Camp

Michigan's 4 Captains Are February's 4 Captains. The 12 Names Underneath Them Are Not

Michigan's players voted on leadership twice this year, in February and again on Monday night, and the top of the document did not move: the same 4 men. The council underneath it did. 3 names came on and 2 came off, and 1 of the 2 who came off is the only tight end either vote has ever named on a roster carrying 8 of them.

WF
Wes FerryAug 18, 20266 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Troy Bowles, Michigan linebacker, in a posed roster portrait against a white background, wearing a navy suit jacket, a white shirt and a gray checked tie carrying a small maize block M. No jersey and no number are in the frame.

Michigan has published no depth chart and is not obliged to until game week. What it has published, twice, is a list of the players its own locker room voted to follow.

The first went out February 2: 4 spring captains and an 11-man council, with a note that the exercise would be repeated and the real thing elected in fall camp. The second went out Monday night at 8:35 and did exactly that, 4 captains and a 12-man council. Two documents, 6 months apart, sorting the same roster. The interesting part is not either list. It is the difference between them.

The 4 at the top did not move#

Quarterback Bryce Underwood (19), running back Jordan Marshall (23), safety Rod Moore (1) and defensive tackle Trey Pierce (95) were the spring captains in February and they are the captains now. Moore is the only returning captain from last season, and the program's release calls him the first player in school history to be voted a 3-time captain. Michigan's own archive complicates that. The Bentley Historical Library, the university's repository for its athletic records, carries a page headed "Horace G. Prettyman, Football Captain, 1884-1886." Whether a captaincy in 1884 was the teammate ballot the release is claiming a first for is not settled anywhere public, so the safe version of the sentence is that Moore is the first 3-time captain of the modern era and the athletic department is claiming more than that.

Which is why Kyle Whittingham introducing Pierce at Big Ten Media Days on July 30 as "one of our captains," per Trent Knoop of Sports Illustrated, was simply accurate 18 days early. Michigan took 3 players to Chicago and all 3, Underwood, Marshall and Pierce, already had the title.

The 12 underneath them moved by 5#

Nine carried over: Nico Andrighetto, Zeke Berry and Jyaire Hill (0) in the secondary, Cam Brandt and Enow Etta (17) on the line, Blake Frazier (77), Jake Guarnera (53) and Andrew Sprague (54) up front, and receiver Andrew Marsh (3).

On: linebacker Troy Bowles (18), receiver JJ Buchanan (6), defensive end John Henry Daley (90). Off: safety Mason Curtis (25), tight end Zack Marshall (83).

The new list is 7 offense, 9 defense, 0 specialists. Curtis is still in the mix at safety per Charles Post of Maize n Brew, so a name off a council is not a name off a two-deep, and a vote is not a depth chart. What it shows is where a locker room's attention moved over 6 months. It moved to 3 places and away from 2.

The tight ends had a name in February and have none now#

Zack Marshall is the only tight end either vote has produced, and he is Michigan's most productive returner at the position: 16 receptions for 199 yards and 1 touchdown in 2025, work he got while Hogan Hansen (80) fought injuries.

Twelve days before the vote, offensive coordinator Jason Beck answered a question about him in the language of leadership, naming him among the strength staff's summer standouts and saying Michigan anticipated him being a piece of the offense "based off his involvement last year, but also based off his leadership and work ethic this summer," per Drew Lenard of The Michigan Daily. Marshall missed all of spring practice injured, which is the plainest available explanation for a man being visible to a strength coach and less visible to a roomful of teammates on a field.

Whatever the reason, the room is now at 0 names out of 8 players, Marshall and Hansen alongside Deakon Tonielli (88), Jimmy Pisani (40) and 4 others. It is the largest group on the roster with nobody on the list, and the one Jacob Westendorf of Sports Illustrated described on August 12 as still waiting for a contributor to emerge.

The linebackers went the other way, and the specialists went nowhere twice#

February's council had no linebacker on it. Monday's has Bowles, on the unit with the most to replace: Michigan lost 3 of its top 5 tacklers from 2025 in Jimmy Rolder, Ernest Hausmann and Cole Sullivan, all linebackers, as Justice Steiner of Sports Illustrated laid out on July 24. It is 1 name out of 14 players, which is thin, and it is the only group on the roster that gained ground between the 2 votes.

The competition, per Post on August 12, is Bowles, Nathaniel Owusu-Boateng (12), Nathaniel Staehling (44) and Chase Taylor (29), with defensive coordinator Jay Hill having singled out Bowles and Taylor on day one. Staehling is the useful absence. He arrived from North Dakota State with 75 tackles and 3 interceptions in 2025, missed spring injured, and is getting his first real look at this defense in August. Whittingham on him, per Matt Hartwell of Maize n Brew: "he's a guy that's going to figure prominently in the defense this year." A head coach saying that is a stronger claim about the two-deep than a leadership vote is, and Staehling could not have been on either one.

