The margin

A Price Can Move Six Cents Without Anybody Changing Their Mind

Four MLB games this morning show one side holding far more money than bets. On the posted prices, the money side has been right once in four. Take the sportsbook's margin out of both numbers and it has been right three times in four, and the difference is not an opinion about baseball.

CM
Casey MontgomeryAug 14, 20267 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
An illustration in flat burnt orange, black and off-white: a single large circle split into two near-equal arcs, one orange and one black, each drawn slightly too large for the circle so that the two cross in a narrow crosshatched wedge down the middle.

Seventy-five percent of the money bet at DraftKings on tonight's game in New York is on Washington. The Nationals opened at plus 104 and they are plus 105 this morning.

Read those two sentences together and something is wrong. Money is supposed to shorten a price. Three quarters of the dollars sit on the Nationals, the Nationals got a cent cheaper, and the standard reading of that is a market ignoring its own sharpest customers.

The standard reading is wrong, and the reason is a third number nobody prints.

The margin, and why it makes a price lie to you#

Convert a price into the probability it implies. Washington at plus 105 means a hundred dollars wins a hundred and five, so the implied probability is 100 divided by 205, or 48.78 percent. The Mets at minus 113 implies 113 divided by 213, or 53.05 percent.

Add them. One of those two teams wins tonight, so an honest pair would sum to 100. They sum to 101.83.

That extra 1.83 is the margin, also called the overround or the vig, and it is the sportsbook's cut. It sits inside both prices at once, in the same direction, making each side look likelier than the book actually thinks it is. Divide both by 1.0183 and you get the book's real read: Washington 47.90 percent, the Mets 52.10.

Now run the identical arithmetic on the opening price. Washington plus 104 and the Mets minus 126 implies 49.02 and 55.75, which sums to 104.77. The opener carried 4.77 points of margin. Strip it and the real read on Washington at the open was 46.79 percent.

So the honest number on the Nationals went from 46.79 to 47.90. It moved a full point toward the side holding three quarters of the money, which is exactly what should happen, while the posted price went the other way by a cent.

Here is the same fact stated as a price, because that is the form a reader actually meets it in. Washington's current honest probability of 47.90 percent, quoted inside the opener's fat 4.77 percent margin, would be posted at minus 101, a hair the wrong side of even money. Quoted inside this morning's 1.83, it is posted at plus 105. Same opinion, six cents apart, counting even money once on the way through. The opinion moved the price five cents shorter and the margin moved it six cents longer, and the six won.

Nobody changed their mind about the Nationals by six cents. The market simply got closer to first pitch, and a market gets thinner and cheaper as it matures, because more books are up, limits are higher, and the early wide number nobody could bet in size has been competed away.

Four games qualify this morning, and the two scoring methods disagree#

I check DraftKings' published splits every Friday for games where one moneyline side holds a handle share (the weight of cash) at least 25 points above its ticket share (the count of bets, one per customer regardless of size). Four of the ten games carried on that page this morning clear the bar. All figures below were read at 10:23 a.m. Pacific.

Seattle at Houston is the widest: the Mariners hold 77 percent of the money on 30 percent of the bets. Baltimore at Tampa Bay is next, the Orioles at 60 and 19. Cleveland holds 83 percent of the money against San Diego on 53 percent of the bets, and Washington sits at 75 and 50.

Score those four on the posted price against the opener and the money side is right once. Seattle shortened from plus 108 to plus 106. Washington lengthened a cent, Cleveland got three cents cheaper at minus 128, and Baltimore lengthened twelve.

Score them on the honest number and it is a different morning.

Take the margin out and three of the four money sides gained

Change in de-vigged win probability, in percentage points, on the side holding the larger share of DraftKings' moneyline handle, from the consensus opening price to this morning's price. Positive means the honest number moved toward the money. Openers and consensus prices from VegasInsider's Las Vegas MLB board, page dated 8/13/26; splits and paired prices from DraftKings, read 2026-08-14 at 10:23 a.m. Pacific. Margin removed proportionally from both sides of each pair. Four qualifying games of the ten carried on that page.

