Michigan FB
Camp

The Freaks List Used To Be Where Michigan Kept Its Defensive Line

Bruce Feldman's annual list of the 101 most athletic players in college football came out Monday, and Michigan's man on it is a long snapper who transferred in from Marshall. Two Augusts ago the Wolverines put four names on it, led by a nose tackle at No. 3 overall. All four are gone, and the one holdover from last year's list switched to offense in the spring.

GL
Grant LombardAug 10, 20264 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Manuel Beigel, Michigan offensive lineman, in a posed roster portrait against a white background, wearing a navy suit jacket, white shirt and a navy and maize plaid tie carrying a small block M.

Bruce Feldman has published his Freaks list at The Athletic every August for years, 101 names long, and it works as a rough census of who in college football can do something physically ridiculous. This year's came out Monday morning.

Michigan's entry is a long snapper.

That is not a joke at anybody's expense. Gavin Magorien is real, his testing is real, and No. 78 out of 101 puts him ahead of every player in the sport who did not make the list at all.

It is still a long snapper.

Feldman's write-up, quoted in full by Von Lozon at Maize n Brew on Monday morning, has Magorien at 6-0 and 202 pounds, a sophomore who spent 2025 snapping for Marshall and played receiver and defensive back at McDowell High in Erie, Pennsylvania. The numbers: a 10-foot-10 broad jump, 26 bench reps at 225 pounds, a 550-pound squat, a 6.87-second three-cone. Feldman's own framing is that this makes a case for one of the strongest players pound-for-pound in the sport, and that qualifier is doing honest work. A 550-pound squat is 2.72 times what Magorien weighs.

(Nobody audits a squat. Figures like these come from strength coaches, which is worth remembering about every list of this kind, very much including the years the numbers flattered Michigan.)

Every one of those figures is Feldman's, relayed by Lozon, and so is the claim that Magorien is the only Wolverine on the list. None of it has been confirmed anywhere else. What can be checked is Michigan's own roster, which lists him at No. 46, LS, sophomore, 6-0, 202 pounds, Erie, Pa., McDowell. Five stated fields, five matches. Whatever else is uncertain here, nobody has the wrong guy.

(Michigan lists four long snappers on a roster of 118. One of them can squat 550 pounds.)

Anyway. The reason this is worth more than a chuckle is what the same list looked like two Augusts ago.

In 2024, Michigan put four men on it, and the highest of them was Kenneth Grant, a nose tackle, at No. 3 overall. Third. Out of everybody. Behind him, per Andrew Bailey's write-up at Maize n Brew that August, came Alex Orji at 13, Will Johnson at 28 and Marlin Klein at 90.

Mason Graham did not get a number of his own and did not need one, because Feldman put him inside Grant's entry instead, which is the part worth reading twice:

"The Wolverines have produced more freak defensive linemen in the last half-dozen years than anyone, from Rashan Gary (first-rounder), Kwity Paye (first-rounder), Aidan Hutchinson (first-rounder) and Mazi Smith (first-rounder) to Kris Jenkins (second-rounder)."

That is not a compliment about one player. It is a description of a pipeline, written in 2024 as a settled fact about the program, by the man who compiles the list.

The 2025 list carried two Wolverines, Klein at No. 35 and Manuel Beigel at No. 62, per Tony Garcia of the Detroit Free Press. Beigel was a defensive lineman. Feldman wrote that he "weighs 315 and moves like a linebacker," and that he went up the reactive plyo stairs in 2.64 seconds, faster than any other lineman in the program.

Four, then two, then a long snapper.

Grant went 13th overall to Miami. Graham went fifth to Cleveland. Johnson went 47th to Arizona out of the same draft. Klein went 59th to Houston in this year's, the fourth Michigan tight end taken in four drafts. Orji transferred to UNLV.

Of the five names Feldman attached to Michigan in 2024, not one is on the 2026 roster. Not one of the 118.

(A roster page is the only document in this sport that cannot spin. Your name is on it or it is not.)

Beigel is still here. No. 76, junior, 6-5, 312 pounds, Frankfurt, Germany.

He is listed as an offensive lineman.

(Nothing on a roster page is more consequential or less remarked upon than the two letters printed after a name.)

That switch happened in the spring, under a staff in its first year in Ann Arbor, and On3 reported it off the March roster release: Beigel, who had appeared in eight games across two seasons and four of them along the defensive line, was moving to the other side of the ball. Which is a defensible thing to do with a 312-pound man who moves like a linebacker, and a lot of programs would do it. It also means the last Michigan defensive lineman a national list certified as an outlier athlete now blocks for a living. If Lozon has the list right, the position group Feldman himself called the best supplier in the country two years ago has nobody on it at all.

