Civic memory

The Giants brought the 1951 pennant west, but the home run stayed in New York

Bobby Thomson's home run turned 75 on Saturday. His bat was on display in Cooperstown, the people who remember the afternoon were found with a New York society's help, and the man who hit it was traded twelve days before San Francisco played its first game.

AL
August LindenOct 4, 20265 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
An illustration in black, orange and cream of a concrete stairway with an iron handrail running down a grassy hillside. A single baseball sits on the middle landing.

Bobby Thomson played third base in the last game the Giants played as New York's team.

That was September 29, 1957, a Sunday at the Polo Grounds. Pittsburgh won 9 to 1, and Thomson had one of the six Giants hits. He had been traded to Milwaukee in February 1954 and traded back in June 1957, so the man who won the 1951 pennant with one swing was on the field for the franchise's final afternoon as the home team in the city where he did it.

On April 3, 1958, the club sent him to the Chicago Cubs for Bob Speake and cash. The club making that trade was the San Francisco Giants. Twelve days later it played its first game in California, an 8 to 0 win over the Dodgers at Seals Stadium, and Thomson was a Cub. He never played a regular-season game for San Francisco.

His home run turned 75 on Saturday.

The afternoon fits in a sentence. On October 3, 1951, in the bottom of the ninth inning of the third game of a playoff for the National League pennant, with one out, two on and the Giants two runs down, Thomson hit a home run to left field off Ralph Branca, and the Giants beat Brooklyn 5 to 4 in front of 34,320 people.

Where it was on Saturday#

The bat is in Cooperstown. The National Baseball Hall of Fame keeps it on the museum's second floor, and the program the Hall announced for the anniversary featured it along with Russ Hodges's scorecard from the game and an interview with Thomson's daughters, Megan Hann and Nancy Mitchell.

The people who remember it were reached through New York. Michael Clair of MLB.com went looking for them and had help from Gary Mintz of the New York Giants Preservation Society. Most had been children then, in the Bronx and in Brooklyn, in Bayonne and in New Haven. One of them watched on his tiptoes at a five-and-dime. Clair's two pieces ran on the San Francisco club's own news page, and San Francisco is not mentioned in either.

The ground is in Harlem. The Polo Grounds came down in 1964, and four public housing towers were finished on the site in 1968 and named for it. A bronze plaque was made for the towers to mark roughly where home plate was. It was restored last year in an effort led by Michael Mays, the son of Willie Mays, with the city's housing authority and the Preservation Society, and unveiled on September 6, 2025.

Consider what that society is. It preserves a baseball team that is still playing. Mintz, its president, said so to MLB.com in 2014: "There was a team here and that team still exists even though they're 3,000 miles away."

What moved#

A franchise carries its papers when it moves. The 1951 pennant sits in the San Francisco Giants' record book because a record book is property, and property goes where the owner goes. An afternoon is something else. It happened to the people who were listening, in the places where they were listening, and the record since 1958 says the home run stayed with them. San Francisco has done well by it as a guest, and came away without the man who hit it when it tried to play host.

San Francisco's side of this is real. Willie Mays was the next batter when Thomson swung, and he played center field for San Francisco from 1958 into 1972. Hodges called the home run and then called Giants games in San Francisco through 1970; he died in Mill Valley the following April. Bill Rigney pinch-hit in the eighth inning that day and managed the first San Francisco team. Alvin Dark, who opened the ninth with a single, managed San Francisco to the 1962 pennant. The men came west, and the day came with them as their own.

In 2001 San Francisco sent for the day itself. There were to be fiftieth-anniversary festivities at a Giants-Dodgers game in San Francisco, rescheduled after the September 11 attacks, and Thomson declined to attend. Dave Anderson wrote in The New York Times that October that Branca's feelings were a factor, and he quoted Thomson on the plan. "They were going to have Ralph and me ride around in a cart," Thomson said. "Ralph doesn't need that."

In 2011 the club went the other way. On January 21, 2011, it carried the 2010 World Series trophy to P.S. 46, a public school next to the towers, and Willie Mays went with it. "This is my neighborhood," Mays said there, in Sports Illustrated's account. That November Fox Sports reported that the club had put $50,000 toward rebuilding the John T. Brush Stairway, which runs down Coogan's Bluff toward where the ballpark stood and which the city's parks department calls the last remnant of the Polo Grounds. A club spokeswoman, Staci Slaughter, said it would be "highly appropriate for us to participate." The job was budgeted at $950,000 when work began. The football Giants gave $200,000, and the Yankees and the Mets gave $100,000 each. The baseball Giants gave what the Jets gave.

The restoration kept the original brass lettering, set in a landing halfway down. It says the stairway was presented by the New York Giants.

April 15, 1958#

San Francisco's first lineup had Mays in center field and Rigney in the dugout. Jim Davenport played third base. The third baseman from the last afternoon in New York was twelve days gone, in another uniform, and the home run was where he had left it.

Sources: Retrosheet box scores and play-by-play for October 3, 1951, September 29, 1957 and April 15, 1958; the Society for American Baseball Research's biographies of Bobby Thomson (trades of February 1954 and June 1957) and Russ Hodges; Dave Anderson, The New York Times, October 1, 2001, on the 2001 anniversary; Baseball-Reference for the trade of April 3, 1958; the National Baseball Hall of Fame's announcement, September 24, 2026, of its 75th-anniversary program; the New York City Housing Authority's development data, for the towers; Michael Clair, MLB.com, October 2, 2026; the NYCHA Journal, September 11, 2025, on the home plate plaque; Paul Post, MLB.com, September 9, 2014, on the reopened Brush Stairway, for Gary Mintz and the brass lettering; Sports Illustrated, January 24, 2011, and WCBS 880, January 20, 2011, on the trophy at P.S. 46; Fox Sports, November 7, 2011, and NYC Parks, July 10, 2015, on the stairway and who paid for it.

