Injury

JJ Buchanan, probably done, caught more long passes than the rest of Michigan

Kyle Whittingham said Monday that JJ Buchanan, Michigan's leading receiver, is probably out for the season with a shoulder injury. He caught 10 of Michigan's 19 completions of 20 yards or more. Andrew Marsh, the receiver Michigan still has, averages 9.6 yards a catch.

GL
Grant LombardNov 16, 20264 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Michigan receiver JJ Buchanan, in the navy home jersey and maize trousers, carries the ball in his right hand and stiff-arms a UTEP defender in white along the sideline at Michigan Stadium on September 19, 2026, with an official watching behind them.

Andrew Marsh has caught more passes than anyone at Michigan this season. JJ Buchanan has caught the ones that went somewhere, and on Monday Kyle Whittingham said Buchanan is probably done.

"Probably going to be out for the season," Whittingham told reporters, per MLive. "It's not 100 percent, but it's looking like the probable outcome."

Buchanan hurt his left shoulder early in the second quarter at Oregon on Saturday and went to a hospital for tests while the 31-7 loss was still being played, having been thrown to twice in the first quarter and caught neither, which is an abrupt way for the one Michigan receiver who reliably got behind people to end a season. His final line reads 2 targets, 0 catches.

Who caught what#

The two receivers have split the passing game almost evenly by volume and not at all by distance.

ReceiverCatchesYardsPer catchTDCatches of 20+
Andrew Marsh484599.614
JJ Buchanan4064616.2510
Everyone else5353110.015

Catches, yards and touchdowns are from Michigan's ten official box scores. The 20-yard column is counted from the official play-by-play, which has Michigan at 19 completions of that length all season. Buchanan caught more of them than everybody else on the roster put together.

His 646 yards are about two of every five receiving yards Michigan has (the team has 1,636, which is not a lot of receiving yards for ten games of football, but that is a different column), and his touchdown catches are five of the seven Michigan has thrown for all season. Buchanan was most of the passing game's scoring and more than half of its long plays.

The depth tags make the same point from the other direction. Of the throws the play-by-play marks as deep, Buchanan caught five of 14. Marsh has caught one of 15. Marsh is a good receiver doing a specific job, and the play-by-play tags 66 of his 81 targets as short, so the job has never included the 49-yard touchdown down the right side that put Michigan ahead of Iowa in the fourth quarter or the 47-yarder on the last play against Western Michigan, both of which were Buchanan's.

(That Western Michigan play is the reason Michigan is 5-5 rather than 4-6, which is a strange thing to be able to say about a single catch in November. It is also true.)

Saturday was the preview#

Michigan has gone a whole game without a completion of 20 yards twice this season, once at Minnesota on October 3 and once at Oregon, the game Buchanan left.

After he went out, Marsh became the passing game in the most literal sense available. He was thrown to 14 times. He caught 4, for 46 yards. Michigan finished 6 of 20 for 71 between Tommy Carr and Bryce Underwood, and nothing anyone caught went 20 yards.

Anyway.

Whittingham said the quarterback job is open again, between the same two. "We will have an open competition this week between our two guys and see who comes away with it," he said, per Maize n Brew. Whoever wins it inherits a receiver room that, without Buchanan, has caught nine passes of 20 yards or more in ten games: four by Marsh and one each by Hogan Hansen, Channing Goodwin, Salesi Moa, Mason Bonner and Travis Johnson.

The line in front of them is thinner too. On the two starting tackles, Whittingham said, "Andrew for certain, no. And Blake would be a long shot this week, unfortunately. Two good players. Two really good players." Andrew Sprague has not played since the Oklahoma game in September. Blake Frazier was hurt against Michigan State on November 7 and missed Oregon. ESPN reported Monday that neither is expected back this season; the words Whittingham was quoted saying close the door on Sprague and only on this week for Frazier.

What it costs, and when#

Michigan is one win from bowl eligibility with two games left: UCLA, 10-0, at Michigan Stadium on Saturday at 12:30 p.m. Pacific, and Ohio State in Columbus on November 28.