The specialists are the hardest number here. Michigan carries 3 kickers, 3 punters and 4 long snappers. Across 2 votes, 6 months apart, this locker room has named 18 different men and not one of the 10. Nobody has published a starter at any of the 3 jobs either.

Three open line jobs and a 4-day deadline#

Michigan has 19 offensive linemen, 3 of them on the list. Guarnera has center, on the flattest sentence this staff has produced about anything: offensive line coach Jim Harding said it would take Guarnera "really screwing something up for me to not feel comfortable playing him on the 5th of September," per Anthony Broome of On3. Sprague has right tackle, which Harding called his to lose. Left tackle is a 3-man race between Frazier, Andrew Babalola (65) and Evan Link (71), per Post. Frazier started 8 games there last season after Link's season-ending injury, and Babalola is a redshirt freshman back from an ACL injury, a full participant as of early this month per Harding. The 2 guard spots are contested by Nathan Efobi (55), Brady Norton (70) and Link. Whittingham believes Michigan is 10 deep on the line. He has not said which 5.

Harding has put a date on it. Asked in the first week of camp for a timeline, he declined to give one and then gave one anyway: he wants the group "solidified" roughly 2 weeks out, at the end of the second scrimmage. Michigan held the first of its 2 scrimmages on Saturday, August 15, per Tony Garcia of the Detroit Free Press. Two weeks out is about August 22, which is 4 days from today.

The captain nobody describes the same way twice#

Rod Moore has been a captain in both votes and has barely played in 2 years, and in a single week 3 outlets put him in 3 different places. Post wrote on August 12 that he is "fully healthy" and that Whittingham has him and Chris Bracy (7) with the inside track at the 2 safety jobs. Westendorf wrote the same day that he was expected to be full go by the Oklahoma game on September 12, a week after the opener. Hartwell wrote on August 17 that he is "once again practicing." Michigan publishes no availability report in August and is not required to, so the state of its most decorated leader 18 days out is that he is practicing and that the people who watch him do not agree what that means for September 5.

Whittingham named the condition himself in Chicago, before any of it was contested. "We've got some work to do in the depth department at a few positions," he said. "I think in a year or two we'll be right where we need to be across the board."

Michigan's players have now answered that question twice. The second answer is mostly the first one, and where it is not, it is a linebacker moving up and a tight end moving off.


Sources: MGoBlue.com for the February 2, 2026 spring captains and leadership council release (Dave Ablauf and Chad Shepard), for the August 17 captains and leadership council release, for the 2026 football roster and for every jersey number and position-group count in this piece, all read off the official roster page. Brandon Carr, All About Ann Arbor, August 18, 2026, for independent corroboration of the August captains and council. Trent Knoop, Sports Illustrated, July 31, 2026, for Whittingham's Big Ten Media Days remarks on Trey Pierce, Blake Frazier and offensive line depth, and February 2, 2026 for the spring captains. Drew Lenard, The Michigan Daily, August 6, 2026, for Jason Beck on Zack Marshall and for Marshall's 2025 production and spring absence. Matt Hartwell, Maize n Brew, August 17, 2026, for Whittingham on Nathaniel Staehling and for the state of the safety and linebacker rooms. Charles Post, Maize n Brew, August 12, 2026, for the offensive line, linebacker and safety competitions and Jay Hill's day-one remark. Jacob Westendorf, Sports Illustrated, August 12, 2026, for the cornerback order and the tight end room. Justice Steiner, Sports Illustrated, July 24, 2026, for the 2025 linebacker departures. Tony Garcia, Detroit Free Press, August 17, 2026, for the August 15 scrimmage. Anthony Broome, On3, August 6, 2026, for Jim Harding on Guarnera, Sprague, Babalola and the August timeline. Michigan's 2026 schedule for the September 5 opener. The Bentley Historical Library's football captains index, bentley.umich.edu, for Horace G. Prettyman, 1884-1886. Nobody from this site was at any practice, scrimmage or press conference described here.

Filed under Michigan FB

More on JJ Buchanan

His page →
JJ Buchanan, probably done, caught more long passes than the rest of Michigan
Injury

JJ Buchanan, probably done, caught more long passes than the rest of Michigan

Kyle Whittingham said on Monday, November 16, that wide receiver JJ Buchanan is probably out for the rest of the season with the left shoulder injury he suffered at Oregon. Buchanan leads Michigan with 646 receiving yards and five touchdowns on 40 catches, about two of every five receiving yards the team has. By the official play-by-play he caught 10 of Michigan's 19 completions of 20 yards or more; Andrew Marsh, the other half of the passing game, has 48 catches at 9.6 yards each and has caught one of the 15 throws tagged deep to him. Whittingham also said Andrew Sprague will not return and Blake Frazier is a long shot for this week, and that the quarterback job is open again between Bryce Underwood and Tommy Carr. Michigan is 5-5 and plays unbeaten UCLA on Saturday.