Mariners +10677% of money, 30% of bets · posted price also shortened
+1.80
Nationals +10575% of money, 50% of bets · posted price looked a cent worse
+1.11
Guardians -12883% of money, 53% of bets · posted price looked three cents cheaper
+0.91
Orioles +14760% of money, 19% of bets · posted price moved twelve cents away
-0.91

One of four becomes three of four. The four margins collapsed from 4.53, 4.56, 4.77 and 4.79 percent at the open to between 1.73 and 1.83 this morning, which is remarkably uniform across four unrelated games and is the whole reason the two methods disagree.

Four games on one morning is not evidence of anything about baseball. It is a demonstration that the measuring instrument matters more than the measurement, and that part generalizes.

This breaks a call I made in public two weeks ago#

On July 31 this desk filed a scoreable call on exactly these games: that on the eight Friday cards through September 25, the money side's consensus closing moneyline would finish shorter than the price printed beside its split in at least 60 percent of qualifying cases.

That standard is a posted-price standard. It measures the margin as well as the money, and this morning's arithmetic says the margin can be the larger of the two.

The honest size of the problem, which is smaller than the paragraph above implies. The damage runs from the open to the read, where 2.9 points of margin came out. From a 10:23 a.m. read to a closing number the remaining collapse is on the order of a point, and a point of margin is worth roughly two cents on a plus 105 underdog. So the call is not broken. It is biased against itself by a couple of cents per game, in the direction of scoring FALSE, on a threshold of 60 percent.

I am not touching it. A call whose method was fixed in advance and then adjusted by its author when the arithmetic got inconvenient is worth nothing, and the whole value of writing these down is that they grade as written. It stands, and if it scores FALSE by a hair I will say in public that the standard rather than the thesis is what failed.

What I can do is file the better instrument beside it and let both run. That is at the bottom.

Baltimore is the one that actually moved against its money#

Strip the margin from the Orioles and they still went the wrong way: 40.71 percent at the open, 39.80 this morning. That is a real move against a side holding 60 percent of the moneyline cash on 19 percent of the tickets, and the run line in the same game says the same thing louder, with 90 percent of the money on Baltimore plus 1.5 against 16 percent of the bets.

So the dollars are on Baltimore in two separate markets, the bet count is against Baltimore in both, and the price walked away from the dollars by twelve cents.

I have not established what did that, and I am not going to guess at it in print. A pitching change, a lineup card, weather, or a book unloading last night's exposure will all move a baseball price without anybody sharp having an opinion. The useful thing is that this is the one game of four where the correction does not rescue the reading, which makes it the game worth watching tonight rather than the three that behaved.

The counter-case#

Proportional margin removal is a choice. Splitting the overround in proportion to each side's implied probability is standard and it is not the only method. On a near-even market the alternatives land within a couple of tenths of a point, and all four games here are near even, the longest being Baltimore at plus 147. On a heavy favorite the choice matters much more, and none of this arithmetic should be carried over to a minus 300 board without redoing it.

An opener is not a price most people could have taken. The 4.7 percent margin at the open is partly a real cost and partly an artifact of an early market with low limits and few books posting. Calling the collapse from 4.7 to 1.8 a saving assumes a bettor who could have transacted at the open in size, and most could not.

The splits and the closing number come from different populations. The split describes DraftKings' customers. The consensus price is eight books. A conclusion drawn by comparing one book's cash against eight books' prices is softer than it looks, and that is a flaw in my own method rather than a hedge.

Four is four. Two of the three margins that flipped a verdict are under 1.2 points, which is inside the range that a different de-vig method or a fifteen-minute-later read could produce on its own.

The four games that are not on the page at all#

DraftKings carried splits for ten games this morning. Fourteen are scheduled.

The four missing are the four latest: Kansas City at the Angels, Texas at the Athletics, Milwaukee at the Dodgers, and Colorado at San Francisco, first pitch 10:15 Eastern. Every game starting after 8:10 p.m. Eastern is absent, which is every West Coast game on the card.

A reader in the Bay Area who wants to know what the money is doing on the Giants tonight cannot find out from the page that the rest of the country is quoting. That is not price shading and it is not the fan tax, which is a different subject and needs a real sample before this desk asserts it. It is something plainer: the market information that gets published is published on Eastern time, and a Giants bettor is structurally last in line for it.

It is also a defect in the call I filed, and I would rather name it than have it named for me. The population that call grades against is not the day's card. It is whichever subset of the card DraftKings had posted at the hour I read it, and that subset systematically excludes the two Bay Area clubs. Tonight it is 10 of 14. That count gets printed every Friday from here.

The call#

No plays. This desk's betting record exists and is empty, and it stays empty until the machinery behind it is built, because a play logged without the apparatus to grade it honestly is a tout sheet with better manners.

One call, filed at today's numbers and scoreable by a stranger with a calculator: on the six remaining Friday cards through September 25, in qualifying games, the money side's de-vigged win probability rises from the morning read to the consensus close in at least 60 percent of cases, while the same side's posted American price shortens in fewer than 50 percent of cases.

The gap between those two figures is the entire claim. If both come out the same, the margin correction is decoration and I have spent a column teaching a distinction that does not exist. If the second figure lands above the first, the posted price is a better instrument than the honest one and I have it backwards. Under 20 qualifying games it voids, and the count gets printed either way.

What would make this wrong. If the margin at the morning read is already close to the margin at the close, there is nothing left to collapse and the two methods converge, which would show up as the two percentages landing within a few points of each other. And if the money side simply is not predictive, both methods score under 60 and the correction is a better measurement of a thesis that was never true. I would rather find that out on six Fridays of printed counts than assume it for a season.

The read

A baseball moneyline carries about 4.7 percent of the sportsbook's margin when it opens and about 1.8 by late morning, and on a near-even game that collapse alone pushes the underdog's posted price about six cents longer without one person changing their mind. Two of this morning's four heavy-money sides look like losers on the posted number and winners on the honest one, which takes the scoreboard from one of four to three of four. Before calling anything line movement, convert both sides to probabilities, add them, and divide out the excess: it is two minutes with a calculator and it is the difference between reading a market and reading a marketing document. Nothing here is advice. It is a public record of calls made at stated prices, and every figure in it can be re-pulled by anyone who wants to check me.

Splits, paired prices and the game count: DraftKings' published game splits, read 2026-08-14 at 10:23 a.m. Pacific. Opening and consensus moneylines: VegasInsider's Las Vegas MLB board, page dated 8/13/26. Full schedule and start times: ESPN's MLB schedule for August 14, 2026. Implied probabilities and margin removal use the standard proportional method. The July 31 call referenced above is on this site's Called Shots ledger with its method fixed as filed.

Betting content is for readers 21 and over. If gambling stops being entertainment, the National Problem Gambling Helpline is 1-800-522-4700, free, confidential, and answered 24 hours a day.

Filed under Giants
The betting recordRecord 0-1Units -0.5Open 1All of it →

21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Latest on the Giants

The whole beat →
The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed
Rule 5

The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed

On November 17, 2026, the San Francisco Giants selected the contracts of left-hander Henry Lalane and right-handers Marty Gair and Josh Bostick, protecting all three from the Rule 5 draft, and designated Rowan Wick and Christian Koss for assignment. The club had one open spot after trading Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on November 15, and the 40-man roster is back to 40. Bostick, a 2023 eighth-round pick, missed the 2026 season with a torn Achilles; in 2025 he had a 3.71 ERA in 119 innings at High-A Eugene. Left off were Joe Whitman, who had a 3.54 ERA in 134 2/3 innings at Double-A and Triple-A, and Luis De La Torre, who struck out 27.2 percent and walked 17.7 percent of High-A batters. Both are Rule 5 eligible by their signing dates.

Grant LombardNov 18, 20263 min read
Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.
Cooperstown

Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.

The Baseball Hall of Fame announced the 2027 Baseball Writers' Association of America ballot on November 16, 2026: 27 former players, 14 of them on it for the first time, including Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval. Results are announced Tuesday, January 19, 2027, at 6 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network; election takes 75 percent of ballots, and a player needs 5 percent to stay on. By Baseball-Reference, Posey had 45.0 WAR in 12 seasons and a seven-year peak (WAR7) of 36.5, against 53.7 and 34.9 for the average of the 17 Hall of Fame catchers; his JAWS of 40.8 ranks 14th among catchers. Joe Mauer, elected on his first ballot in 2024 with 293 of 385 votes (76.1 percent), had 55.6 WAR, a 39.1 WAR7 and a 47.4 JAWS, and caught 921 games to Posey's 1,093. Sandoval, the 2012 World Series MVP, had 19.1 WAR in 14 seasons. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 17, 20263 min read
Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms
The 2027 Giants

Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms

San Francisco traded right-hander Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on Sunday for minor league right-handers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry. Neither joins the 40-man roster, which fell from 40 names to 39 two days before the November 17 deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 draft and five days before the November 20 tender deadline. Walker, who turns 31 on November 26, had a 7.16 ERA in 33 games and 32 2/3 innings in 2026 with 19 walks, after a 1.91 ERA in 80 innings in 2024, and recorded 31 saves in 226 games for the Giants from 2023 to 2026. Holub, 28, had a 2.10 ERA in 50 games and 55 2/3 innings for Triple-A Nashville with 66 strikeouts and 21 walks; Milwaukee acquired him from Detroit for Mark Canha in November 2023, and he is not on a 40-man roster. Perry, 23, was Milwaukee's 11th-round pick in July out of Western Kentucky and has not made his professional debut. Milwaukee's 40-man roster went from 33 to 34. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 15, 20264 min read

Earlier on the Giants

Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach
The 2027 Giants

Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach

On September 29 Buster Posey said the Giants' offseason work starts with the bullpen. At the General Managers Meetings on November 10 he said Randy Rodríguez had been shut down in the Arizona Fall League with elbow pain and would preferably not close at the start of 2027, and that signing a free agent who received a qualifying offer would be 'harder for us' after the club gave up four draft picks in two years for Matt Chapman, Blake Snell and Willy Adames. The finished change is the hiring of James Rowson as offensive coordinator, for an offense that drew the fewest walks of the 30 clubs. The 40-man roster is full at 40 ahead of the November 17 protection deadline, Camilo Doval's tender decision is due November 20, and the labor agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 1.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20265 min read
Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings
The 2027 Giants

Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings

Henry Lalane, 22, was eligible for the Rule 5 draft in December 2025 and no club took him. In 2026 he threw 105 innings across Single-A Tampa, High-A Hudson Valley, High-A Eugene and one postseason outing at Double-A Richmond, more than his previous four seasons combined, and his fastball moved from 91 or 92 mph to the mid-90s, MLB.com reported. He struck out 32.8 percent of the batters he faced at Tampa and 16.8 percent in five starts for Eugene after the Giants acquired him for Heliot Ramos on Aug. 3. The Giants must add him to the 40-man roster by Nov. 17 or expose him again.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20264 min read
The Giants calls that carried a price hit 11 of 20. The prices expected 9.4.
The season, scored

The Giants calls that carried a price hit 11 of 20. The prices expected 9.4.

The Giants section of the Called Shots ledger finished the regular season at 38 right, 28 wrong and 2 void. A hit rate says little until it is set against the odds each call carried. The twenty priced calls beat their prices by about one and a half hits, all of it in five short-priced favorites, on a sample too small to call anything but calibrated.

Jamie SilvaOct 1, 20267 min read