Buchanan followed Whittingham from Utah this year, and so did Jason Beck, the offensive coordinator Michigan fired last week. One of the two imports worked from the first week. Buchanan had at least two catches in each of the nine games before Oregon and two games over 100 yards. On a team whose offense needed one man who could catch it 30 yards downfield, he was the man, and now the job is vacant on a Monday in mid-November.

Called Shot#

Michigan completes no pass of 20 yards or more against UCLA. The case for it is the table above and the Oregon game, the one game this offense has played mostly without him. The case against it is that Michigan has managed at least one such completion in eight of its ten games, including two of the four games in which Buchanan did not catch one: Hansen's 22-yarder at Penn State and Goodwin's 24-yarder against Indiana. In the games he did not supply one, somebody else did half the time.

Sources: Michigan's official box scores and play-by-play for its ten 2026 games; MLive (Aaron McMann), November 16, 2026; ESPN (Adam Rittenberg), November 16, 2026; Maize n Brew (Von Lozon), November 16, 2026.

Filed under Michigan FB

More on JJ Buchanan

His page →
Five Oregon completions gained 228 yards, and Michigan threw for 71
Takeaways

Five Oregon completions gained 228 yards, and Michigan threw for 71

Oregon beat Michigan 31-7 at Autzen Stadium on November 14. Five Dylan Raiola completions of 22 yards or more gained 228 of his 341 passing yards and produced three touchdowns. Michigan ran for 215 yards, 107 of them by Savion Hiter, but completed 6 of 20 passes for 71 yards, lost JJ Buchanan to a trip to the hospital in the second quarter, and had all five of its full second-half possessions end on downs or a fumble. Michigan is 5-5 and plays undefeated UCLA on Saturday.

Wes FerryNov 15, 20266 min read
Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost
Takeaways

Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost

Minnesota beat Michigan 20-14 at Huntington Bank Stadium, its first win over Michigan since 2014 and its first in Minneapolis since 1977. Michigan led 14-7 at halftime on Jordan Marshall's 5-yard run and Nathaniel Staehling's 79-yard interception return, then turned the ball over on a muffed punt and two Bryce Underwood interceptions in a span of 7:31. Minnesota scored 13 points off those turnovers on drives of 4, 34 and 35 yards. Michigan's offense gained 180 yards, its fewest of the season, held the ball for 41 seconds of the third quarter, and ran eight plays for no net yards between its touchdown and the fourth quarter. Underwood was 10 of 21 for 101 yards and was sacked three times. The running backs carried 18 times for 59 yards. Michigan's defense forced two turnovers, allowed one scoring drive longer than 35 yards and had no sacks. Michigan's last drive ended with two timeouts unused. JJ Buchanan, Nathan Efobi and Chase Taylor each went down during the game, and Kyle Whittingham said a couple of players could not finish without naming them. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten.

Wes FerryOct 4, 20266 min read
Underwood cleared both bars against Iowa. He did it five times last year.
Deep dive

Underwood cleared both bars against Iowa. He did it five times last year.

Bryce Underwood cleared both of the bars his 2025 Big Ten season set for him in Michigan's 20-19 loss to Iowa: 9.9 yards an attempt (17 of 28 for 276) against 7.5, and a 48.3 percent success rate (14 of 29 dropbacks) against 44.1. By yards per attempt and by CollegeFootballData's expected points per dropback (+0.56), it was the best of his 13 college games against Power 4 defenses, against an Iowa defense that had allowed 4.4 yards an attempt in its first three games. It does not settle whether he has improved, because his 2025 Big Ten line was an average of two kinds of game: he cleared both marks in five of nine (Wisconsin, USC, Washington, Northwestern, Maryland) and missed both in the other four (Nebraska, Michigan State, Purdue, Ohio State), with none in between. By success rate Iowa ranks above only the USC game among those five. His two Power 4 games this season are one of each: Oklahoma at 6.5 and 31.6 percent, Iowa at 9.9 and 48.3. Pooled, that is 41.7 percent on 48 dropbacks and 8.6 yards an attempt on 45. The yards came from the deep ball: three of six deep-tagged throws were caught for 101 yards after one of 11 in the first three games, and on his 26 attempts other than the 49- and 32-yard throws to JJ Buchanan he averaged 7.5. All four of Andrew Marsh's incompletions were broken up, three by Jaylen Watson in the first half. Underwood was sacked once in 29 dropbacks. His second-half success rate fell again, 5 of 12 after 9 of 17 before halftime. Four straight Big Ten games above both marks, starting with Iowa, would be a streak he never had in 2025.

