Feature

The last time Rafael Devers played third base, an umpire put him there

He played 951 games at third base for Boston across eight seasons. Since the start of 2025 he has played nine innings there, all of them on one Tuesday night in Denver. His season ended Sunday on the 60-day injured list, and he had surgery in Philadelphia on Tuesday.

PT
Posey ThompsonSep 16, 20267 min read
Every call on this site goes on a public ledger and gets graded. The misses stay up.
Rafael Devers at the finish of a left-handed swing in a day game at Oracle Park, his head up and following the ball out of frame, the bat wrapped behind his shoulders. He wears the Giants cream home uniform with GIANTS lettered in orange across the chest, an orange sleeve and orange batting gloves, and a dark helmet with a face guard. The crowd behind him is out of focus. A league media photograph; the date of the frame is not established.

On the second of September last year, at Coors Field, Rafael Devers batted in the top of the first inning with Heliot Ramos on base and hit the ball into the seats in right field. It was his thirtieth home run of 2025. San Francisco led 2-0 before Colorado had recorded an out.

What happened after that is in the play-by-play as an on-field delay, and the record does not say what was said during it. Home plate umpire Phil Cuzzi ejected Colorado's pitcher, Kyle Freeland. Then he ejected Willy Adames, who had not yet seen a pitch. Then he ejected Matt Chapman, who was the Giants' third baseman.

Devers had started that game at first base. In the bottom of the first, before Colorado came to bat, he moved across the infield to third and Dominic Smith took over at first. Devers played the rest of the game there. Three ground balls came to him in nine innings. He threw all three to first base, and all three men were out.

He has not played the position since.

951#

Devers played third base for the Boston Red Sox in every season he spent there. Fifty-six games in 2017, the year he came up at twenty. Then 116, then 152, then 57 in the short season, then 151, then 138, then 151, then 130 in 2024. Those add to 951 games at third base across eight years.

Since the start of the 2025 season he has played nine innings there.

Both numbers come off the league's own fielding record, and the second one is the Tuesday night in Denver.

February#

Boston signed Alex Bregman in February of 2025. Bregman had won a Gold Glove at third base the season before, with Houston. On Monday, February 17, Devers spoke to reporters at spring training through an interpreter.

"Third base is my position," he said. "It's what I've played. I don't know what their plans are. I know we had a conversation. I made it clear, kind of what my desires were, and whatever happens from here, I don't know."

He was asked whether he would move to designated hitter. He answered before the interpreter could turn the question over.

"No."

Five weeks later, on the afternoon of Wednesday, March 26, Alex Cora went on WEEI in Boston and closed it.

"We had conversations throughout Spring Training, and [Devers] was very vocal about how he felt," Cora said. "We made a decision. Alex is going to play third, and Raffy is going to DH. We all are in the winning business, and [Devers] understands that." And: "It's like everything, you don't have to agree with it, but at the end of the day, [this is] what we're going to do to perform every single day."

Boston opened the season in Arlington the next afternoon. Devers was the designated hitter.

The decision was defensible and the numbers under it are not close. Counting from 2017, the year Devers debuted, defensive runs saved had Bregman at plus 21 at third base and Devers at minus 62. That is the comparison MLB.com laid side by side the week Cora announced it.

May#

Triston Casas played his last game of 2025 on May 2. He ruptured the patellar tendon in his left knee, had surgery, and Boston's first baseman was gone for the year.

Craig Breslow, the club's chief baseball officer, asked Devers whether he would move there. On Thursday, May 8, speaking through team interpreter Daveson Perez, Devers said he had told him no.

"I know I'm a ballplayer, but at the same time, they can't expect me to play every single position out there," he said. "In Spring Training, they talked to me and basically told me to put away my glove and I wasn't going to play any other position but DH."

Asked whether he might change his mind, he said no before the question was finished.

"I don't feel that they were true to their word," Devers said. "They told me that I was going to play this position, DH, and now they're going back on that. I just don't think they [are] staying true with their word."

Boston traded him thirty-eight days later. On Sunday, June 15, Devers went to San Francisco and Kyle Harrison, Jordan Hicks, Jose Bello and James Tibbs III went to Boston. The league's transaction log writes the deal in its own words and describes the player who moved as a designated hitter. Two months earlier the same log had called him a third baseman.

July#

He was the Giants' designated hitter for twenty-nine games. Then, on Tuesday, July 22, at Truist Park in Atlanta, Rafael Devers started at first base. He was twenty-eight and it was the first time in his life he had played the position in a major league game.

