 7, 20267 min read
Michigan's First Official Injury Report Is Due September 23, Three Games Into A Season That Starts Saturday
Game week

Michigan's First Official Injury Report Is Due September 23, Three Games Into A Season That Starts Saturday

Michigan Athletics published thirty-six pages of week-one game notes on Monday. Page 36 prints a table headed Michigan Starting Lineups, twenty-two positions across offense and defense, and every 2026 box in it is empty. The table directly beside it, which counts how many games each returning player has started, is filled in completely. Four days later the Big Ten announced it will require four availability reports a week instead of one, and the conference confirmed the reports cover games against conference opponents only. Michigan plays three non-conference games first. Its first report is due at 8 p.m. Eastern on Wednesday, September 23. It will say who cannot play. It has no column for who starts.

Grant LombardSep 1, 20266 min read
Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass
The depth chart

Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass

At his first Big Ten Media Days, Whittingham said Tommy Carr is Michigan's backup quarterback without a doubt, putting a true freshman who has never taken a college snap ahead of Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, who threw 969 passes at Colorado State. In the same session he said Bryce Underwood arrived not nearly as fundamentally sound as he needed to be, and pointed at how the position was staffed in 2025, when the offensive coordinator carried the quarterbacks title as well. Camp opens August 5.

Grant LombardAug 1, 20265 min read