Wes FerrySep 28, 20267 min read

More on Tommy Carr

His page →
Michigan needs about 14 points at Oregon. It scored 6 in two of its last three
Game day

Michigan needs about 14 points at Oregon. It scored 6 in two of its last three

Michigan (5-4) plays at 18th-ranked Oregon (6-3) at 12:30 p.m. Pacific on FS1 as a 10.5-point underdog, one win from bowl eligibility, in its first game since firing offensive coordinator Jason Beck. The Big Ten's Friday report lists Oregon outside linebacker Teitum Tuioti, who has 5.5 of Oregon's 19 sacks, Out, and Michigan offensive lineman Blake Frazier Doubtful. Tommy Carr is expected to start at quarterback, ESPN reported, with Bryce Underwood likely to play.

Wes FerryNov 14, 20265 min read
Twelve throws on third-and-short, three sacks: what Jim Harding inherits
Deep dive

Twelve throws on third-and-short, three sacks: what Jim Harding inherits

By CollegeFootballData's play-by-play across Michigan's nine 2026 games, Michigan converted 17 of 27 third downs with 3 yards or fewer to go when it ran and 5 of 12 when it threw, with three sacks on those throws, all against Indiana. Tommy Carr has been sacked on about 1 dropback in 9, against 1 in 19 for Bryce Underwood, and its first- and second-down runs have lost ground more often. Jim Harding, the offensive line coach, is now interim coordinator and will lead a collaborative play-calling group at Oregon, which has at least two sacks in each of its last six games.

Wes FerryNov 9, 20266 min read
Michigan held Michigan State without a touchdown and lost by nine
Takeaways

Michigan held Michigan State without a touchdown and lost by nine

Michigan State beat Michigan 15-6 at Michigan Stadium on November 7 on five Liam Boyd field goals. Twelve of the 15 points came on drives that started at the Michigan State 38 or better, set up by two Michigan punts from deep after sacks and by two turnovers. Michigan gained 192 yards, was sacked five times, went 2 of 10 on third down and did not score until 1:35 remained.

Wes FerryNov 8, 20266 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
MissedAug 18, 2026

True freshman receiver Travis Johnson (No. 13) catches at least 1 pass in the September 5 opener against Western Michigan.

Johnson is the clearest riser of Michigan's camp. Tony Garcia of the Detroit Free Press reported that he was named a standout of the August 15 scrimmage; Hartwell reported on August 17 that cornerback Jyaire Hill named Johnson among the hardest young receivers to cover, that Jaime Ffrench praised his speed, and that Andrew Marsh spoke well of him, and framed him as possibly forcing his way into the two- or three-deep immediately. Against the call: Michigan's top 2 receivers are settled in Marsh and Buchanan, the WR3 job is contested by at least Ffrench and Salesi Moa as well, and a true freshman can dress and never be targeted in a season opener a team expects to control. This is a playing-time call rather than a talent call.

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
Michigan plays 6 of the committee's top 25. Its bowl is a coin flip
The wider view

Michigan plays 6 of the committee's top 25. Its bowl is a coin flip

The College Football Playoff selection committee's third top 25, released November 17, put Oklahoma 22nd, which makes Michigan's 17-10 win in September its first over a team the committee ranks. Six of Michigan's 12 regular-season games are against teams in that ranking, tied with seven SEC teams for the most in FBS. Michigan is 5-5 and 1-3 in those games so far. By DraftKings' moneylines with the margin removed, it has about a 38% chance against UCLA and 18% at Ohio State, which puts its chance of a sixth win at about 49%.

Wes FerryNov 18, 20265 min read
Michigan ran for 215 yards at Oregon, and ran exactly as well as it always does
Deep dive

Michigan ran for 215 yards at Oregon, and ran exactly as well as it always does

Savion Hiter's career-high 107 yards at Oregon were 70 on one carry and 37 on twelve others, and 3 of his 13 carries succeeded by the standard college measure. Bryson Kuzdzal succeeded on 5 of 9. As a team Michigan's runs succeeded at 39%, its season rate exactly. Its 16 early-down dropbacks succeeded 4 times, its lowest rate in any game this season, so its 13 third downs averaged 8.7 yards to go and only 3 were 3 yards or shorter. UCLA, next, has held 7 of its 10 opponents under 100 rushing yards.