Nothing was hit to him. He recorded four putouts, every one of them a throw from Casey Schmitt or Willy Adames. He went 2-for-5 with a double and a run batted in, and San Francisco won and ended a six-game losing streak.

Afterward, through interpreter Erwin Higueros, he said he had been nervous for a couple of innings and then was not. He was asked about the glove he was wearing.

"It's my own glove," Devers said. "I ordered it the second day I arrived [in] San Francisco."

Seventy-five days earlier he had said Boston told him to put his glove away. He had been a Giant for two days when he ordered a new one.

That is not a man changing his mind about first base. Read back what he objected to in Boston and almost none of it is about the position. He said they could not expect him to play every position out there. He said he had been given two months at one job before being asked to learn another. He said they had not been true to their word. The complaint is about being moved, twice, in two directions, by people who had already told him something else. Nobody in San Francisco had told him anything yet, and he gave his own reason for wanting to be out there the same night in Atlanta:

"It keeps me active and it keeps my head out of just thinking of the next at-bat. I'm the kind of player who likes to be active and likes to be on the field. I'd rather be on the field than be in the cage hitting all the time."

Six weeks after that, in Denver, Matt Chapman was ejected in the first inning and Rafael Devers spent nine innings at third base. Three chances, three assists, no errors. It has not happened again.

What the season was#

In 2026 Devers played 100 games at first base and was the designated hitter in 48 more. At first base he took 827 putouts and made 71 assists and eight errors.

He did all of it with a core muscle injury. In a statement released Sunday, the Giants said he "managed this issue for much of the season and chose to keep playing through it." Tony Vitello said the problem went back further than this season and had been difficult to diagnose. Alex Pavlovic of NBC Sports Bay Area, who had been asking, wrote that Vitello was vague about Devers's health all season and that the club had been hiding a significant injury.

Devers appeared in 148 of the 149 games San Francisco completed before his season ended. The one he missed was Wednesday, September 9, a day off Vitello said was overdue.

On Saturday, September 12, against San Diego, Devers was the designated hitter. In the bottom of the first inning he hit a Michael King pitch to right center field and Drew Gilbert scored ahead of him. It was his thirty-seventh home run. He grounded out to first base in the third, grounded out softly to the pitcher in the sixth, and struck out swinging in the eighth against Adrian Morejon.

He had last stood on a field on Tuesday, September 8, against St. Louis: nine innings at first base, twelve putouts, one assist, no errors.

The next afternoon San Francisco put him on the 60-day injured list. He finished with a .258 average, 37 home runs, 36 doubles, 98 RBIs and 161 strikeouts in 148 games. The 36 doubles were tied for the most in the major leagues on the day he stopped, with Wilyer Abreu, Alec Burleson and Bryan Reynolds, and those three are still playing.

On Tuesday, in Philadelphia, Dr. William Meyers repaired the left side of his core. He is the surgeon who operated on Matt Chapman earlier this summer. Vitello said before Tuesday night's game against St. Louis that the procedure went the way the club expected.

"Got done what they needed to do," Vitello said. "They felt like he'll do well afterwards, do well with the recovery."

The baseline is about three months, which ends in the middle of December. Camp opens in February.

Rafael Devers is twenty-nine, and he turns thirty next month. He played 951 games at third base, and then nine innings, and the nine innings happened because an umpire threw somebody else out of a game.

The league keeps a file on every player in it, and one of the fields in that file is the position he primarily plays. His says first base.

Sources: MLB Stats API, read September 16, 2026: Devers's year-by-year and game-by-game fielding record (personId 646240), his 2026 season hitting line and game log, the transaction log for 2025 and 2026, and the play-by-play and box score of the September 2, 2025 game at Coors Field (gamePk 776486) and the September 12, 2026 game against San Diego (gamePk 823170). Triston Casas's 2025 game log (personId 671213) for the date of his last game. MLB.com, March 26, 2025, for Cora's WEEI remarks and the defensive runs saved comparison; May 8, 2025, for Devers's remarks through Daveson Perez; July 23, 2025, for his first-base debut and his remarks through Erwin Higueros; and September 15, 2026, for the surgery and Vitello's remarks. Yahoo Sports, February 17, 2025, carrying Devers's spring training remarks as reported by MLB.com and NESN. The San Francisco Standard, September 13, 2026, for the club's statement. NBC Sports Bay Area, Alex Pavlovic, September 13, 2026.

