The 2027 Giants

Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms

The Giants traded the reliever they had optioned three times this season for Blake Holub and Gavin Perry, two minor league right-handers who need no 40-man spot. One of them is exposed to the same Rule 5 draft the Giants just made room for.

GL
Grant LombardNov 15, 20264 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Ryan Walker mid-delivery in the Giants' grey road uniform, SAN FRANCISCO across the chest in black and orange, a black cap with the orange SF, the ball cocked behind his head in his right hand and his glove held out in front of him, a blurred day-game crowd behind. A league media photograph from an earlier season.

There is a week in every move when you look at the couch and do the math. You can carry it to the curb on Friday for nothing, or you can put it online on Sunday and hope somebody with a truck and more floor space wants it.

The Giants put Ryan Walker online, and Milwaukee showed up with a truck.

San Francisco traded Walker to the Brewers on Sunday for two minor league right-handers, Blake Holub and Gavin Perry. Neither of them goes on the 40-man roster. Walker came off it. So the roster that held 40 names on Friday holds 39 tonight, with two days left before Tuesday's deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 draft.

Friday, November 20, is the curb. That is the tender deadline, when a club can decline to offer an arbitration-eligible player a contract and he simply leaves as a free agent. No trade partner, no phone call, nothing back. Walker was eligible, and the case for leaving him on it was not subtle: a 7.16 ERA in 33 games this year, 19 walks in 32 2/3 innings, and three separate trips to Sacramento between May and September. Nineteen walks in 32 2/3 innings is 5.2 per nine. Two years ago he walked 18 men in 80 innings all season.

The problem with the curb is that it opens on Friday and the Giants needed the space on Tuesday. Henry Lalane, the left-hander they got from the Yankees for Heliot Ramos in August, is not on the 40-man, and a roster with no open spot could not add him without first removing somebody. Now there is a spot. (Whether Lalane gets it will be known on Tuesday.)

Anyway. The truck.

Milwaukee's 40-man held 33 names before the trade and 34 after it. That is a lot of floor space. A club with six open spots can afford to bet on a reliever's good year, and Walker has one worth betting on. In 2024 he threw 80 innings across 76 games with a 1.91 ERA, 99 strikeouts and a WHIP of 0.85. Even this season, the part spent in Triple-A looked like a different pitcher: a 2.52 ERA at Sacramento across 35 2/3 innings, with 11 walks. Milwaukee now owns the Friday decision San Francisco did not want to make, and it has five days to make it.

(There is a small loop here. In September the Giants claimed Joel Kuhnel off Milwaukee's waivers and optioned Walker to Sacramento to make room for him. Walker has now followed the waiver wire back to where it started.)

Walker leaves with 31 saves in 226 games for the only organization he had ever pitched for, a 31st-round pick out of Washington State in 2018 who got to the ninth inning the long way. He turns 31 on November 26.

What came back is more interesting than a couch usually fetches.

Holub is 28, 6-foot-5, and a 15th-round pick by Detroit in 2021 out of St. Edward's University. Milwaukee got him in November 2023 for Mark Canha, which means he has now been traded for a major league veteran twice without ever throwing a major league pitch himself. He has pitched at Triple-A Nashville in each of the last three seasons, and the line there tells one story in reverse of Walker's. In 2024 he walked 22 men in 23 1/3 innings at Nashville, 8.5 per nine, with an 8.49 ERA. In 2026 he walked 21 in 55 2/3 innings, 3.4 per nine, with a 2.10 ERA, 66 strikeouts and five saves in 50 games. The Giants traded a reliever who lost the strike zone for one who went and found it. He was assigned to Sacramento.

Here is the catch. Holub is not on a 40-man roster either, and he signed out of college at 22, so he has been eligible for the Rule 5 draft in each of the last two Decembers. Nobody took him. Unless the Giants add him by Tuesday he is eligible again, which means the club cleared a spot for the Rule 5 deadline by trading for a pitcher who has his own Rule 5 deadline. Tuesday. The same one.