Grant LombardNov 16, 20264 min read
Five Oregon completions gained 228 yards, and Michigan threw for 71
Takeaways

Five Oregon completions gained 228 yards, and Michigan threw for 71

Oregon beat Michigan 31-7 at Autzen Stadium on November 14. Five Dylan Raiola completions of 22 yards or more gained 228 of his 341 passing yards and produced three touchdowns. Michigan ran for 215 yards, 107 of them by Savion Hiter, but completed 6 of 20 passes for 71 yards, lost JJ Buchanan to a trip to the hospital in the second quarter, and had all five of its full second-half possessions end on downs or a fumble. Michigan is 5-5 and plays undefeated UCLA on Saturday.

Wes FerryNov 15, 20266 min read
Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost
Takeaways

Michigan's defense scored as many touchdowns as the offense, and Michigan lost

Minnesota beat Michigan 20-14 at Huntington Bank Stadium, its first win over Michigan since 2014 and its first in Minneapolis since 1977. Michigan led 14-7 at halftime on Jordan Marshall's 5-yard run and Nathaniel Staehling's 79-yard interception return, then turned the ball over on a muffed punt and two Bryce Underwood interceptions in a span of 7:31. Minnesota scored 13 points off those turnovers on drives of 4, 34 and 35 yards. Michigan's offense gained 180 yards, its fewest of the season, held the ball for 41 seconds of the third quarter, and ran eight plays for no net yards between its touchdown and the fourth quarter. Underwood was 10 of 21 for 101 yards and was sacked three times. The running backs carried 18 times for 59 yards. Michigan's defense forced two turnovers, allowed one scoring drive longer than 35 yards and had no sacks. Michigan's last drive ended with two timeouts unused. JJ Buchanan, Nathan Efobi and Chase Taylor each went down during the game, and Kyle Whittingham said a couple of players could not finish without naming them. Michigan is 3-2 and 0-2 in the Big Ten.

Wes FerryOct 4, 20266 min read

More on Zack Marshall

His page →
Michigan and Penn State were ranked in August but got no votes Sunday
The wider view

Michigan and Penn State were ranked in August but got no votes Sunday

Michigan received no votes in either poll on Sunday, October 4, after losing 20-14 at Minnesota. A week earlier it had 54 AP points and was 24th in the coaches poll. Penn State, which lost 34-13 at Northwestern, also received none. They were 16th and 18th in the preseason AP poll and meet at Michigan Stadium on October 17 at 3:30 p.m. Eastern. Washington, preseason 17th, is the third of the eight Big Ten teams in that preseason poll to sit at 0-2 with no votes. Minnesota and Northwestern, who beat Michigan and Penn State, both received votes. Six Big Ten teams are 2-0 in the conference and seven are 0-2. In the last two Big Ten seasons every title-game team was 8-1 or better, and Michigan can finish no better than 7-2. Its at-large path is 10-2, which means winning all seven remaining games. In 2024 and 2025, 75 FBS teams lost two of their first five games. One, Notre Dame in 2025, won the rest; it finished 11th in the committee's final ranking and was not in the field. None of the 41 power-conference teams among them won out; two finished 9-3. Michigan scores 23.0 points a game, 106th of 138 FBS teams, and four of its last seven opponents are in the top 14. Tight end Zack Marshall apologized on Tuesday for leaked messages criticizing offensive coordinator Jason Beck. Andrew Sprague has missed three straight games.

Wes FerryOct 7, 20266 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
MissedAug 18, 2026

True freshman receiver Travis Johnson (No. 13) catches at least 1 pass in the September 5 opener against Western Michigan.

Johnson is the clearest riser of Michigan's camp. Tony Garcia of the Detroit Free Press reported that he was named a standout of the August 15 scrimmage; Hartwell reported on August 17 that cornerback Jyaire Hill named Johnson among the hardest young receivers to cover, that Jaime Ffrench praised his speed, and that Andrew Marsh spoke well of him, and framed him as possibly forcing his way into the two- or three-deep immediately. Against the call: Michigan's top 2 receivers are settled in Marsh and Buchanan, the WR3 job is contested by at least Ffrench and Salesi Moa as well, and a true freshman can dress and never be targeted in a season opener a team expects to control. This is a playing-time call rather than a talent call.

Latest on the Michigan FB

The whole beat →
Michigan plays 6 of the committee's top 25. Its bowl is a coin flip
The wider view

Michigan plays 6 of the committee's top 25. Its bowl is a coin flip

The College Football Playoff selection committee's third top 25, released November 17, put Oklahoma 22nd, which makes Michigan's 17-10 win in September its first over a team the committee ranks. Six of Michigan's 12 regular-season games are against teams in that ranking, tied with seven SEC teams for the most in FBS. Michigan is 5-5 and 1-3 in those games so far. By DraftKings' moneylines with the margin removed, it has about a 38% chance against UCLA and 18% at Ohio State, which puts its chance of a sixth win at about 49%.