Filed under Giants

More on Matt Chapman

His page →
The Giants are building 2027 on seven players, and two of them held up
The 2027 Giants

The Giants are building 2027 on seven players, and two of them held up

Nothing the Giants announced at their season-end news conference moves any of the seven players the club is building 2027 on: Rafael Devers, Bryce Eldridge, Logan Webb, Landen Roupp, Willy Adames, Matt Chapman and Jung Hoo Lee. Measured against what next season asks of each, two of them delivered in 2026, and they are the two who split first base and designated hitter. Devers and Eldridge drew 128 walks in 1,081 plate appearances; every other Giant drew 321 in 4,980, a 6.4 percent rate against 8.9 for the majors. The other five each have to recover a specific thing from 2025: Webb's innings and strikeouts, Roupp's walk rate, Adames's defense at shortstop, Chapman's bat and Lee's walk rate. Adames went from +5 Outs Above Average to -17, and of 12 qualified shortstops since 2017 who fell to -10 or worse and stayed at the position, three got back to zero. Lee can opt out of his contract after 2027. One Called Shot filed.

Andie TownsendOct 23, 20266 min read
Posey starts the winter with the bullpen, and the rotation lost more
The 2027 Giants

Posey starts the winter with the bullpen, and the rotation lost more

At the season-end news conference on September 29, Buster Posey took the blame for the bullpen and said the club's offseason work starts there, with the rotation right behind it. The 2026 record explains why the bullpen is first in line: 16-29 in one-run games, and a relief corps whose strikeout-minus-walk rate beat only two clubs. The 2027 supply says the rotation has the bigger hole. Of 162 starts, 39 went to Robbie Ray and Tyler Mahle, both traded at the deadline, and 31 went to Trevor McDonald, Blade Tidwell and Carson Whisenhunt, whose elbows put their returns at late 2027 or 2028. The lineup the club intends to keep drew 449 walks, the fewest in the majors, and owes $451 million from 2027 on to Rafael Devers, Willy Adames and Matt Chapman. The same week, MLB Pipeline named San Francisco its Farm System of the Year. No take filed.

Andie TownsendOct 2, 20266 min read
Rafael Devers Is Done For The Year, And The Paperwork That Says So Is Also A Call-Up
The first baseman

Rafael Devers Is Done For The Year, And The Paperwork That Says So Is Also A Call-Up

San Francisco placed Rafael Devers on the 60-day injured list on Sunday with a core muscle injury, and the league's roster system carries his status as Injured 60-Day. With 13 games left on the schedule the designation ends his season by the calendar, whatever Monday's consultation with a Philadelphia specialist recommends. The club's 40-man roster held 40 of 40 before the move and 40 of 40 after it: the transaction that closed Devers's year is the transaction that made room for Scott Bandura, whose contract was selected from Sacramento the same day. Devers hit .258 with a .340 on-base percentage and a .525 slugging percentage across 148 games, with 37 home runs, 98 RBI and 36 doubles, which ties him with three other hitters for the major league lead. He homered in each of his last two games. He is the 16th man on this club's 60-day list and the second infielder it has moved there to end a season, after Matt Chapman in August. Seven contract years remain. One take filed at -160.

Andie TownsendSep 13, 20265 min read

More on Rafael Devers

His page →
Remove Rafael Devers and the Giants are still 25th against left-handed pitching
Left versus right

Remove Rafael Devers and the Giants are still 25th against left-handed pitching

Rafael Devers posted a .573 OPS against left-handed pitching and a 1.027 OPS against right-handed pitching in 2026, a gap of 454 points and the largest of any qualified left-handed hitter in the major leagues. Remove his 220 plate appearances against left-handers from San Francisco's team totals and the Giants improve from .669 to .684, which moves them from 28th to 25th of thirty and leaves them 22 points below the league median of .706. The 40-man roster holds 18 position players, nine right-handed and nine left-handed, and no switch-hitter; four of the thirty clubs are in that position. Willy Adames, the club's primary right-handed bat, hit worse against left-handed pitching than against right-handed pitching. The best right-handed answer in the system is 22-year-old Lorenzo Meola, who is at Single-A San Jose. One take filed.

Grant LombardSep 21, 20266 min read
The Giants cannot lose 100 games. Their floor is one game better than 1985.
The arithmetic

The Giants cannot lose 100 games. Their floor is one game better than 1985.

San Francisco is 63-89 with ten games to play, so the worst record it can finish with is 63-99 and a second hundred-loss season is off the table. The league's year-by-year record for this franchise runs 144 seasons and contains exactly one hundred-loss year: 1985, at 62-100. The distance between that team and this year's floor is one game. Four seasons in the 144 have a worse winning percentage than a 63-99 finish, three of them played in New York. Across the 69 seasons the Giants have played in San Francisco, the best available outcome, winning all ten, is 73-89 and the eleventh-worst season in that span; losing seven of the ten produces 66-96, which is the 1984 club's record exactly. Tuesday's nine starters were Cox, Eldridge, Gilbert, Lee, Basabe, Hill, Cavanaugh, McCray and Koss. Turner Hill drove in three on a single, a groundout and the first home run of his major league life. Seven of the ten runs scored without a home run. Rafael Devers had core-muscle surgery in Philadelphia the same day. One take filed.

Grant LombardSep 16, 20265 min read
A Giant Has Hit 35 Doubles And 35 Home Runs Seven Times Since 1883. Rafael Devers Just Made It Eight.
The eighth time

A Giant Has Hit 35 Doubles And 35 Home Runs Seven Times Since 1883. Rafael Devers Just Made It Eight.

Rafael Devers has 36 doubles and 36 home runs in 147 games for San Francisco, which is the eighth time a player has reached 35 of each in a season for this franchise and the first since Jeff Kent in 2002. Devers is the seventh man to do it, because Barry Bonds did it twice. Counted across every season the league's records hold for the club, 1883 through 2026, the other seven seasons belong to Mel Ott in 1929, Willie Mays in 1962, Willie McCovey in 1970, Barry Bonds in 1993 and 1998, Rich Aurilia in 2001 and Kent. Devers is also the only player in the major leagues at 35 and 35 in 2026: four men have 35 doubles and eight have 35 home runs, and he is the only name on both lists. He reached 35 home runs on September 5 at New York and 35 and 36 doubles on September 7 against St. Louis. He was the National League's player of the week for the week dated September 6. Tony Vitello rested him on September 9, ending a consecutive-games streak at 309, which Susan Slusser reported as the third-longest active streak in the majors behind Matt Olson's 927 and Pete Alonso's 562. The next-best home run total on the roster is 21, shared by Willy Adames and Casey Schmitt, and both men are on the 60-day injured list with returns the club lists as 2027. Devers has 36 of San Francisco's 167 home runs and 36 of its 246 doubles. The club is 62-86 and eliminated with 14 games left. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 12, 20264 min read

On the record

Called Shots →
Held upJul 26, 2026

Neither Willy Adames nor Matt Chapman is traded by the August 3, 2026 deadline.

Resolved 2026-08-03: CORRECT. Neither was traded. Both Willy Adames and Matt Chapman remain on San Francisco's 40-man roster, verified at the club's live roster feed. Scored 2026-08-05 by CP against the league's official transaction feed for teamId 137 (statsapi.mlb.com/api/v1/transactions, 08/02-08/04) and the club's live 40-man roster. Two days late, and the lateness is the desk's, not the writer's: the site published nothing from 2026-08-02 through 2026-08-04 and nobody scored the ledger on the night it resolved. The five deadline trades of record: Mahle to Atlanta for Anthony Molina (Aug 2); Arraez and Caleb Kilian to Philadelphia for Marty Gair and Ramon Marquez; Erik Miller and Carlos Gutierrez to Boston for Marcelo Mayer; Robbie Ray to San Diego for Miguel Mendez and Joniel Hernandez; Heliot Ramos to the Yankees for Henry Lalane and Kaeden Kent (all Aug 3). PRIOR NOTE FOLLOWS. Both hold full no-trade clauses and both are producing below league average, Adames at a 93 wRC+ with 0.1 fWAR and Chapman at 95. Negative surplus value plus an absolute player veto is what makes a contract immovable rather than merely expensive. The Giants were reported in June as open to offers on both, which is what makes this falsifiable rather than obvious.

Latest on the Giants

The whole beat →
Four pitchers would cost the Giants no draft pick, and the youngest is 30
The 2027 Giants

Four pitchers would cost the Giants no draft pick, and the youngest is 30

Freddy Peralta, Clay Holmes, Kevin Gausman and Robbie Ray changed clubs at the deadline, so signing any of them costs the Giants no draft pick; they are 30 to 35, and two walked batters at a higher rate than the Giants' staff, sixth-highest in the majors. The four lower-walk arms can carry a qualifying offer, and their clubs decide by Monday, Nov. 2, the same day the Giants must cut their 40-man roster by 11.

Andie TownsendOct 30, 20265 min read
The Giants' farm had the best record in baseball. Promotions decided who rose
The 2027 Giants

The Giants' farm had the best record in baseball. Promotions decided who rose

The Giants' seven minor league affiliates combined for a 413-303 record and a run differential of plus 540, the best of any organization, and MLB Pipeline named San Francisco its Farm System of the Year. A team record does not say which prospects rose. A promotion does, because the new level's pitchers have not seen the hitter and the rate either holds or it does not. Jhonny Level, 19, kept his strikeout rate under 19 percent after moving to High-A Eugene. Josuar Gonzalez hit better at Single-A than he had in the complex league and climbed from 15th to 7th on Pipeline's Top 100. Gavin Kilen, Trevor Cohen and Dakota Jordan all reached Double-A Richmond on July 17; Kilen's .812 OPS did not move, Cohen's walk rate fell by half and Jordan's power disappeared in 88 plate appearances. Bo Davidson improved after his promotion to Triple-A and reached the majors. Joe Whitman's strikeout rate fell from 33 percent to 19 after his.

Andie TownsendOct 16, 20267 min read
Randy Rodríguez's last pitch left the park. On Tuesday he threw the next one
Randy Rodríguez

Randy Rodríguez's last pitch left the park. On Tuesday he threw the next one

Randy Rodríguez, signed by the Giants out of Santo Domingo on July 2, 2017, became a National League All-Star in 2025 with a 1.78 earned run average over 50 games. His last pitch that season was a slider William Contreras hit for a walk-off home run in Milwaukee on August 22. He had Tommy John surgery on September 24, 2025, and on October 13, 2026 he threw a scoreless first inning for the Scottsdale Scorpions at Scottsdale Stadium, his first game at any level in 417 days.

Posey ThompsonOct 14, 20268 min read

Earlier on the Giants

Tidwell is the fourth young Giants starter sent for elbow surgery since March
Four of four

Tidwell is the fourth young Giants starter sent for elbow surgery since March

The Giants placed Blade Tidwell on the 15-day injured list on September 22 and recalled Braxton Roxby from Sacramento. Tidwell left his start against Minnesota on September 21 in the fourth inning with right elbow discomfort; an MRI showed what the club's injury page calls a moderate to high-grade UCL sprain, and team orthopedist Dr. Kenneth Akizuki recommended surgery. The page lists his expected return as 2028. He is the fourth starter on the club to reach that ligament in 2026, after Hayden Birdsong (Tommy John surgery March 25), Trevor McDonald (August 5) and Carson Whisenhunt (September 16). All four are 25 and were born within 314 days of each other. The club's own expected-return column reads 2027 for Birdsong, late 2027 or 2028 for McDonald, and 2028 for Whisenhunt and Tidwell. The same day, Landen Roupp was shut down healthy at a career-high 155 innings. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 23, 20264 min read
At the All-Star break, the Giants' winter regrades to a D+. Only Arraez went up
Free Agent Regrade

At the All-Star break, the Giants' winter regrades to a D+. Only Arraez went up

The mid-season regrade of the sixteen 2025-26 Giants signings, as of the All-Star break on July 14, 2026, off each player's line through that date and nothing later. Arraez, an All-Star at .330/.369/.460 through 402 plate appearances, moves from a B+ to an A. Bader, at .170 in 111 plate appearances and on the injured list, moves from an A- to a D. Houser is a C-, Mahle a D+, Kilian a B-, Hentges a B-. Brennan, Oliva, Ramos and Kennedy, all off the 40-man by the break, are D-minuses. Knizner, signed in August, has no mid-season grade. The class, a C+ at opening day, regrades to a D+. The season-end regrade follows September 27.

Andie TownsendSep 22, 20268 min read
Cesar Perdomo Gave Up Three Singles And A Walk In His First Major League Start
Twenty Men

Cesar Perdomo Gave Up Three Singles And A Walk In His First Major League Start

Cesar Perdomo made his first major league start at Citi Field on September 6, five days after his major league debut, and pitched six scoreless innings against the New York Mets. He faced twenty batters, allowed three singles and one walk, struck out four and threw 83 pitches, 48 of them for strikes. No New York runner reached second base against him. Joel Kuhnel pitched a scoreless seventh. Carson Seymour then allowed four earned runs on sixteen pitches in the eighth, on a solo home run by Brett Baty and a three-run home run by Bo Bichette, and San Francisco lost 4-2 in front of 29,410. The Giants scored both their runs in the fourth on a Jung Hoo Lee single and finished with five hits and twelve strikeouts. Perdomo is the thirteenth different pitcher to start a game for San Francisco in 2026, which resolves an open Andie Townsend call filed August 21, and his start resolves a Grant Lombard call filed September 2. Perdomo's career major league line is now ten innings, six hits, one earned run, two walks and eight strikeouts. His 2026 was worse at every stop before this: a 3.98 earned run average at Double-A Richmond and a 5.10 mark with twenty walks at Triple-A Sacramento. He has thrown 130 innings this year against a previous career high of 127 and a third. Two takes filed.

Grant LombardSep 7, 20265 min read