Draft Regrade · NFC East

New York Giants

10 drafts, 76 picks. Class ranks are after Week 9, 2026.

2026 draft

8thof 32 classes39pointsB+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2026 draft

0 stars 2 good starters 0 average starters 5 depth 0 busts

  1. 5Rd 1Arvell ReeseLB · Ohio StateB13pointsgood starter18thin a redraft
  2. 10Rd 1Francis MauigoaOT · MiamiC5pointsdepth63rdin a redraft
  3. 37Rd 2Colton HoodCB · TennesseeC-2pointsdepth103rdin a redraft
  4. 74Rd 3Malachi FieldsWR · Notre DameA-16pointsgood starter9thin a redraft
  5. 186Rd 6Bobby Jamison-TravisDT · AuburnA-3pointsdepth89thin a redraft
  6. 192Rd 6J.C. DavisOT · IllinoisB-0pointsdepth154thin a redraft
  7. 193Rd 6Jack KellyLB · BYUB-0pointsdepth187thin a redraft

B+ on draft weekend. Two top-five board players at 5 and 10 on a pick the Lawrence trade created, then three picks spent on one receiver two graders did not rate. The whole grade, and why

2025 draft

6thof 32 classes103pointsB+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2025 draft

1 star 0 good starters 3 average starters 3 depth 0 busts

  1. 3Rd 1Abdul CarterEDGE · Penn StateA+54pointsstar2ndin a redraft
  2. 25Rd 1Jaxson DartQB · Ole MissC+22pointsaverage starter24thin a redraft
  3. 65Rd 3Darius AlexanderDT · ToledoB12pointsaverage starter74thin a redraft
  4. 105Rd 4Cam SkatteboRB · Arizona StateB-10pointsaverage starter83rdin a redraft
  5. 154Rd 5Marcus MbowOG · PurdueB-3pointsdepth153rdin a redraft
  6. 219Rd 7Thomas Fidone IITE · NebraskaA-0pointsdepth201stin a redraft
  7. 246Rd 7Korie BlackCB · Oklahoma StateB-2pointsdepth174thin a redraft

B+ on draft weekend. The best defender in the draft at three, then a second-round pick and two thirds spent on the quarterback the graders split over. The whole grade, and why

2024 draft

11thof 32 classes137pointsBon draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2024 draft

1 star 2 good starters 1 average starter 2 depth 0 busts

  1. 6Rd 1Malik NabersWR · LSUA56pointsstar8thin a redraft
  2. 47Rd 2Tyler NubinS · MinnesotaD+12pointsdepth98thin a redraft
  3. 70Rd 3Andru PhillipsCB · KentuckyA41pointsgood starter21stin a redraft
  4. 107Rd 4Theo JohnsonTE · Penn StateB-12pointsaverage starter102ndin a redraft
  5. 166Rd 5Tyrone Tracy Jr.RB · PurdueA-11pointsgood starter106thin a redraft
  6. 183Rd 6Darius MuasauLB · UCLAA-5pointsdepth129thin a redraft

B on draft weekend. The receiver the roster lacked and the top safety on two boards, with the quarterback left for later. The whole grade, and why

2023 draft

28thof 32 classes55pointsB+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2023 draft

0 stars 1 good starter 1 average starter 3 depth 1 bust

  1. 24Rd 1Deonte BanksCB · MarylandB-24pointsgood starter73rdin a redraft
  2. 57Rd 2John Michael SchmitzC · MinnesotaC-10pointsaverage starter119thin a redraft
  3. 73Rd 3Jalin HyattWR · TennesseeB-13pointsdepth105thin a redraft
  4. 172Rd 5Eric GrayRB · OklahomaC-0pointsdepth206thin a redraft
  5. 209Rd 6Tre Hawkins IIICB · Old DominionC-5pointsbust151stin a redraft
  6. 243Rd 7Jordon RileyDT · OregonA-3pointsdepth167thin a redraft
  7. 254Rd 7Gervarrius OwensS · HoustonB-0pointsnot yettied 247thin a redraft

B+ on draft weekend. Corner, center and receiver with the first three picks, bought with two trades up. The whole grade, and why

2022 draft

6thof 32 classes242pointsA-on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2022 draft

0 stars 4 good starters 1 average starter 3 depth 3 busts

  1. 5Rd 1Kayvon ThibodeauxDE · OregonB71pointsgood starter17thin a redraft
  2. 7Rd 1Evan NealOT · AlabamaD9pointsbust144thin a redraft
  3. 43Rd 2Wan'Dale RobinsonWR · KentuckyA-57pointsgood starter30thin a redraft
  4. 67Rd 3Joshua EzeuduOG · North CarolinaB-6pointsdepth160thin a redraft
  5. 81Rd 3Cordale FlottCB · LSUB41pointsaverage starter51stin a redraft
  6. 112Rd 4Daniel BellingerTE · San Diego StateB19pointsgood starter105thin a redraft
  7. 114Rd 4Dane BeltonS · IowaA+17pointsgood starter112thin a redraft
  8. 146Rd 5Micah McFaddenILB · IndianaB-13pointsdepth128thin a redraft
  9. 147Rd 5D.J. DavidsonDT · Arizona StateB8pointsdepth145thin a redraft
  10. 173Rd 5Marcus McKethanOG · North CarolinaD+1pointbust212thin a redraft
  11. 182Rd 6Darrian BeaversILB · CincinnatiC-0pointsbusttied 253rdin a redraft

A- on draft weekend. Two top-seven picks on the two top needs, extra picks from trading down, and a reach at 43. The whole grade, and why

2021 draft

32ndof 32 classes53pointsA-on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2021 draft

0 stars 0 good starters 0 average starters 1 depth 5 busts

  1. 20Rd 1Kadarius ToneyWR · FloridaD-17pointsbust103rdin a redraft
  2. 50Rd 2Azeez OjulariOLB · GeorgiaC+27pointsdepth82ndin a redraft
  3. 71Rd 3Aaron RobinsonCB · UCFF4pointsbust156thin a redraft
  4. 116Rd 4Elerson SmithOLB · Northern IowaC-2pointsbust180thin a redraft
  5. 196Rd 6Gary BrightwellRB · ArizonaC-1pointbust196thin a redraft
  6. 201Rd 6Rodarius WilliamsCB · Oklahoma StateB-2pointsbust184thin a redraft

A- on draft weekend. Two trades down added a 2022 first and third, and Ojulari met the edge need, at the price of a reach at 20. The whole grade, and why

2020 draft

11thof 32 classes183pointsB+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2020 draft

1 star 1 good starter 0 average starters 2 depth 6 busts

  1. 4Rd 1Andrew ThomasOT · GeorgiaB82pointsgood starter20thin a redraft
  2. 36Rd 2Xavier McKinneyS · AlabamaA67pointsstar24thin a redraft
  3. 99Rd 3Matt PeartOT · UConnB-8pointsdepth148thin a redraft
  4. 110Rd 4Darnay HolmesCB · UCLAB+15pointsdepth119thin a redraft
  5. 150Rd 5Shane LemieuxOG · OregonB3pointsbust185thin a redraft
  6. 183Rd 6Cam BrownOLB · Penn StateB-1pointbust206thin a redraft
  7. 218Rd 7Carter CoughlinOLB · MinnesotaB+2pointsbust194thin a redraft
  8. 238Rd 7TJ BrunsonILB · South CarolinaB-0pointsbust238thin a redraft
  9. 247Rd 7Chris WilliamsonCB · MinnesotaB-0pointsbust227thin a redraft
  10. 255Rd 7Tae CrowderILB · GeorgiaB-5pointsbust168thin a redraft

B+ on draft weekend. The line need met at four with the top tackle on PFF's board, and value found at 36 without a trade. The whole grade, and why

2019 draft

4thof 32 classes439pointsC+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2019 draft

2 stars 0 good starters 1 average starter 2 depth 5 busts

  1. 6Rd 1Daniel JonesQB · DukeB-116pointsdepth15thin a redraft
  2. 17Rd 1Dexter LawrenceDT · ClemsonA+156pointsstar6thin a redraft
  3. 30Rd 1Deandre BakerCB · GeorgiaD9pointsbust144thin a redraft
  4. 95Rd 3Oshane XiminesDE · Old DominionC+23pointsbust91stin a redraft
  5. 108Rd 4Julian LoveCB · Notre DameA52pointsstar42ndin a redraft
  6. 143Rd 5Ryan ConnellyILB · WisconsinB-2pointsbust184thin a redraft
  7. 171Rd 5Darius SlaytonWR · AuburnA75pointsaverage starter26thin a redraft
  8. 180Rd 6Corey BallentineCB · WashburnB+6pointsdepth152ndin a redraft
  9. 232Rd 7George Asafo-AdjeiOG · KentuckyB-0pointsbusttied 230thin a redraft
  10. 245Rd 7Chris SlaytonDT · SyracuseB-0pointsbusttied 230thin a redraft

C+ on draft weekend. Rich capital and three first-rounders, with the heaviest pick spent on a quarterback most graders thought went too early. The whole grade, and why

2018 draft

19thof 32 classes302pointsBon draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2018 draft

0 stars 1 good starter 1 average starter 1 depth 3 busts

  1. 2Rd 1Saquon BarkleyRB · Penn StateD+68pointsaverage starter44thin a redraft
  2. 34Rd 2Will HernandezOG · UTEPB-50pointsdepth67thin a redraft
  3. 66Rd 3Lorenzo CarterOLB · GeorgiaC+66pointsbust45thin a redraft
  4. 69Rd 3B.J. HillDT · NC StateA-115pointsgood starter10thin a redraft
  5. 108Rd 4Kyle LaulettaQB · RichmondD0pointsbust222ndin a redraft
  6. 139Rd 5RJ McIntoshDT · MiamiC-3pointsbust185thin a redraft

B on draft weekend. The best player on many boards at 2, at a position the graders argued about, and the guard need met at 34. The whole grade, and why

2017 draft

18thof 32 classes205pointsC+on draft weekend

After Week 9, 2026. The whole 2017 draft

0 stars 0 good starters 2 average starters 0 depth 4 busts

  1. 23Rd 1Evan EngramTE · Ole MissB+50pointsaverage starter59thin a redraft
  2. 55Rd 2Dalvin TomlinsonDT · AlabamaA+134pointsaverage starter9thin a redraft
  3. 87Rd 3Davis WebbQB · CaliforniaB-0pointsbust201stin a redraft
  4. 140Rd 4Wayne GallmanRB · ClemsonA-13pointsbust126thin a redraft
  5. 167Rd 5Avery MossDE · Youngstown StateC-8pointsbust144thin a redraft
  6. 200Rd 6Adam BisnowatyOG · PittsburghC-0pointsbust202ndin a redraft

C+ on draft weekend. A tight end in the first round, and the offensive tackle the roster needed most left for the sixth. The whole grade, and why