Wes FerryNov 16, 20266 min read
Michigan's last three opponents are 21-6, and each is playing for the playoff
The wider view

Michigan's last three opponents are 21-6, and each is playing for the playoff

The College Football Playoff selection committee's second ranking, released November 10, has UCLA 4th, Oregon 16th and Ohio State 20th, Michigan's last three opponents, who are a combined 21-6. Michigan, 5-4 and unranked, needs one win for bowl eligibility. By DraftKings' moneylines with the margin removed, it has about a 22% chance at Oregon and 18% at Ohio State.

Wes FerryNov 11, 20265 min read

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Northwestern ran for 413 yards on Penn State. Was that the real Penn State?
Game week

Northwestern ran for 413 yards on Penn State. Was that the real Penn State?

Penn State (3-3, 0-3 Big Ten) visits Michigan (3-2, 0-2) on Saturday, October 17, at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS. Against Marshall, Temple and Buffalo, Penn State ran 120 times for 615 yards and allowed 333 on 97 carries. In three Big Ten games it has run 89 times for 235 yards, 2.6 a carry and 17th of 18 conference teams in conference games, and allowed 662 yards on 113 carries, 5.9 a carry and 16th. Northwestern's 413 rushing yards on October 2 account for most of that defensive figure: it is the only 400-yard rushing game against an ACC, Big Ten, Big 12 or SEC defense in 322 such team-games this season, and Northwestern had run 27 times for 32 yards against Indiana the week before. Without it, Wisconsin and USC ran 58 times for 249 yards, 4.3 a carry, which would rank 12th. Penn State's own running game has been poor in all three conference games: everyone other than quarterback Rocco Becht has 62 carries for 182 yards. Michigan has run 68 times for 232 yards in two Big Ten games, 12th in the conference, and its run defense ranks fourth at 2.9 yards a carry.

Wes FerryOct 14, 20265 min read
Michigan and Penn State were ranked in August but got no votes Sunday
The wider view

Michigan and Penn State were ranked in August but got no votes Sunday

Michigan received no votes in either poll on Sunday, October 4, after losing 20-14 at Minnesota. A week earlier it had 54 AP points and was 24th in the coaches poll. Penn State, which lost 34-13 at Northwestern, also received none. They were 16th and 18th in the preseason AP poll and meet at Michigan Stadium on October 17 at 3:30 p.m. Eastern. Washington, preseason 17th, is the third of the eight Big Ten teams in that preseason poll to sit at 0-2 with no votes. Minnesota and Northwestern, who beat Michigan and Penn State, both received votes. Six Big Ten teams are 2-0 in the conference and seven are 0-2. In the last two Big Ten seasons every title-game team was 8-1 or better, and Michigan can finish no better than 7-2. Its at-large path is 10-2, which means winning all seven remaining games. In 2024 and 2025, 75 FBS teams lost two of their first five games. One, Notre Dame in 2025, won the rest; it finished 11th in the committee's final ranking and was not in the field. None of the 41 power-conference teams among them won out; two finished 9-3. Michigan scores 23.0 points a game, 106th of 138 FBS teams, and four of its last seven opponents are in the top 14. Tight end Zack Marshall apologized on Tuesday for leaked messages criticizing offensive coordinator Jason Beck. Andrew Sprague has missed three straight games.

Wes FerryOct 7, 20266 min read
Michigan Named Its Two Running Backs In May And Fall Camp Has Not Moved Them
Camp

Michigan Named Its Two Running Backs In May And Fall Camp Has Not Moved Them

Michigan's running back room is the one place on this roster where fall camp is a formality. Whittingham named Jordan Marshall the starter and promised eighteen-year-old Savion Hiter carries in game one, both in early May. The man whose carries those are, Justice Haynes, averaged 7.1 yards a carry for Michigan last season and is now at Georgia Tech. The game log says the staff can probably live with that, and the reason is volume rather than talent.

Grant LombardAug 13, 20264 min read