I do not think they spend the spot on him. One open spot and Lalane in line for it is a short list, and adding Holub would mean removing somebody else by Tuesday for a 28-year-old every club passed on in two drafts. The draft itself may not even be held if the labor agreement expires on December 1 without a new one. If the Giants do add him, it says they view him as major league bullpen help next season and not as a Triple-A arm they happened to get back in the deal.

Perry is the long-range part of the package. He is 23, 6-foot-5 and 265 pounds, and Milwaukee took him in the 11th round in July, No. 341 overall, out of Western Kentucky. He signed on July 27 and has not thrown a professional pitch. He goes to the Arizona Complex League Giants, and his own protection question is years away.

So the Giants did not have to carry anything to the curb. They got the floor space five days early and two chairs thrown in, one of them with a tag on it that also says Tuesday.

Called Shots: one filed, on whether the Giants add Blake Holub to the 40-man roster by the November 17 deadline. An open call on whether Walker is on San Francisco's 40-man roster on Opening Day 2027 resolves in April.

Sources: MLB Stats API (Giants and Brewers transaction logs; Giants 40-man roster on November 13 and November 15 and Brewers 40-man roster on November 13 and November 15; player records, draft records and year-by-year major and minor league pitching lines for Ryan Walker, Blake Holub and Gavin Perry); MLB.com (Brewers announcement of the trade, November 15; Rule 5 protection deadline).

Filed under Giants

More on Ryan Walker

His page →
The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed
Rule 5

The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed

On November 17, 2026, the San Francisco Giants selected the contracts of left-hander Henry Lalane and right-handers Marty Gair and Josh Bostick, protecting all three from the Rule 5 draft, and designated Rowan Wick and Christian Koss for assignment. The club had one open spot after trading Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on November 15, and the 40-man roster is back to 40. Bostick, a 2023 eighth-round pick, missed the 2026 season with a torn Achilles; in 2025 he had a 3.71 ERA in 119 innings at High-A Eugene. Left off were Joe Whitman, who had a 3.54 ERA in 134 2/3 innings at Double-A and Triple-A, and Luis De La Torre, who struck out 27.2 percent and walked 17.7 percent of High-A batters. Both are Rule 5 eligible by their signing dates.

Grant LombardNov 18, 20263 min read
San Francisco Claimed A Reliever Milwaukee Waived, So Ryan Walker Is Going To Sacramento For The Third Time
Seventeen saves

San Francisco Claimed A Reliever Milwaukee Waived, So Ryan Walker Is Going To Sacramento For The Third Time

San Francisco optioned right-hander Ryan Walker to Triple-A Sacramento on Saturday morning, the third time it has optioned him in 2026, and activated right-hander Joel Kuhnel, whom it claimed off waivers from Milwaukee on Friday after the Brewers designated him for assignment on Wednesday. The move was forced by two ceilings: the Giants carried 28 active players and 14 pitchers before it, and all thirty major league clubs were carrying exactly 28 and exactly 14 on Saturday, measured off MLB's active-roster endpoint. Walker led the 2025 Giants with 17 saves out of the 41 the club recorded in 162 games, with Camilo Doval taking 15 of the rest. This season he has a 7.16 ERA across 33 appearances and 32.2 innings, with 19 walks, one more than he issued in 80.0 innings in 2024, when his ERA was 1.91. Opponents have scored in 16 of his 33 outings. His three optional assignments came on May 10, July 9 and September 5, with recalls on June 12 and August 24; in his last stint he allowed four runs across 6.1 innings in six appearances, the first three scoreless, two runs on August 29 and one in each of the last two. San Francisco has made 49 optional assignments across 26 players in 2026, led by Tristan Beck's six. Ten different Giants have recorded a save this year, 26 in total through 142 games, with Caleb Kilian's eight the most. Walker was San Francisco's 31st-round pick in 2018, No. 916 overall, out of Washington State. The club is 58-84, eliminated in the National League West, with a wild-card elimination number of five and 20 games left. Sacramento has 14 games left and its regular season ends September 20. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 5, 20265 min read
San Francisco's Active Roster Does Not List A Shortstop
What is left