None of which tells you Michigan will be bad. A Freaks list is not a depth chart, and a 550-pound squat has never tackled anybody. Gary was No. 1 on the whole thing in 2018 and then went 12th overall to Green Bay, which is the version of this that works, and plenty of players who never sniffed the top 101 have ruined a Saturday for somebody.

What the list measures, roughly, is where a roster keeps its physical outliers. At Michigan they lived on the defensive line, year after year, long enough for the man who compiles the list to write it down as a fact about the program. Then the last two went fifth and 13th in the same draft, and the one who stayed changed positions. That is the roster Kyle Whittingham inherited, described in somebody else's terms instead of his own.

Michigan opened camp on August 5. It plays Western Michigan on September 5, 7:30 at night, in Ann Arbor.

Somebody out there is going to have to make a tackle.

Sources#

Feldman's 2026 list, Magorien's ranking at No. 78 and Feldman's description of him: Von Lozon, Maize n Brew, published 2026-08-10, quoting Feldman's entry in full. The underlying list is at The Athletic; the testing figures and the lone-representative claim are single-sourced to Feldman through Lozon and are labeled as such above. Magorien's and Beigel's roster lines, the four long snappers and the 118-man count: Michigan's official roster at MGoBlue.com, read 2026-08-10. The 2025 Freaks list rankings and Feldman's quotes on Beigel: Tony Garcia, Detroit Free Press, 2025-08-04. The 2024 list, its four Michigan entries at Nos. 3, 13, 28 and 90, Graham's placement inside Grant's entry, and Feldman's quoted paragraph on the defensive-line pipeline: Andrew Bailey, Maize n Brew, 2024-08-06, quoting Feldman's entries in full. Beigel's move to the offensive line and his games played: On3, 2026-03-18, off Michigan's spring roster release. Draft slots for Graham, Grant, Johnson and Klein: 247Sports and the drafting clubs' own announcements of the 2025 and 2026 picks. Orji's transfer to UNLV: Sports Illustrated, 2025. Gary at No. 1 on the 2018 Freaks list: Maize n Brew, 2018-07-14; his selection at No. 12 overall in 2019: the Packers' own announcement of the pick. Opener date, time and site: Michigan's official 2026 schedule at MGoBlue.com, read 2026-08-10.

Filed under Michigan FB

On the record

Called Shots →
OpenAug 10, 2026

Manuel Beigel starts at least one game on Michigan's offensive line during the 2026 regular season.

Beigel was a defensive lineman when Bruce Feldman put him 62nd on the 2025 Freaks list, and Michigan's spring roster moved him to the offensive line in March under a first-year staff. The call is that the move is real rather than a depth experiment: a 6-5, 312-pound junior with two years in the program starts a game somewhere on a line that entered camp with three jobs open. It fails if he starts none, which is what a developmental flier looks like, and it fails if he starts a game back on the defensive line instead. A start is required, not an appearance. MOVED BOTH WAYS 2026-09-06, NOT SCORED. Manuel Beigel did not start: Michigan's Player Participation release lists him second in the Rhino package, "RHINO -- 89 Gach, 96 Beigel". He did play, which is the first hard evidence against Brian Cook's 2026-09-04 line that he is not in the top eight offensive linemen, and MGoBlog's own game recap says Michigan used the Rhino on roughly half its snaps and that Beigel was left in true pass protection against edge defenders, which MGoBlog says did not go well. A backup Rhino is not a start and the row still needs one.

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
The rating

Iowa's special-teams edge is 0.8 points, and three games have shrunk it

In Bill Connelly's SP+ ratings after Week 3, Iowa's special teams rate 0.5 points per game better than an average FBS unit and Michigan's rate -0.3, a gap of 0.8 points. That is the same size as the gap between the two defences, which sit 9th and 11th, even though the special-teams ranks are 7th and 108th. Every FBS special-teams rating sits between -0.6 and 0.6, a range of 1.2 points, against about 30 points on offence and on defence. ESPN's own note says early-season ratings rest mainly on preseason projections, special teams included, and the table agrees: across all 138 teams the Week 3 special-teams ratings track the final preseason ones almost exactly, and 121 teams have moved by 0.1 or less. Michigan has moved up 0.2, from -0.5, and Iowa down 0.1, from 0.6, so the gap has shrunk from 1.1 to 0.8. Michigan's counting numbers through three games are clean: 2 of 2 on field goals, 10 of 10 on extra points, 43.5 yards a punt. Iowa has missed two extra points and a field goal and averages 17.0 yards on 11 punt returns, with a touchdown. One take filed, on where Michigan's rating finishes the regular season.

Jamie SilvaSep 24, 20266 min read
Iowa's special-teams edge is 0.8 points, and three games have shrunk it
The wider view

Michigan drew five of the Big Ten's other ranked teams. Penn State drew two.