Filed under Giants

Latest on the Giants

The whole beat →
The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed
Rule 5

The Giants protected a pitcher who missed 2026 and left Joe Whitman exposed

On November 17, 2026, the San Francisco Giants selected the contracts of left-hander Henry Lalane and right-handers Marty Gair and Josh Bostick, protecting all three from the Rule 5 draft, and designated Rowan Wick and Christian Koss for assignment. The club had one open spot after trading Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on November 15, and the 40-man roster is back to 40. Bostick, a 2023 eighth-round pick, missed the 2026 season with a torn Achilles; in 2025 he had a 3.71 ERA in 119 innings at High-A Eugene. Left off were Joe Whitman, who had a 3.54 ERA in 134 2/3 innings at Double-A and Triple-A, and Luis De La Torre, who struck out 27.2 percent and walked 17.7 percent of High-A batters. Both are Rule 5 eligible by their signing dates.

Grant LombardNov 18, 20263 min read
Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.
Cooperstown

Posey's best seven years beat the Hall's average catcher. His twelve do not.

The Baseball Hall of Fame announced the 2027 Baseball Writers' Association of America ballot on November 16, 2026: 27 former players, 14 of them on it for the first time, including Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval. Results are announced Tuesday, January 19, 2027, at 6 p.m. Eastern on MLB Network; election takes 75 percent of ballots, and a player needs 5 percent to stay on. By Baseball-Reference, Posey had 45.0 WAR in 12 seasons and a seven-year peak (WAR7) of 36.5, against 53.7 and 34.9 for the average of the 17 Hall of Fame catchers; his JAWS of 40.8 ranks 14th among catchers. Joe Mauer, elected on his first ballot in 2024 with 293 of 385 votes (76.1 percent), had 55.6 WAR, a 39.1 WAR7 and a 47.4 JAWS, and caught 921 games to Posey's 1,093. Sandoval, the 2012 World Series MVP, had 19.1 WAR in 14 seasons. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 17, 20263 min read
Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms
The 2027 Giants

Ryan Walker was five days from the tender deadline, and Milwaukee paid two arms

San Francisco traded right-hander Ryan Walker to Milwaukee on Sunday for minor league right-handers Blake Holub and Gavin Perry. Neither joins the 40-man roster, which fell from 40 names to 39 two days before the November 17 deadline to protect prospects from the Rule 5 draft and five days before the November 20 tender deadline. Walker, who turns 31 on November 26, had a 7.16 ERA in 33 games and 32 2/3 innings in 2026 with 19 walks, after a 1.91 ERA in 80 innings in 2024, and recorded 31 saves in 226 games for the Giants from 2023 to 2026. Holub, 28, had a 2.10 ERA in 50 games and 55 2/3 innings for Triple-A Nashville with 66 strikeouts and 21 walks; Milwaukee acquired him from Detroit for Mark Canha in November 2023, and he is not on a 40-man roster. Perry, 23, was Milwaukee's 11th-round pick in July out of Western Kentucky and has not made his professional debut. Milwaukee's 40-man roster went from 33 to 34. One take filed.

Grant LombardNov 15, 20264 min read

Earlier on the Giants

Cesar Perdomo Gave Up Three Singles And A Walk In His First Major League Start
Twenty Men

Cesar Perdomo Gave Up Three Singles And A Walk In His First Major League Start

Cesar Perdomo made his first major league start at Citi Field on September 6, five days after his major league debut, and pitched six scoreless innings against the New York Mets. He faced twenty batters, allowed three singles and one walk, struck out four and threw 83 pitches, 48 of them for strikes. No New York runner reached second base against him. Joel Kuhnel pitched a scoreless seventh. Carson Seymour then allowed four earned runs on sixteen pitches in the eighth, on a solo home run by Brett Baty and a three-run home run by Bo Bichette, and San Francisco lost 4-2 in front of 29,410. The Giants scored both their runs in the fourth on a Jung Hoo Lee single and finished with five hits and twelve strikeouts. Perdomo is the thirteenth different pitcher to start a game for San Francisco in 2026, which resolves an open Andie Townsend call filed August 21, and his start resolves a Grant Lombard call filed September 2. Perdomo's career major league line is now ten innings, six hits, one earned run, two walks and eight strikeouts. His 2026 was worse at every stop before this: a 3.98 earned run average at Double-A Richmond and a 5.10 mark with twenty walks at Triple-A Sacramento. He has thrown 130 innings this year against a previous career high of 127 and a third. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 7, 20265 min read
The Giants Have One 40-Man Spot Left. December 1 Is What Makes It Expensive.
Roster math

The Giants Have One 40-Man Spot Left. December 1 Is What Makes It Expensive.

Counted entry by entry Thursday morning: 45 names on the Giants' 40-man roster, six on the 60-day injured list, 39 against the limit, one spot open. Two contracts have been selected in the last six days and neither was a prospect decision. What a September call-up costs in a year when two labor agreements expire at different times, and the part of it nobody outside the building can see.

Jamie SilvaAug 13, 20266 min read
San Francisco Sold Everything It Was Allowed To Sell
The deadline

San Francisco Sold Everything It Was Allowed To Sell

The Giants moved Mahle, Arraez, Ray, Ramos and Erik Miller and got eight players back, one of whom matters. What they did not move is the story: Adames and Chapman each hold a full no-trade clause, which means the salary relief everyone was pricing was never actually on the market. Plus an honest accounting of six deadline calls filed here on Sunday, two of which were right.

Grant LombardAug 5, 20267 min read