San Francisco's Active Roster Does Not List A Shortstop

San Francisco placed Willy Adames (left elbow sprain on the transaction log; MLB.com reported an MRI showing a moderate strain of the non-throwing elbow, and the two wordings are recorded here as published rather than blended) and Victor Bericoto (right knee bone bruise) on the 10-day injured list on August 24 and JT Brubaker (bruised ribs) on the 15-day, all three hurt in Sunday's 5-4 loss at Boston. Bryce Eldridge went on the bereavement list and Matt Wilkinson was optioned. The Giants recalled five men from Triple-A Sacramento the same day: Nate Furman, Grant McCray, Anthony Molina, Ryan Walker and Shay Whitcomb. Adames had started 121 games at shortstop and played 1,046.1 innings there; MLB's active-roster page now lists no shortstop among the 26. Christian Koss, a third baseman with 71 innings at short this year and two innings pitched, played the position Monday while Whitcomb made his Giants debut at third. San Francisco won 5-0 behind six pitchers after losing starter Carson Whisenhunt in the third inning to left elbow pain. Whisenhunt was scheduled for an MRI on Tuesday morning and no result has been published. The Giants have used 58 players this season, tied with the Angels and the Athletics for fifth-most in the majors against a league median of 52, and seven of them made their San Francisco debut in August.

Grant LombardAug 25, 20264 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
Held upSep 5, 2026

Ryan Walker does not appear in a major league game for the San Francisco Giants at any point in the remainder of the 2026 regular season, meaning he throws no major league pitch from September 5 through the end of the regular season. RIGHT if he makes no appearance. WRONG if he appears in one or more games. Resolves off the league's official box scores.

This takes the side I expect to lose, which is why it is worth filing. Sacramento's regular season ends September 20 and San Francisco plays seven more games after that, so from the 21st the club has an optioned pitcher with nowhere else to throw and no reason to protect a result: it is 58-84 and eliminated in the National League West. That is the ordinary shape of a September recall. Against that: the Giants have just chosen a waiver claim over him at the pitcher ceiling, they have optioned him three times in one season, and a club deciding in November whether to keep a reliever with a 7.16 ERA has no need to add innings to the file. I make it roughly two in five and price it at +140, which implies 41.7 percent. RESTATEMENT CHECK, run against all 45 open Giants rows and written out rather than asserted. No open row names Ryan Walker. The nearest in kind is my own 2026-08-25 row asking whether San Francisco uses at least 68 players in 2026: Walker is already counted in that total and no further appearance can move it, so the two are independent. My own 2026-08-30 row counting major league debuts cannot be touched, because Walker debuted in 2023. Andie Townsend's open 2026-08-21 row counts distinct STARTING pitchers and Walker has not started a game since 2023.

Latest on the Giants

The whole beat →
Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.
Cooperstown

Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.

The Baseball Hall of Fame announced the 2027 Baseball Writers' Association of America ballot on November 16, 2026: 27 former players, 14 of them on it for the first time, including Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval. Results are announced Tuesday, January 19, 2027, at 6 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network; election takes 75 percent of ballots, and a player needs 5 percent to stay on. By Baseball-Reference, Posey had 45.0 WAR in 12 seasons and a seven-year peak (WAR7) of 36.5, against 53.7 and 34.9 for the average of the 17 Hall of Fame catchers; his JAWS of 40.8 ranks 14th among catchers. Joe Mauer, elected on his first ballot in 2024 with 293 of 385 votes (76.1 percent), had 55.6 WAR, a 39.1 WAR7 and a 47.4 JAWS, and caught 921 games to Posey's 1,093. Sandoval, the 2012 World Series MVP, had 19.1 WAR in 14 seasons. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 17, 20263 min read
Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings
The 2027 Giants

Nobody took Henry Lalane in last year's Rule 5 draft. Then he threw 105 innings

Henry Lalane, 22, was eligible for the Rule 5 draft in December 2025 and no club took him. In 2026 he threw 105 innings across Single-A Tampa, High-A Hudson Valley, High-A Eugene and one postseason outing at Double-A Richmond, more than his previous four seasons combined, and his fastball moved from 91 or 92 mph to the mid-90s, MLB.com reported. He struck out 32.8 percent of the batters he faced at Tampa and 16.8 percent in five starts for Eugene after the Giants acquired him for Heliot Ramos on Aug. 3. The Giants must add him to the 40-man roster by Nov. 17 or expose him again.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20264 min read
Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach
The 2027 Giants

Posey put the bullpen first in September. His first hire was a hitting coach

On September 29 Buster Posey said the Giants' offseason work starts with the bullpen. At the General Managers Meetings on November 10 he said Randy Rodríguez had been shut down in the Arizona Fall League with elbow pain and would preferably not close at the start of 2027, and that signing a free agent who received a qualifying offer would be 'harder for us' after the club gave up four draft picks in two years for Matt Chapman, Blake Snell and Willy Adames. The finished change is the hiring of James Rowson as offensive coordinator, for an offense that drew the fewest walks of the 30 clubs. The 40-man roster is full at 40 ahead of the November 17 protection deadline, Camilo Doval's tender decision is due November 20, and the labor agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 1.

Andie TownsendNov 13, 20265 min read

Earlier on the Giants

The Giants' nine free-agent contracts, graded on signing day. The biggest one is a C+
Free Agent Regrade

The Giants' nine free-agent contracts, graded on signing day. The biggest one is a C+

The 2025-26 Giants signed nine major league free agents for $70.28 million guaranteed across the nine, and none of the nine came from the top of the market. Each is graded here as of its signing date, on a four-part rubric in this order: need, fit, price and term against MLB Trade Rumors' November 6 and FanGraphs' November 5 predictions, and risk. Hentges B, Foley B-, Houser C+, Mahle B+, Bader A-, Arraez B+, Wick C, Brennan B-, Borucki C+. The winter as a class, graded at opening day: C+. The result grades come at the All-Star break and at season's end.

Andie TownsendSep 22, 202612 min read
Adrian Houser's Forearm Took A Job With It, And San Francisco Has Been Filling It With Starting Pitchers
The long man

Adrian Houser's Forearm Took A Job With It, And San Francisco Has Been Filling It With Starting Pitchers

San Diego beat San Francisco 7-5 at Oracle Park on Friday night. Anthony Molina gave up nine hits and seven earned runs in three innings; Yunior Marte, who made his major league debut as a starting pitcher two weeks ago and whose last relief appearance before this month came at High-A Eugene in April, threw the next five innings and allowed nothing. It was the tenth time in 148 games a Giants reliever has thrown more innings than that day's Giants starter. Adrian Houser was the reliever in six of the first seven. He has been on the injured list since August 26 with a right forearm strain and was moved to the 60-day list on September 1. Rafael Devers hit his 36th home run, a grand slam off Robbie Ray in the fifth, and San Francisco scored nothing after it. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 12, 20265 min read
Luis Arraez Is Worth What He Looks Like. Robbie Ray Is Worth 1.3 Runs Less.
Deadline math

Luis Arraez Is Worth What He Looks Like. Robbie Ray Is Worth 1.3 Runs Less.

One of the Giants' two rentals is having a season the components support. The other has the rotation's best ERA and its second-worst FIP. Pricing them the same way is the mistake available between now and August 3.

Jamie SilvaJul 26, 20266 min read