Wes FerryNov 18, 20265 min read
Michigan ran for 215 yards at Oregon, and ran exactly as well as it always does
Deep dive

Michigan ran for 215 yards at Oregon, and ran exactly as well as it always does

Savion Hiter's career-high 107 yards at Oregon were 70 on one carry and 37 on twelve others, and 3 of his 13 carries succeeded by the standard college measure. Bryson Kuzdzal succeeded on 5 of 9. As a team Michigan's runs succeeded at 39%, its season rate exactly. Its 16 early-down dropbacks succeeded 4 times, its lowest rate in any game this season, so its 13 third downs averaged 8.7 yards to go and only 3 were 3 yards or shorter. UCLA, next, has held 7 of its 10 opponents under 100 rushing yards.

Wes FerryNov 16, 20266 min read
Michigan needs about 14 points at Oregon. It scored 6 in two of its last three
Game day

Michigan needs about 14 points at Oregon. It scored 6 in two of its last three

Michigan (5-4) plays at 18th-ranked Oregon (6-3) at 12:30 p.m. Pacific on FS1 as a 10.5-point underdog, one win from bowl eligibility, in its first game since firing offensive coordinator Jason Beck. The Big Ten's Friday report lists Oregon outside linebacker Teitum Tuioti, who has 5.5 of Oregon's 19 sacks, Out, and Michigan offensive lineman Blake Frazier Doubtful. Tommy Carr is expected to start at quarterback, ESPN reported, with Bryce Underwood likely to play.

Wes FerryNov 14, 20265 min read

Earlier on the Michigan FB

Michigan had third down at Indiana's 1 and 3, and lost yards both times
Takeaways

Michigan had third down at Indiana's 1 and 3, and lost yards both times

Indiana beat Michigan 13-6 in overtime at Michigan Stadium in front of 111,276, its first win there since 1967. Michigan is 4-3 and 1-3 in the Big Ten. Michigan had the ball inside the Indiana 23 on five possessions and scored two field goals. Three of the five ended with Tommy Carr sacked on third down, including a 13-yard loss on third-and-1 from the Indiana 1 that Kyle Whittingham called 'not a good football call,' and a 5-yard loss on third-and-3 from the 3 with 32 seconds left. Trey Butkowski, 4 of 4 on field goals before Saturday, missed from 53 and 32. Indiana's six points in regulation both came on short fields after Carr's two turnovers; its nine other regulation possessions, all starting in its own territory, produced nothing. Josh Hoover, playing hurt per Curt Cignetti, was 8 of 18 for 81 yards and threw his first interception of the season, to Zeke Berry. Michigan ran 42 times for 57 yards, its running backs 26 times for 52. In his first start Carr was 20 of 32 for 167 yards; no completion travelled more than 18 yards past the line. Blake Frazier and Dom Nichols were ruled out on game day; Marky Walbridge started at right tackle and Benny Patterson III made his first career start. Michigan plays at Rutgers on Saturday.

Wes FerryOct 25, 20266 min read
To Find Out What Michigan Football Pays, Ask Ohio
The money

To Find Out What Michigan Football Pays, Ask Ohio

Michigan Athletics announced two future non-conference games on August 28: Bowling Green at Michigan Stadium on August 25, 2029, and Charlotte on September 9, 2028. FBSchedules had published the Bowling Green game and its $1.6 million guarantee on August 19, off a copy of the contract obtained from Bowling Green State University through an Ohio open records request. The Charlotte story, by the same writer on the day of the announcement, carries no figure and is sourced to Michigan. The pattern holds at higher stakes: Utah's August 3 suit against Michigan tight ends coach Freddie Whittingham put a $525,000 salary, a 75 percent liquidated-damages formula and six departing assistants into a public record on August 20. Michigan's own account of what the coaching change cost is one clause in the FY2027 budget presentation: salaries, wages and benefits up $2.53 million, due in part to football staff transition costs and annual salary increases, not broken out.

Grant LombardSep 3, 20266 min read
Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass
The depth chart

Michigan's Backup Quarterback Has Never Thrown A College Pass

At his first Big Ten Media Days, Whittingham said Tommy Carr is Michigan's backup quarterback without a doubt, putting a true freshman who has never taken a college snap ahead of Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, who threw 969 passes at Colorado State. In the same session he said Bryce Underwood arrived not nearly as fundamentally sound as he needed to be, and pointed at how the position was staffed in 2025, when the offensive coordinator carried the quarterbacks title as well. Camp opens August 5.

Grant LombardAug 1, 20265 min read