Michigan is 3-0 and 18th in the AP poll with 432 points, sixth of the seven Big Ten teams in the Top 25. Oklahoma, the 11th-ranked team Michigan beat on September 12, beat New Mexico 14-6 on Saturday and dropped out of the AP poll; it is 24th in the coaches poll. Michigan's nine Big Ten games include five of the six other ranked conference teams, everyone but USC, and those five hold 4,657 AP points, the most on any ranked Big Ten team's schedule. Penn State's two ranked conference opponents hold 1,339 and Iowa's hold 1,847. Of the five unbeaten Big Ten teams in the AP poll, Michigan is the only one ranked lower than in the preseason ballot. Indiana and Penn State have not played a team from the ACC, Big Ten, Big 12 or SEC. The 12-team playoff takes the champions of those four conferences, the highest-ranked champion from six other conferences, and the next seven highest-ranked teams. The committee publishes six rankings, the first on November 3 and the last on Selection Day, December 6. The Big Ten championship game is December 5 in Indianapolis between the top two teams in the conference standings. Michigan hosts Iowa on Saturday at 3:30 p.m. Eastern on CBS.

Wes FerrySep 23, 20266 min read
Michigan drew five of the Big Ten's other ranked teams. Penn State drew two.
Like for like

Is Bryce Underwood a better passer, or did he play Western Michigan and UTEP?

Bryce Underwood's 2026 passing line looks better than his freshman line: 50.0 percent of his dropbacks have been successful plays against 41.4 percent in 2025, and his expected points added per dropback has risen from +0.14 to +0.31. By expected points, the schedule explains all of that; by success rate, somewhere between a sixth of it and nearly all of it. Forty-nine of his 68 dropbacks this season came against Western Michigan and UTEP, against 58 of 355 against Group of Five teams in 2025. Against Group of Five opponents he completed 66.1 percent in 2025 and 66.0 percent this season. Against Oklahoma, the one Power 4 defence in both seasons, his success rate went from 20.0 percent to 31.6 percent and his expected points from -0.05 to -0.02. Reweighting his 2025 rates to this season's schedule puts his matched expected points at +0.38 or +0.33, both above his actual +0.31; the matched success-rate gain is between 0.4 and 7.2 points, inside the sampling error of 68 plays. Michigan is not throwing less by choice: on first and second down in one-score games through three quarters it has passed on 44.2 percent of plays, against 44.4 percent in 2025. Iowa's pass defence ranked 13th of 136 last season by expected points allowed per pass play; Oklahoma's was 17th. One take filed, on yards per attempt in Big Ten games.

Jamie SilvaSep 23, 20268 min read
Is Bryce Underwood a better passer, or did he play Western Michigan and UTEP?

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Game week

Michigan Would Not Name Its Two Starting Guards Because Three Seniors Are Going To Split The Job

Michigan's offensive coordinator held his final press conference before the opener on Wednesday afternoon and was asked the question that has followed this offensive line since camp opened. Jason Beck answered it with a number rather than a name. Evan Link, Nathan Efobi and Brady Norton will all play at the two guard spots, at what Beck called fairly similar snaps, and Clayton Sayfie of On3 reported that the rotation may hold for more than one game. The three tackles-and-center jobs are settled: Blake Frazier on the left, Jake Guarnera at center, Andrew Sprague on the right, the last of those hardened by Andrew Babalola's injury. Michigan's own roster still lists nineteen men as OL and nothing else, while it breaks the defensive line into ends and tackles, and on Wednesday the defensive coordinator named starters at both.

Grant LombardSep 3, 20265 min read
Michigan Would Not Name Its Two Starting Guards Because Three Seniors Are Going To Split The Job
Camp

Utah Ran A Sixth Offensive Lineman On Half Its Snaps. That Offense Is Michigan's Now.

The Rhino is a sixth offensive lineman, named for a Syracuse player, and it is older than the staff that brought it to Ann Arbor. Beck says Utah ran it 400 to 500 snaps last season. Utah ran 962 offensive plays in 2025, so his range is 42% to 52% of everything they did, and an independent charting of one game puts it at nearly half.

Wes FerryAug 9, 20265 min read
Utah Ran A Sixth Offensive Lineman On Half Its Snaps. That Offense Is Michigan's Now.
The depth chart

Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass

At his first Big Ten Media Days, Whittingham said Tommy Carr is Michigan's backup quarterback without a doubt, putting a true freshman who has never taken a college snap ahead of Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, who threw 969 passes at Colorado State. In the same session he said Bryce Underwood arrived not nearly as fundamentally sound as he needed to be, and pointed at how the position was staffed in 2025, when the offensive coordinator carried the quarterbacks title as well. Camp opens August 5.

Grant LombardAug 1, 20265 min read
Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass