Cooperstown

Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.

Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval are on the Baseball Writers' Hall of Fame ballot for the first time. The writers announce on January 19 whether a short career with a tall peak is enough, and Joe Mauer's 76.1 percent is the nearest answer they have given.

GL
Grant LombardNov 17, 20263 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Buster Posey, in the Giants' grey road uniform and a black batting helmet, waits in his stance with the bat raised at Citizens Bank Park in Philadelphia, Brandon Belt on deck behind him and the Phillies catcher crouched in red at the left edge.

The Hall of Fame put out the 2027 writers' ballot on Monday, and two men from the 2010, 2012 and 2014 Giants are on it for the first time: Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval.

There are 27 names in all, 14 of them new. The other first-timers include Jon Lester, Jake Arrieta, Andrew Miller, Ryan Zimmerman, Brett Gardner and Kyle Seager. The returnees are led by Chase Utley, who got 59.1 percent last winter, and Omar Vizquel, who is on his last try. The members of the Baseball Writers' Association of America with ten straight years on the beat vote, and on Tuesday, January 19, at 6 p.m. Eastern, MLB Network announces who reached 75 percent.

(This is not the vote on Bruce Bochy, Dusty Baker and Brian Sabean. That one belongs to a 16-member committee and happens December 6. Different room, different math, same franchise hogging the chairs.)

A tall man in a short house#

Posey's case is a single question asked two ways, and Baseball-Reference has both answers on one page.

Asked as a career, it is a short one. Posey played 12 seasons and 1,371 games before he retired after 2021, and Baseball-Reference credits him with 45.0 wins above replacement. The 17 Hall of Fame catchers on Baseball-Reference's JAWS board average 53.7. By JAWS, the site's blend of career and peak, Posey's 40.8 ranks 14th all time among catchers, and the Hall average is 44.3.

Asked as a peak, it is a different conversation. WAR7, the sum of a player's seven best seasons, has Posey at 36.5. The average Hall of Fame catcher is at 34.9. His best seven years were better than theirs. He just did not stay long enough to pile up the rest.

The peak has receipts attached. Rookie of the Year in 2010. MVP in 2012. A batting title, seven All-Star games, five Silver Sluggers, a Gold Glove, three rings. A .302/.372/.460 line and a 129 OPS+, which means he hit about 29 percent better than a league-average hitter while doing the job that wrecks hitters.

The Mauer test#

The writers have already graded the nearest version of this paper. Joe Mauer, another catcher who hit for average and finished his career somewhere else on the field, went in on his first ballot in 2024 with 293 of 385 votes. That is 76.1 percent, 1.1 points clear of the line.

Mauer had more of almost everything Baseball-Reference counts: 55.6 WAR, a 39.1 WAR7, a 47.4 JAWS that ranks seventh among catchers, 15 seasons, 2,123 hits to Posey's 1,500. The one column Posey wins is the one that defines the position. He caught 1,093 games. Mauer caught 921, then moved to first base for his last five seasons.

So the writers face a fair version of the question they answered narrowly for Mauer. Posey has less career, about the same peak, more time behind the plate and three championships to Mauer's none. Whether that adds up to 75 percent of the room is the whole story between now and January, and it is a real question, not a coronation.

One clause on the obvious: Posey now runs the Giants as president of baseball operations. Nobody votes on that.

The Kung Fu Panda line#

Sandoval's number is 5, not 75. He played 14 seasons from 2008 to 2021, had 19.1 WAR, two All-Star selections and a .278/.330/.443 line, and was the MVP of the 2012 World Series. His last major league game was July 29, 2021. Players who fall under 5 percent come off the ballot for good, and a career built on one October and a lot of goodwill is exactly the kind that tests whether goodwill shows up on a ballot.

Election day is January 19. The Giants will learn by dinner time whether their catcher got the Mauer treatment.


Sources: National Baseball Hall of Fame, "2027 BBWAA Hall of Fame Ballot Announced," November 16, 2026 (ballot, voting rules, results date). Baseball-Reference player pages for Buster Posey, Joe Mauer and Pablo Sandoval, and its JAWS leaderboard for catchers (WAR, WAR7, JAWS, games, Mauer's 2024 vote).

Filed under Giants

More on Buster Posey

His page →
Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach
The 2027 Giants

Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach

On September 29 Buster Posey said the Giants' offseason work starts with the bullpen. At the General Managers Meetings on November 10 he said Randy Rodríguez had been shut down in the Arizona Fall League with elbow pain and would preferably not close at the start of 2027, and that signing a free agent who received a qualifying offer would be 'harder for us' after the club gave up four draft picks in two years for Matt Chapman, Blake Snell and Willy Adames. The finished change is the hiring of James Rowson as offensive coordinator, for an offense that drew the fewest walks of the 30 clubs. The 40-man roster is full at 40 ahead of the November 17 protection deadline, Camilo Doval's tender decision is due November 20, and the labor agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 1.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20265 min read
Posey starts the winter with the bullpen, and the rotation lost more
The 2027 Giants

Posey starts the winter with the bullpen, and the rotation lost more

At the season-end news conference on September 29, Buster Posey took the blame for the bullpen and said the club's offseason work starts there, with the rotation right behind it. The 2026 record explains why the bullpen is first in line: 16-29 in one-run games, and a relief corps whose strikeout-minus-walk rate beat only two clubs. The 2027 supply says the rotation has the bigger hole. Of 162 starts, 39 went to Robbie Ray and Tyler Mahle, both traded at the deadline, and 31 went to Trevor McDonald, Blade Tidwell and Carson Whisenhunt, whose elbows put their returns at late 2027 or 2028. The lineup the club intends to keep drew 449 walks, the fewest in the majors, and owes $451 million from 2027 on to Rafael Devers, Willy Adames and Matt Chapman. The same week, MLB Pipeline named San Francisco its Farm System of the Year. No take filed.

Andie TownsendOct 2, 20266 min read
The Giants Have Stolen 68, 68 And 69 Bases In Three Seasons, And Buster Posey Has Spent Two Of Them Asking For More
The bases

The Giants Have Stolen 68, 68 And 69 Bases In Three Seasons, And Buster Posey Has Spent Two Of Them Asking For More

San Francisco has stolen 69 bases in 147 games this season, after 68 in 162 games in 2025 and 68 in 162 games in 2024. Buster Posey, the club's president of baseball operations, told Susan Slusser of the San Francisco Chronicle this week that he has added running to the pitching and defense he has emphasized since taking the job, and that he has spent two years wanting that tone set. The season number is not what changed. The split inside it is: 27 steals in the first 85 games at a 69.2 percent success rate, then 42 in the next 62 at 80.8 percent. Since July 1 the Giants have stolen bases at 0.677 per game against a league rate of 0.668 over the same span, which ranks them twelfth of thirty after finishing 29th in each of the two previous seasons. Of the four Giants with nine or more steals, Luis Arraez was traded to Philadelphia on August 3 and Casey Schmitt is on the 60-day injured list with a torn meniscus. Jung Hoo Lee stole none in his first 56 games and twelve in his next 78. Fifty-eight major league players have stolen fifteen bases this season and no Giant has stolen more than twelve. Two takes filed.

Andie TownsendSep 11, 20265 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
Held upAug 10, 2026

Robert Jones, not Connor Colby, takes the first offensive snap at left guard for the San Francisco 49ers in their preseason opener against the Tennessee Titans on 2026-08-13. Scored off the official game book's starting offensive lineup, with the first-drive participation reported by the beat as the second source. The take is WRONG if Colby, Carver Willis, Brett Toth or anyone else opens the game at left guard, and it is WRONG if Jones opens the game at any position other than left guard. If San Francisco does not play the game on August 13, the take voids rather than scores.

The evidence for it is reps rather than words. Robert Jones has worked with the first-team offensive line at left guard in every published session since August 5, when David Lombardi reported the switch, and on Monday he did it again while Connor Colby took second-team RIGHT guard, which three separate accounts carry with no disagreement (Bonilla at 49ers Webzone, Posey at Niners Nation, Cohn at Sports Illustrated, all August 10). The case AGAINST it, and it is the reason this is a call and not a formality: offensive coordinator Klay Kubiak said the same afternoon that the job is 'definitely still an open competition,' that both men will compete all camp and play in the preseason 'a lot,' and that putting Colby in first was 'no slight on Connor.' A club that means that has one obvious way to show it, which is to start Colby in the game where nothing counts and let the tape decide. A preseason opener is also the cheapest possible place to give a seventh-round pick the first-team look back.

Latest on the Giants

The whole beat →
The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed
Rule 5

The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed

On November 17, 2026, the San Francisco Giants selected the contracts of left-hander Henry Lalane and right-handers Marty Gair and Josh Bostick, protecting all three from the Rule 5 draft, and designated Rowan Wick and Christian Koss for assignment. The club had one open spot after trading Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on November 15, and the 40-man roster is back to 40. Bostick, a 2023 eighth-round pick, missed the 2026 season with a torn Achilles; in 2025 he had a 3.71 ERA in 119 innings at High-A Eugene. Left off were Joe Whitman, who had a 3.54 ERA in 134 2/3 innings at Double-A and Triple-A, and Luis De La Torre, who struck out 27.2 percent and walked 17.7 percent of High-A batters. Both are Rule 5 eligible by their signing dates.

Grant LombardNov 18, 20263 min read
Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms
The 2027 Giants

Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms

San Francisco traded right-hander Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on Sunday for minor league right-handers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry. Neither joins the 40-man roster, which fell from 40 names to 39 two days before the November 17 deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 draft and five days before the November 20 tender deadline. Walker, who turns 31 on November 26, had a 7.16 ERA in 33 games and 32 2/3 innings in 2026 with 19 walks, after a 1.91 ERA in 80 innings in 2024, and recorded 31 saves in 226 games for the Giants from 2023 to 2026. Holub, 28, had a 2.10 ERA in 50 games and 55 2/3 innings for Triple-A Nashville with 66 strikeouts and 21 walks; Milwaukee acquired him from Detroit for Mark Canha in November 2023, and he is not on a 40-man roster. Perry, 23, was Milwaukee's 11th-round pick in July out of Western Kentucky and has not made his professional debut. Milwaukee's 40-man roster went from 33 to 34. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 15, 20264 min read
Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings
The 2027 Giants

Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings

Henry Lalane, 22, was eligible for the Rule 5 draft in December 2025 and no club took him. In 2026 he threw 105 innings across Single-A Tampa, High-A Hudson Valley, High-A Eugene and one postseason outing at Double-A Richmond, more than his previous four seasons combined, and his fastball moved from 91 or 92 mph to the mid-90s, MLB.com reported. He struck out 32.8 percent of the batters he faced at Tampa and 16.8 percent in five starts for Eugene after the Giants acquired him for Heliot Ramos on Aug. 3. The Giants must add him to the 40-man roster by Nov. 17 or expose him again.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20264 min read

Earlier on the Giants

Randy Rodríguez's last pitch left the park. On Tuesday he threw the next one
Randy Rodríguez

Randy Rodríguez's last pitch left the park. On Tuesday he threw the next one

Randy Rodríguez, signed by the Giants out of Santo Domingo on July 2, 2017, became a National League All-Star in 2025 with a 1.78 earned run average over 50 games. His last pitch that season was a slider William Contreras hit for a walk-off home run in Milwaukee on August 22. He had Tommy John surgery on September 24, 2025, and on October 13, 2026 he threw a scoreless first inning for the Scottsdale Scorpions at Scottsdale Stadium, his first game at any level in 417 days.

Posey ThompsonOct 14, 20268 min read
The Paperwork Still Says Abdominal Strain
The injury report

The Paperwork Still Says Abdominal Strain

Chapman finishes 2026 at 84 games, a .692 OPS and seven home runs, with four seasons still to run on his contract. Four men have started at third base since he left, and the newest arrived on a waiver claim the same day his season formally closed. The 2027 question is not whether he is the third baseman. It is who the Giants think the alternative is.

Andie TownsendAug 14, 20265 min read
San Francisco Traded A Reliever For A Starter And Then Used Him In Relief
The fifth starter

San Francisco Traded A Reliever For A Starter And Then Used Him In Relief

Tidwell has walked four men in seventeen innings as a Giant, a rate of 2.1 per nine. He walked 35 in 72 innings at Sacramento this season, 37 in 97 Triple-A innings last season, and ten in fifteen with the Mets. Every other sample on his record says he walks people, and San Francisco is buying about five innings tonight.

Grant LombardAug 10, 20264 min read